Contents:

Free Python Course ➞ Mini-course for beginners and for Experienced coders. 4 cool projects in the portfolio, live communication with the speaker. Click and find out what you can learn on the course.
Learn moreRussian jurisprudence in the field of copyright on software code is not abundant in landmark cases. However, against this background, a recent case that reached the Constitutional Court stands out. This precedent may have a significant impact on the development of legislation in the field of software copyright protection in Russia.
The essence of the dispute
From 2012 to 2016, Anton Mamichev held the position of Head of the Information Resources Development Department at Intervim LLC, a subsidiary of Veeam Software AG. While his responsibilities did not include programming, he successfully managed the development and implementation of information systems, which contributed to the company's growth and improved the quality of services provided.
In his free time, Mamichev worked on his own project—the eLearning Metadata Manager (eMM) learning management system. This tool is designed for developing training materials using the ADDIE (Analysis, Design, Development, Implementation, Evaluation) model. Anton wrote over 30,000 lines of code for this project, but he did not develop a boxed version of the program. eMM offers unique opportunities for educational institutions and companies seeking to improve the learning process and enhance the quality of educational materials.

In October 2016, Mamichev decided to leave the company "Intervim" offered his former employer a contract for the use of eMM under a simple (non-exclusive) license with restrictions on commercial use. His offer was initially accepted, but the process of signing the contract dragged on. Immediately before his dismissal, Anton transferred the program from a rented server to his employer's server.
From this point on, conflicts arose: according to Mamichev, his unsuccessful partners soon began to misuse eMM, and then even claimed that it was a work for hire, and he had no right to any copyright.
Negotiations of varying degrees of tension continued for more than eight months, and in June 2017, Intervim concluded them by removing the line "© 2012-2017 Anton Mamichev" from the program's source code. This action violated copyright, which, according to Mamichev, is a gross violation of Article 1300 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.
Rise, the court is in session!
In January 2018, Anton Mamichev filed a lawsuit in the Primorsky District Court of St. Petersburg against Intervim and Viam Software Group GmbH. In his lawsuit, he demanded recognition of the copyright to the eMM software, as well as the right to the name and exclusive rights to this program. The case attracted public attention because it concerned intellectual property and the protection of the rights of software developers.
The plaintiff demanded compensation for damages.
- 1,996,000 rubles from each of the defendants for deleting information about the author and reproducing the program without the author's name;
- 2,994,000 rubles jointly and severally from both defendants for violating the terms of use (illegal reproduction of the program);
- 17,638,200 rubles from Viam Software Group GmbH for illegally providing access to the program on the server api.veeamuniversity.com;
- 2,994,000 rubles jointly and severally from both defendants for illegal processing (modification) of the program.
Mamichev put forward non-property claims, insisting on prohibiting the use of eMM without his consent. This includes any actions such as reproducing, modifying, or making it available on a server. He also demanded that Wiam Software Group GmbH publish the court decision online, listing him as the author and copyright holder of the program. These demands highlight the importance of protecting intellectual property and upholding copyright in the software industry.
The trial court conducted a computer-based forensic examination and issued a decision. The results of the examination formed the basis for the final verdict, which determined further action in the case. This confirms the importance of using modern technology in legal proceedings, which allows for a more accurate assessment of the facts and circumstances of the case.
- The program in question is a cloud service.
- When creating it, the author used library files, most of which are distributed under free licenses, including the GNU GPL v2. Their further distribution is possible only under the same license.
- The plaintiff did not distribute copies of his program, so the rights of the authors of the library files were not violated.
In June 2019, the Primorsky District Court upheld most of Mamichev's claims. The court recognized him as the author of the eMM program and the owner of exclusive rights to it. The defendants were ordered to pay compensation in the amount of approximately 23 million rubles and were prohibited from further use of this program. This decision was an important step in protecting copyright in the software industry.
Not Everything Is So Clear-cut
The original trial generated significant media attention, both due to the notoriety of the defendants and the impressive amount of compensation. This case attracted public attention and became a subject of discussion in legal circles, raising important questions about the fairness and consequences of such cases.
The story continued in January 2020, when the appellate court, namely the St. Petersburg City Court, overturned the decision of the trial court. The court ruled to dismiss Mamichev's claim, which became an important turning point in this case.
Expert assessments this time were completely opposite:
- eMM's status as a cloud service was removed.
- The disputed program was recognized as "boxed" - that is, intended for installation on the buyer's server. Accordingly, payment could be made only for the right to use the program, without additional costs for computing resources, communication channels, and so on.
- eMM was also recognized as a composite work, including library files, without which the service would simply be inoperable.
In accordance with these findings, the appellate court concluded that Mamichev was not an injured party. On the contrary, he had grossly violated the rights of the authors of the libraries used in his project. The court based its decision on relevant legal provisions.
A translator, compiler, or other author of a derivative or composite work has the right to exercise their copyright, provided that the rights of the authors of the original works used to create the new work are respected. This means that for the legal use of materials, the copyrights of the original authors must be considered and respected. Respect for these rights is essential for protecting intellectual property and ensuring the fair use of creative works.
Clause 3 of Article 1260 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation establishes important provisions regarding copyright. This clause regulates issues related to the use of works and defines the rights and obligations of the parties involved in the process of creating and distributing copyrighted objects. A key aspect is the protection of the rights of authors, which allows them to control the use of their works and receive remuneration for their work. Proper understanding and application of the provisions of this clause is necessary to ensure the legality of intellectual property and protect the interests of authors and copyright holders.
The author, of course, tried to express his dissatisfaction, arguing that his work cannot be classified as a composite work. He noted that his project contains 30,000 lines of unique code and wondered whether his work could then be considered "the result of a creative selection or arrangement of materials." This dispute raises important questions about the nature of copyright and originality in programming. It is important to consider that even large volumes of code may contain elements that are not completely unique, and this may affect the legal status of the work.
The court ignored this and other reasonable arguments. The library authors did not file any claims against Mamichev, but the vague wording of paragraph 3 of Article 1260 of the Civil Code effectively limited his right to judicial protection. This raises serious questions about the fairness of law enforcement and the need to clarify the legislation to protect the interests of authors.
In August 2020, the plaintiff filed a cassation appeal, but the court, without delving into the details of the case, upheld the appellate decision. Mamichev attempted to review the dispute in the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation from November 2020 to April 2021, but all his efforts were futile. At that point, there was only one option left for further action.
Long live the Constitution!
In December 2021, Mamichev filed a complaint with the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, requesting a review of paragraph 3 of Article 1260 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation for compliance with the Constitution.
The complaint is based on the inadmissibility of releasing violators from liability, as well as the inadmissibility of refusing to protect the rights to parts of the software created by the author himself. It is important to note that it is impossible to establish a violation of the rights of third parties in a situation where these parties do not initiate legal action. Copyright protection is a key aspect in the field of intellectual property, and any attempts to evade liability must be carefully considered.
The Kachkin & Partners Law Firm provides professional legal services and protects the interests of plaintiffs. Our team of experts has extensive experience in various areas of law, allowing us to effectively represent clients in court and beyond. We understand the importance of a personalized approach to each case and strive to achieve the best possible results for our clients. By contacting Kachkin & Partners Law Firm, you can be assured of high-quality protection of your rights and legitimate interests.
The Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation supported Mamichev's position. The court stated that refusing to protect the rights of a program author is unacceptable if the sole basis is the work's status as a composite. Furthermore, the court noted that the violation of third-party rights cannot serve as grounds for depriving the author of their rights. These findings underscore the importance of upholding copyright in the software industry and the need to consider the interests of authors when considering such cases.
In addition to the Constitution, the court also drew attention to Article 2, paragraph 3, of the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works. This paragraph establishes that translations, adaptations, musical arrangements, and other adaptations of literary or artistic works have the same degree of protection as the originals. Thus, copyright extends not only to the original works, but also to their derivative versions, which emphasizes the importance of protecting intellectual property in the field of culture and art.
In its decision, the court presented the following arguments:
- Copyright to computer programs (including the right of authorship, the right to a name, and the exclusive right) arises for the author from the moment the program is created.
- This procedure for the emergence of copyright, according to Part 1 of Article 44 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, applies to all computer programs, including composite works.
- The creation of a composite work in itself does not deprive the authors of the libraries used to create it of any rights.
- The principle of optionality underlies civil law and the process - the authors of works themselves determine whether to protect their violated right or not.
- The refusal of the appellate court to protect Mamichev's copyright contradicts the constitutional requirements of fairness and proportionality arising from Part 3 of Article 17, Parts 1–2 of Article 19, Part 3 of Article 55 of the Constitution.
- This leads to an unjustified protection of the interests of the defendants who have actually violated the copyright of the disputed program.
The result was clear and uncompromising.
Clause 3 of Article 1260 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation is not consistent with the Constitution of the Russian Federation. It violates Articles 17 (Part 3), 19 (Parts 1 and 2), 34 (Part 1), 44 (Part 1), 45 (Part 1), 46 (Part 1) and 55 (Part 3), since, within the framework of current legal regulation, it allows the court to refuse to protect the copyright of the creator of a computer program. This occurs in cases where a dispute arises with a person using this program without the consent of the author, and the court bases its decision solely on the fact that the program is a composite work. Moreover, the author failed to comply with the conditions for respecting the rights of authors (copyright holders) of the objects used to create the program, which is especially relevant when the defendant also does not have the necessary rights to use such objects. This creates legal risks for authors and complicates the protection of their intellectual property rights.
The Ruling of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation of June 16, 2022, No. 25-P, is of significant importance for law enforcement practice and the protection of citizens' constitutional rights. This ruling examines key aspects related to the observance of human rights and freedoms, as well as the mechanisms for their protection within the framework of current legislation. The court analyzed specific cases in which questions of compliance with constitutional norms arose, underscoring the significance of this act for the country's legal system. The ruling serves as an important guide for courts and human rights activists, establishing precedents and interpretations that may influence future decisions in similar cases. Thus, Resolution 25-P is a significant step in strengthening the rule of law and ensuring respect for citizens' rights in Russia.
Mamichev as a Mirror of Copyright
The specific nature of the case and the essence of a judicial error lie in the fact that judicial decisions can be based on incorrect facts, insufficient analysis of evidence, or misinterpretation of legal norms. A judicial error can lead to unfair decisions, which, in turn, undermines trust in the judicial system. It is important to understand that such an error can occur both at the stage of case consideration and during the appeal process. Ensuring justice requires continuous analysis and improvement of procedures to minimize the likelihood of judicial errors and protect the rights of citizens. Thus, the study of judicial errors and their consequences is an important task for lawyers and human rights activists.
The appellate court unlawfully compared the creative work of the program's author with the work of the compiler, who is responsible for the original selection and arrangement of materials. This decision calls into question the uniqueness and creative nature of software development, which could negatively impact copyright protection in this area.
The trial completely ignored the defendants' alleged copyright infringement. The author, however, was deprived of the opportunity to protect his rights solely because of the alleged infringement of the rights of other authors related to the development of free software. This creates serious precedents in the field of intellectual property protection and calls into question the fairness of court decisions in such cases.
Mamichev claims that he did not infringe copyright. He developed his program using free software licensed under the GNU GPL v2, but never distributed the program itself.

The study of modern technologies and their impact on human life is becoming increasingly relevant. It is important to understand how new developments change our everyday experience and what opportunities they open up. Technologies not only simplify the performance of tasks but also contribute to the development of new skills and professional horizons. It's important to stay up-to-date with the latest trends to stay informed and adapt to changes. Continuous learning and self-improvement in technology will help you stay competitive in the job market and open up new opportunities. Read also:
A Guide to Free GNU Licenses: What They Are and What Types Exist
Free GNU licenses are legal instruments that allow users to freely use, modify, and distribute software. The main goal of these licenses is to ensure freedom for users by allowing them to control the use and development of software products.
There are several types of free GNU licenses, each with its own characteristics. The most well-known is the GNU General Public License (GPL), which guarantees users the right to study, modify, and distribute software. This license requires that any derivative works be released under the GPL, thereby ensuring that freedom remains for all users.
Another popular license is the GNU Lesser General Public License (LGPL), which provides more flexibility to developers by allowing them to use a library in their projects without requiring all software to be licensed under the GPL.
An important aspect of free licenses is that they promote the development of open source software and the communities around it. Users can not only use ready-made solutions but also make modifications, improving products and sharing their developments with others.
Thus, free licenses from GNU play a key role in the software world, ensuring user freedom and fostering innovation.
Transferring a program from Mamichev's server to an employer's server is not considered its distribution. This is due to the nature of the program as an intangible object. Thus, the GNU GPL v2 requirements for distributing the program under the same terms were not violated by the author.
The free software authors involved in Anton Mamichev's development did not request protection of their rights.
The appellate court erred in interpreting paragraph 3 of Article 1260 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, considering it outside the context of other provisions of this article and the norms of the Civil Code, as well as the Constitution and international agreements regarding copyright. These aspects became key for the attention of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation.
The Intellectual Property Court, as a rule, supports the authors of composite and derivative works, without linking their rights with the copyright of the original works. This position is consistent with current legislation and protects the interests of creators of new works. This allows authors to confidently develop their ideas, building on existing creations, which contributes to cultural and intellectual progress.
Now this practice will also apply to software developers using free software. They will no longer need to confirm the legality of using third-party products to protect their copyrights. This is quite reasonable, given that many modern software products, such as MS Windows, Android, Google Chrome, and Mozilla Firefox, are either entirely based on free software or integrate individual free components. This approach simplifies the development process and promotes more active use of free software in the industry.
However, the question of which programs should be classified as derivatives and composites remains open. This decision must be made by the legislator.
Immersion in the world of reading brings many benefits. Reading develops thinking, improves vocabulary, and broadens horizons. Regularly reading books, articles, and other materials contributes to the development of critical thinking and the ability to analyze information. Reading also helps improve concentration and attention, which is essential in today's distraction-filled world. To get the most out of your reading, choose a variety of genres and topics that interest you. This will not only enrich your knowledge but also make the process more engaging. Don't forget to share your thoughts on what you've read by discussing books with friends or in online communities. Reading is not only a way to learn new things, but also an opportunity to enjoy deep emotions and experiences that can change your perception of life.
- How to protect a computer program from a legal point of view
- "Before joining IT, I worked as a forensic scientist in the police"
- What is MVC: patterns, basic concepts, and an example application

