Code

Copyright Case Law: Rambler & Lynwood vs. Sysoev & Nginx

Copyright Case Law: Rambler & Lynwood vs. Sysoev & Nginx

Free course: “Quick start in Python”

Learn more

You created code. Who is its author? Don't rush to answer: the situation is not that simple. Much depends on the context in which you wrote it. If the code was written at work on assignment from management, then the copyright to it belongs to your employer, according to Russian law. This is a work for hire, and exclusive rights transfer to the organization that hired you. It is important to understand that even if you developed the code yourself, its use and rights to it may be regulated by an employment contract or internal corporate rules.

Don't be upset. Sometimes IT specialists succeed and regain the rights to their developments from their previous employers, which allows them to independently manage the results of their work. A striking example is the story of Rambler system administrator Igor Sysoev, who defended his rights to his own brainchild and now enjoys commercial success.

Background

In the early 2000s, driven by a deep interest, Igor Sysoev began scaling web server capabilities. His goal was to create an efficient and high-performance solution capable of handling a large number of simultaneous requests. This work became the foundation for the further development of web hosting technologies and had a significant impact on the industry. Sysoev's innovations have significantly improved the performance and stability of web services, making them more accessible to users around the world.

Igor Sysoev (right), F5 Networks CEO Gus Robertson, Nginx co-founders Andrey Alekseev and Maxim KonovalovPhoto: Nginx

At the time of its inception, the most common web server was Apache, which was limited to serving no more than a thousand simultaneously connected users. Instead of the traditional approach of scaling by increasing the number of servers, as most companies did, Igor Sysoev chose the path of developing a more efficient web server. After two years of hard work, he introduced Nginx. This server proved so effective that the owners of the Zvuki.Ru website decided to take a risk and implement even its preliminary, unfinished version. Nginx quickly gained popularity due to its high performance and ability to handle a large number of connections, making it one of the leaders in the web server market.

Initially, the Nginx project was developed as a non-commercial solution based on the free 2-Clause BSD License, which allowed anyone to use it. The web server quickly gained popularity, and by 2007 its market share reached 4% without any advertising efforts. Four years later, when Nginx's market share had doubled, Maxim Konovalov and Andrey Alekseev from Comstar-OTS joined the team and decided to monetize their success. Thus, the Nginx legal entity was founded and a commercial version of the server, called Nginx Plus, was released. Nginx became a significant player in the web server market, offering high performance and stability for various web applications. Nginx's monetization was successful: in March 2019, its market share in various internet segments reached 40-50%. As a result, the company was acquired by the American company F5 Networks for $670 million. This deal was a significant technological achievement and increased interest in Nginx products, which undoubtedly had a positive impact on the income of system administration specialists.

But then Rambler intervened

The success of Sysoev and Konovalov caused significant discontent among their previous employers.

On December 4, 2019, at the initiative of Rambler Group, the Main Directorate of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia for Moscow opened a criminal case under Part 3 of Article 146 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, concerning the infringement of copyright and related rights. This case highlights the importance of protecting intellectual property in the digital age and the need to respect the rights of authors and copyright holders.

On December 12, 2019, searches were conducted at the Moscow office of Nginx. Sysoev and Konovalov were detained and questioned, but no charges were brought against them. These events attracted public attention and sparked discussions about the legal aspects of IT companies in Russia.

The case materials indicate that the Nginx server was developed by unidentified individuals during work hours on behalf of management. After development was completed, the program was allegedly distributed free of charge and without restrictions online. In July 2011, exclusive rights to the program were transferred to Nginx. These actions were deemed illegal and became the basis for criminal proceedings.

The Rambler Group press service confirmed that the rights to Nginx are owned by a group division known as Rambler Internet Holding. This statement underscores the importance of Nginx in the Rambler ecosystem and its role in providing high-quality internet services. Nginx, a popular web server and reverse proxy, continues to develop under the management of Rambler Internet Holding, opening up new opportunities to improve the performance and functionality of web solutions.

Igor Ashmanov, former executive director of Rambler Group, disagrees with this point of view. He emphasizes that Igor Sysoev, like many other Rambler employees at the time, joined the company with his own open-source project, which was trending. Open-source developments were very popular at the time and contributed to the development of innovative technologies in various fields.

During the investigation, investigators sought to establish evidence that Rambler management gave Sysoev instructions, both verbal and written, to develop Nginx. However, such evidence was not found: neither his employment contract nor his system administrator job description mentioned the need to create any web products. There was also no indication that he should be involved in programming. Moreover, there was no mention of such important aspects as accounting for Nginx as an intangible asset or its role in the company's share placement.

The first chairman of the board of directors of Rambler Internet Holding LLC, Sergey Vasiliev, who held this position from 1999 to 2004, as well as his immediate supervisor, Andrey Kopeyko, confirmed the lack of connection between Rambler and Nginx. Kopeyko was questioned for 10 hours, which underscores the importance of this issue.

Leading industry representatives, including Yandex top manager Grigory Bakunov, Ontiko CEO Oleg Bunin, as well as MTS, Odnoklassniki, the ReactOS Foundation, and the team of Okko, which is part of Rambler, spoke out in support of Nginx. The following day, an extraordinary meeting of Rambler's board of directors was held, at which it was decided to drop the claims against Nginx and petition for the criminal case to be dismissed. German Gref played a key role in this process: in June 2019, Sber acquired 46.5% of Rambler Group shares, and none of the executives notified him of their intentions to initiate legal proceedings against Nginx. This event underscores the importance of support from major market players in protecting the interests of technologies like Nginx. Four months later, Rambler Group filed a petition, and on May 18, 2020, the criminal case was dismissed. The reason for the termination was the lack of a criminal offense.

The plaintiff did not calm down, but was calmed down

After filing the petition, Rambler Group management decided to terminate the contract with the Cypriot company Lynwood Investments, which represented its interests in the lawsuit. However, on June 8, 2020, Lynwood Investments filed a civil lawsuit against F5 Networks, Sysoev, Konovalov, and several other former Rambler employees in the United States District Court of San Francisco. The venture capital funds Runa Capital and E.ventures were also among the defendants. This case has drawn attention to the legal aspects of interactions between companies and their former employees, as well as issues of liability in business.

Lynwood filed a lawsuit seeking recognition as the legal owner of the intellectual property and related rights to Nginx. The total amount claimed is $750 million.

Igor Sysoev and Maxim Konovalov, in collaboration with their accomplices, illegally removed the popular Nginx web server from Rambler in Russia. This software was developed and implemented during their employment at this company.

From the Statement of Claim

This Statement of Claim sets out the main circumstances of the case, on the basis of which the plaintiff seeks protection of its rights and legitimate interests. The statement of claim contains a reference to the facts confirming the existence of the dispute, as well as references to the relevant legal provisions. The plaintiff asks the court to consider the case and make a decision that will ensure the restoration of violated rights. It is important to note that the Statement of Claim must contain clear and reasonable demands, which will allow the court to make a fair decision. When preparing a claim, it is necessary to consider all evidence and documents supporting the plaintiff's position, as well as to comply with the deadlines for filing a claim. Properly drafting a claim is a key step in litigation and affects the outcome of the case.

Lynwood alleged that Nginx developers intentionally concealed the true value of their product from Rambler in order to attract a buyer in the United States. The lawsuit also states that investors Runa Capital and E.ventures, as well as F5 Networks, were aware of the crime and assisted in the conspiracy.

According to the plaintiff, Alexander Korotkov, who served as IT Director at Rambler from 2007 to 2009, acted as an intermediary in the theft. Korotkov is alleged to have established a connection between Nginx developers and venture funds, which was intended to facilitate the legitimization of the paid product Nginx Enterprise, based on the allegedly stolen intellectual property. After moving to Silicon Valley, Korotkov registered the domain nginxplus.com and the trademark in his own name.

According to the lawsuit, Rambler learned of the Nginx developers' commercial activities and the trademark registration only in 2019. However, the first actual use of this trademark dates back to no later than March 1, 2011.

The lawsuit further details an alleged conspiracy among former Rambler employees who allegedly attempted to conceal the product's true value. This conspiracy allegedly involved the investment funds Runa Capital and E.ventures, and later also F5 Networks.

Nginx's founders and investors consider Lynwood's claims and demands baseless. They cite the fact that the criminal case in Russia was dismissed due to a lack of evidence of a crime.

F5 Networks noted that Lynwood was unable to satisfy its demands in Russia.

The investigation continued for several months, after which the investigative authorities closed the case due to a lack of evidence against the NGINX co-founders. We are confident that the accusations brought against a group of defendants, including F5, in Lynwood's new lawsuit in the US Federal Court are also without merit.

F5 Networks has submitted a statement emphasizing the importance of ensuring application security and performance in a constantly changing digital landscape. The statement emphasizes the need to integrate modern data protection and traffic management solutions. F5 Networks offers innovative technologies that help organizations adapt to new challenges while ensuring the reliability and scalability of their applications. As cyber threats increase and the number of users grows, the company continues to develop its products to ensure high standards of security and efficiency for businesses.

On March 25, 2021, the San Francisco District Court dismissed Lynwood's lawsuit against F5 Networks and other defendants. The judge noted that the claims were "untimely" because the lawsuit alleges events that occurred in 2011. The lack of further claims from Lynwood may indicate that the company did not have sufficient grounds to continue the litigation.

Results

In this case, there is a clear discrepancy both in the timing and the substance of the claims, as well as in the identity of the claimant.

Until January 1, 2008, the definition of works made for hire was contained in the Law of the Russian Federation of July 9, 1993, No. 5351-1 "On Copyright and Related Rights." According to this law, a work made for hire was any creative work created in the course of performing official duties or in accordance with an official assignment from an employer. This definition played a key role in regulating intellectual property rights, as copyright in such works typically transferred to the employer. Since then, the legislation has changed, but the understanding of works made for hire remains an important aspect of copyright law in Russia.

On January 1, 2008, Part IV of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, which defines the concept of a work made for hire, came into force. According to the new provisions, a work made for hire is the result of intellectual activity in the field of science, literature, or art, created by an employee-author within the scope of their work duties. These changes have significantly impacted the legal regulation of copyright in Russia, clarifying the rights and responsibilities of both authors and employers in the creation and use of intellectual property.

Resolution No. 10 of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation dated April 23, 2019, "On the Application of Part Four of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation," explains in detail which works are considered "works made for hire." This document is an important source of information for understanding the legal status of works made for hire in Russia, as well as their characteristics and conditions of use. Works made for hire have their own characteristics and rules, making the study of this Resolution relevant for lawyers, authors, and anyone interested in copyright.

The Plenum clarifies that a work made for hire can be created both under an employment contract and under a civil law contract. This clarification is important for understanding the legal basis for the creation of works in various circumstances. Properly drafting and understanding the terms of contracts facilitates the effective regulation of copyright and the obligations of the parties.

For a court to recognize a work as made for hire, the employer must demonstrate that its creation was part of the employee's job responsibilities. It is important to note that if the author used the employer's materials, for example, developing a program on an office computer, this is not sufficient grounds for recognizing the work as made for hire. The court will consider not only the use of work equipment but also the compliance of the created work with the objectives set out in the employment contract.

Initially, the exclusive right to a work made for hire belongs to the employer. However, if within three years the employer has not begun to use the work, has not transferred the rights to it to third parties, and has not notified the author that the work will be kept as a trade secret, then the rights to this work made for hire revert to the author. This provision emphasizes the importance of actively using works made for hire and protecting the rights of employees. Studying the legislation in this area will help you understand how to properly protect your interests as an author and employer.

The IT industry is actively developing thanks to open source projects, and any interference by commercial organizations seeking to "appropriate" the rights to such products provokes a negative reaction among specialists. This also explains the significant support the Nginx authors received after the criminal prosecution began in Russia. Open source projects play a key role in innovation and collaboration in the IT sector, so protecting the rights of authors is becoming an important aspect for the community.

Read also:

  • Court cases: 3 high-profile lawsuits against Kaspersky Lab
  • "Changed profession before it was too late": why a cyber policeman went into IT
  • Who is a tester and how to become one from scratch