Contents:

Free Course: "Quick Start with Python"
Learn MoreOpen Source and free software truly represent important advances in the world of technology. These development models were created to simplify the work of developers and give them the opportunity to collaborate, share knowledge, and improve software products. Free software promotes innovation because it allows users not only to use but also to modify code to suit their needs. This opens new horizons for the creation of high-quality and accessible software, which, in turn, has a positive impact on the development of technology and society as a whole.
The freedom provided by such software comes with certain risks. A user not restricted by the strict terms of a commercial license may become a victim of malicious activity or even unwittingly join their activities. Therefore, it's important to be attentive and aware of the potential threats associated with using free software.
This article will introduce you to the basics of this topic. We'll cover key points and provide useful information to help you better understand the subject. Dive into the details and gain valuable knowledge that can be applied in practice. This information will be useful for both beginners and those with experience in this field. Stay tuned to learn more.
- What traps do open source users fall into?
- How are offending developers punished?
- What problems do courts face in such cases?
- What rules should you follow to sleep soundly?
- What's wrong with information security in free software?
Reluctant Plagiarists
By law, the author of a work is the person who is listed as such on the original or a copy. This creates risks, especially when you publish your open source program under free licenses. Unscrupulous developers may use your code in their own products and even present it as their own. As a rule, such violations may not be immediately detected, which underlines the importance of copyright protection in the programming industry. Pay attention to your choice of license and carefully monitor the use of your code to avoid potential abuse.
Danger also arises when using open source code in your development. There is no guarantee that the code's author is law-abiding and has the rights to distribute it under the stated license. By using such code, you risk violating copyright or license terms, which can lead to serious legal consequences. Therefore, you should always carefully check the origin and license terms of open source code before using it in your projects.
Situations with software licenses can be varied and complex. For example, you may have used code available under a permissive license, but then discovered that it included elements of proprietary code that was illegally copied. There is also a risk when someone, without paying attention to legal aspects, combines code fragments from different sources released under different licenses into a single library. In some cases, developers may change the license without proper verification, for example, from GPL to MIT. Such actions can lead to legal consequences and constitute copyright infringement. Therefore, it is important to carefully check the licenses for components used in projects and ensure their compliance.
You will always be responsible for the legal correctness of your use of open source code. This obligation remains regardless of whether you were aware of any copyright infringement or not.
In an interesting case from legal practice, a Russian programmer proposed a license agreement to his former employer. This agreement provided for the use of a program he had developed under a simple, non-exclusive license. The copyright for the program remained with the programmer, and commercial use was limited. This approach allows developers to maintain control over their creations while providing companies with the opportunity to legally use the software for their own purposes. This case highlights the importance of properly drafted licensing agreements in the IT sector, which can prevent legal disputes and ensure that the rights of both parties are respected.
Shortly thereafter, he noticed that the copyright symbol had disappeared from the code. A programmer filed a lawsuit seeking to restore his rights and receive compensation for copyright infringement. The lawsuit was directed not only against his former employer but also against the domain administrator who hosted the disputed software.
The trial court ruled in favor of the plaintiff, but this decision was overturned on appeal. During the trial, it was established that the author also violated the terms of use for software libraries licensed under the GPL. As a result, his program was deemed a derivative work, meaning he lacked special rights to use and distribute it. This case highlights the importance of adhering to license terms when developing software.
It is important for IT companies not to skimp on legal services, especially in the area of copyright. It is impossible to completely avoid the risk of borrowing someone else's ideas or code, but having a qualified lawyer will help prove your good faith and diligence. A professional will be able to thoroughly verify the authorship of the content used, which will significantly reduce the likelihood of legal disputes and protect your company from financial losses. Investing in experienced legal services not only minimizes risks but also strengthens a company's reputation in the marketplace.
How are guilty programmers punished?
According to Russian law, copyright infringers may bear financial liability in two forms: full compensation for damages or compensation, the amount of which varies from 10,000 to 5 million rubles. This legislative regulation is aimed at protecting the rights of authors and encouraging compliance with intellectual property standards.
Recovering damages is a complex process for the plaintiff, as they must convincingly justify the claimed amount of damages. Properly preparing evidence and clearly arguing their case are key to a successful outcome. To obtain fair compensation, the plaintiff should gather all the necessary documents and data confirming the losses incurred, as well as use legal knowledge to competently present their case in court.
Compensation is a convenient mechanism for protecting copyright. It allows you to request a fixed amount, which can be double the cost of counterfeit copies or double the cost of the license agreement for use of the work. However, it should be noted that there is an upper limit of compensation of five million rubles. In the case of software infringement, such an amount may be little consolation, especially considering the potential damages from illegal use. It is important to remember the need to protect your rights and choose the optimal strategy for enforcing them.
In some cases, it is also possible to receive compensation for moral damages, especially if the author's reputation has been damaged. The court determines the specific amount of compensation based on the circumstances of the case.
Any user of open-source software can be a defendant in such cases. Such programs include various operating systems, office applications, and development tools. Using open-source software involves certain risks associated with copyright and licensing. Users should be careful about the terms of licenses and possible legal consequences. It is important to understand that even when using free software, you can face legal issues if you do not comply with the established requirements.
- to copyright holders, if you violated the terms of a free license;
- to the original authors, if you did not check the authorship of the program and infringed their rights;
- to other copyright holders: an open-source product may include other intellectual property, for example, patented. Not every free license grants the rights to them necessary for using the program. Even if such rights are granted, as in Apache 2.0, this does not preclude the possibility of patent lawsuits.
All disputes related to property liability have their negative aspects. Even if you ultimately manage to prove your innocence, this will not eliminate the associated problems. For example, the copyright holder may prohibit the use of the disputed software for the duration of the trial. Such an injunction can significantly hinder your activities and cause additional damages.
In 2017, Artifex, the developer of the popular software product Ghostscript, initiated a lawsuit against Hancom. The lawsuit was filed because Hancom used Ghostscript technology in its office suite without proper permission. This case became one of the most famous in the field of intellectual property and drew attention to software licensing issues. The lawsuit highlights the importance of upholding copyright and licensing agreements in the IT industry, especially in the context of open source software.
The dispute arose over the licensing of Ghostscript software, which is owned by Artifex. Artifex offers two license versions: a free (GPL) and a commercial one. Hancom decided to use the open source version of Ghostscript, but did not plan to release its product as free software. Artifex considered this a violation of the license terms, which formed the basis for the lawsuit.
The defendant managed to reach an amicable settlement of the conflict, but the parties decided to keep the terms of the agreement secret.
Take what they give
The general principle of all free licenses is that the software is provided "as is". The developer is not responsible for the quality of the product and does not guarantee its suitability for the user's specific purposes. However, everyone has the ability to use and modify the software as they see fit, allowing them to improve it and fix its flaws. This idea is one of the core concepts of open source software, promoting innovation and collaboration within the developer community.
Disclaiming warranties and liability can create significant risks for users. If harm occurs, they will not be able to file a claim because they have agreed to the license terms. At the same time, if the user harms the interests of third parties while using such software, they will be liable to them. This emphasizes the importance of carefully considering licensing terms and understanding the potential consequences of using software without a warranty.
What Issues Do Courts Encounter?
Free licenses were originally based on the principles of American law, which led to their early versions being inconsistent with modern copyright law. One example of this inconsistency is the terminology surrounding the use and modification of software. This creates challenges for developers and users, as modern copyright requirements require a clearer definition of the rights and responsibilities of the parties. It is important to adapt open source licenses to current legal realities to ensure the protection of intellectual property and support the growth of open source software.
Modern versions of popular licenses, such as GPLv3, rely on international copyright standards, making them more consistent with Russian legislation, including amendments to Part 4 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation (Articles 1286, paragraph 5; 1286.1). However, the risk of conflicts between these licenses and national legislation still exists. It is important to consider these aspects when choosing software licenses to minimize legal risks and ensure copyright protection.
Courts in our country often face various problems. The main difficulties include a lack of resources, which leads to delays in the consideration of cases. There is also a high workload on the judiciary, which can negatively affect the quality of justice. Furthermore, a shortage of qualified personnel and the absence of modern technologies aggravate the situation. These factors create additional challenges in ensuring fair and timely trials. Comprehensive measures are needed to improve the functioning of the judicial system and enhance its effectiveness.
- Identification of the parties to the agreement. In open source licenses, the author and the copyright holder are the same person. But the problem of co-authorship remains: open source software is often the result of the work of many developers. According to the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, anyone who has accepted the license terms becomes a licensee.
- Identification of the subject of the agreement. The Civil Code of the Russian Federation determines that the subject of an open license is not the work itself, but the right to use it within the limits specified in the agreement. Thus, mutual or copyleft licenses extend their effect not only to the original program, but also to derivative programs.
- Form of the agreement. According to Article 1286.1 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, license agreements must be concluded in simple written form. An open license may specify actions, the performance of which will be considered acceptance of its terms. In this case, the written form of the agreement is considered observed.
- Limitation of the author's personal non-property rights. Open licenses that grant the right to modify a program limit the author's right to the inviolability of the work. In Russian law, such a restriction is prohibited: reworking is recognized as a new work based on an existing one. The question remains whether every modification of a program can be considered a reworking.
- Extension of the terms of the original agreement to subsequent users. If a user distributes an unmodified program, subsequent users receive rights not from him, but from the copyright holder. If the program is modified and the modification can be considered a reworking, the rights are transferred by its author.
When working with numerous co-authors, each of whom makes their own contribution to the overall product, determining who transfers the rights and at what point becomes an extremely difficult task. This creates legal and organizational difficulties that can negatively affect the development process and further use of the product. A clear understanding of the legal aspects and proper documentation are key to effectively managing the rights of co-authors.
- The concept of a derivative work. In the Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation on the application of Part Four of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, a derivative work is defined as a new one, created on the basis of an existing one. Software modification may be defined differently in free licenses, and these definitions may not necessarily match the terminology of Russian legislation. Furthermore, not every software modification can be considered a derivative work.
How to Reconcile It All
Following simple rules will help you avoid legal problems in your professional activities. First of all, always study and comply with current legislation in your field. This includes knowledge of the legal regulations governing your work, as well as licensing and certification requirements.
In addition, it is important to maintain transparent documentation and keep all necessary papers in order. This will help you avoid misunderstandings and simplify the inspection process by regulatory authorities. Monitor compliance with the labor rights of your employees and ensure safe working conditions.
Regularly update your knowledge of legislative changes, as laws are subject to change. Participating in seminars and courses on legal issues will help you stay current with current requirements.
Also, don't forget the importance of ethical standards in business. Honesty and openness in relationships with clients and partners build trust and reduce the risk of conflicts that could lead to legal consequences.
By following these recommendations, you can work confidently, minimize risks, and protect your interests.
- Take at least a basic course on copyright. Pay special attention to the correct borrowing of existing code.
- If you use someone else's open source code under different licenses, carefully read their terms and check for compatibility.
- If you plan to modify and distribute someone else's open source code, make sure your actions are legal.
- If your project is proprietary, check whether it violates the terms of the free license of someone else's open source code.
- If you are releasing an open source project, your employer must know about it and give their consent. Otherwise, you risk being sued for copyright infringement.
The project may include confidential data and information related to trade secrets. This requires prior approval from legal specialists. It is also important to keep in mind that not all open source licenses are compatible with each other.

See also:
Compatibility of Free and Open-Source Licenses: An In-Depth Review
The importance of compatibility of free and open-source licenses cannot be Undervalued in the software world. Understanding the different licenses and their requirements allows developers to effectively use and combine code. In this overview, we will take a detailed look at the main types of licenses, their compatibility, and impact on projects.
Free and open-source licenses are divided into several categories, including copyleft and non-copyleft licenses. Copyleft licenses, such as the GNU GPL, require that derivative works be distributed under the same license. This ensures the protection of free software and its availability to all users. However, such strict compatibility can create difficulties when integrating with other licenses.
Non-copyleft licenses, such as MIT and Apache, are more flexible and allow developers to use code in their own projects without having to open source it. This makes them more compatible with other licenses, which allows for the creation of more complex and functional solutions.
When choosing licenses, it is important to consider their compatibility. Some licenses may be incompatible with each other, which may lead to legal consequences or restrictions on code use. Therefore, it is recommended to carefully analyze the licenses you plan to work with to avoid potential problems.
In conclusion, understanding the compatibility of free and open-source licenses is key for developers. Choosing the right license will not only protect your rights but also ensure ease of integration with other projects and libraries.
Monitor your software, be careful
Open source projects attract many contributors, but not all of them have sufficient knowledge of software security. Without centralized code review, the risk of introducing malicious elements, such as backdoors and spyware, increases. This emphasizes the importance of implementing systematic security measures to protect projects from potential threats and maintain user trust. Ensuring the security of open source projects requires a collaborative community effort, which must actively participate in code audits and share best practices to identify vulnerabilities. The discovery of security vulnerabilities is often not accompanied by a universal algorithm for remediating them. The frequency of updates aimed at addressing these issues also leaves much to be desired. This creates serious risks to information security on a global level. The need for timely response and implementation of effective solutions is becoming critical in the face of an ever-evolving threat landscape. A vulnerability in Apache Log4j, a popular library used in millions of enterprise applications and Java servers, allowed attackers to execute arbitrary code on a server or device. This created serious security risks, allowing criminals to steal data or inject malware. The Log4j issue highlights the importance of timely updating and monitoring the libraries used to prevent such threats.
In 2014, the information security world was rocked by the Heartbleed vulnerability, discovered in the widely used open-source component OpenSSL. This vulnerability allowed attackers to access sensitive information such as passwords and encryption keys, compromising the security of numerous websites and services. Heartbleed demonstrated the importance of regularly updating software and paying close attention to the security of open-source libraries.
Gathering information about which companies and popular applications use specific open-source code is not difficult. Data can be easily found in forums, articles, and developer interviews. This allows attackers who have injected malicious code into open-source software to pinpoint their targets and plan attacks. The use of open-source, while promoting innovation and collaboration, also creates security risks that must be considered.
The departure of foreign software vendors from the Russian market is creating significant changes in the industry. Rapidly replacing commercial solutions is proving challenging, leading to increased interest in open-source solutions. As a result of this growth, the risks associated with the use of such technologies also increase. Open Source solutions can offer flexibility and cost savings, but potential issues with support, security, and compatibility must be taken into account.
Who and how fights for the security of open source software
In foreign practice, the system of service level agreements (SLA, Service Level Agreement) is widely used. Such agreements are concluded between the customer and the Open Source provider in order to minimize the risks associated with the lack of feedback and the resolution of information security issues. The conclusion of an SLA allows you to clearly define the responsibilities of the parties, guarantee the quality of service and timely response to emerging problems, which is especially important in a rapidly changing digital landscape.
There are many effective tools for improving the security of open source software. These tools help developers identify vulnerabilities, ensure data protection, and prevent attacks. Using such solutions not only improves security but also increases user confidence in the product. It is important to regularly update and analyze the software you use to minimize risks and meet modern security requirements. Optimizing the security of open source software is becoming increasingly important in the face of growing threats in the digital world.
- static source code analyzers (SAST);
- dynamic application security analyzers (DAST);
- automated testing scenarios during quality assurance (QA);
- analyzers of multi-level interdependencies between in-house and third-party components (SCA);
- security analyzers of scripts used to build "infrastructure as code";
- security analyzers of container images and configurations and tools for their orchestration.
In 2020, the Linux Foundation, in partnership with GitHub, Google, IBM, JPMorgan Chase, Microsoft, NCC Group, OWASP Foundation, and Red Hat, launched a new project, OpenSSF (Open Source Security Foundation). The main goal of this initiative is to improve the security of open source software. The project has also been joined by companies such as GitLab, HackerOne, Intel, Uber, VMware, ElevenPaths, Okta, Purdue, SAFECode, StackHawk, and Trail of Bits. The project participants strive to create a more secure ecosystem for developers and users by providing better vulnerability management and supporting open security standards.
The main objectives of the project include:
- vulnerability disclosure and patch distribution;
- security tool development;
- development and publication of best practices in information security in the development organization;
- open source threat detection, audit, and enhancement of information security of critical open source projects;
- organization of developer identification and verification to prevent illegitimate changes to the code.
Among the projects aimed at open source software security research, Coverity, developed in partnership with Stanford University, stands out. Also worth mentioning are PVS-Studio and the Open Web Application Security Project (OWASP), both active in security issues. These initiatives play a significant role in improving the security of open source software and helping developers identify and mitigate vulnerabilities.
Recently, the Russian IT industry has seen growing attention to open source security issues. Developers and companies recognize the importance of protecting open source software from potential threats and vulnerabilities. This is due to the increasing number of cyberattacks and the need to ensure the reliability and security of developments. As a result, code auditing and testing measures are being strengthened, contributing to a more secure IT environment.
The Federal Service for Technical and Export Control (FSTEC) initiated the creation of the Linux Kernel Security Research Technology Center. In October 2021, representatives of FSTEC, the scientific community, and the IT market presented the center's operating concept and discussed its main objectives and areas of work. The center will focus on improving the security of the Linux kernel, a crucial step in protecting information systems and data in the face of growing cyber threats.
The center will focus on researching and improving the security of domestic Linux distributions and related developments. Its primary goal is to ensure the technological independence of Russian companies developing distributions and hardware and software solutions from foreign suppliers. This will improve the security and stability of Russia's IT infrastructure.
In April 2022, the Open Source Autonomous Nonprofit Organization (ANO) was founded, headed by Lyubov Orlova, who previously headed the Russian Free Software Association (RASPO) in 2014–2015. The organization's founders include Rostelecom, T1, VK, Rosselkhozbank, ADS Group, the Information Democracy Foundation, and others. The main goal of the ANO "Open Code" is to create a favorable environment for developers of national open source projects, which will stimulate innovation and ensure transparency in software development.
Read also:
- 10 myths about free software
- Can robots love, write laws and dream?
- How to improve Python code: refactoring techniques

