Contents:

Free Python Course ➞ Mini-course for beginners and experienced coders. 4 cool projects in your portfolio, live communication with the speaker. Click and find out what you can learn in the course.
Learn moreIn the previous article, we discussed how to protect computer programs with copyright. In this article, we will focus on the graphical user interface (GUI) and examine important court cases related to its protection and rights. The graphical interface plays a key role in the user experience, and its protection is becoming increasingly important in today's digital world. We will analyze how case law shapes legal norms in this area and which aspects of the interface may be subject to copyright.
In Russian legislation, a graphical user interface is referred to as a GUI. However, for convenience and better understanding, I will use the more popular English abbreviation – GUI.
What is a GUI from a legal perspective?
According to official clarifications from Russian lawmakers, a graphical user interface is classified as an audiovisual display created by software. This means that the visual and audio elements that accompany a website or application are protected by copyright. Protecting a graphical user interface is important for developers and content owners, as it prevents unauthorized use and copying of original solutions. Thus, respecting copyright for graphical user interfaces fosters innovation and maintains competitiveness in the digital industry.
Copyright protects not only complete works but also their individual parts, provided they are creative in nature and can be used independently.
The main problem with legally protecting interfaces is their similarity, as they consist of standard elements such as text fields, checkboxes, sliders, and radio buttons. On template-based platforms such as Tilda and WordPress, as well as in simple mobile applications, interfaces often look virtually identical. This most often applies to user registration forms, order forms, product display cases, and image galleries. Such repetitive elements make it difficult to protect the uniqueness of a design and copyright, since they are common components of web development.



An interface is not always the result of a creative process. In order to protect it with copyright, two key conditions must be met. First, the interface must be original, which means that it must be unique and different from existing solutions. Second, the interface must be fixed in some tangible form, for example, in the form of graphic images or code. Only if these conditions are met can an interface be protected by copyright, which allows its creator to prevent unauthorized use and copying.
- Originality of the GUI. The interface is a non-standard design solution and is not the only correct way to solve the problem.
- The fact of plagiarism. Violators directly copied the original parts of the program or the code that reproduces them.
In practice, this can be difficult to implement. Therefore, in addition to copyright, trademarks and patents are also widely used. Trademarks protect the uniqueness of a brand and its identity, while patent law covers inventions and innovations. The use of these rights allows for the effective protection of intellectual property and the prevention of infringement.
A trademark is a unique word, image, or symbol that allows users to easily identify a specific brand. Trademarks can include logos, slogans, musical works, or videos. After registering a trademark, the owner is issued an official certificate confirming their rights to use this mark. Registering a trademark helps protect intellectual property and prevents other companies from using similar designations. Properly registering a trademark is an important step in building a successful brand and its subsequent protection in the marketplace.
A patent is an exclusive right to an invention, which is usually related to a technical solution. The exclusivity of a patent means that only its owner has the right to freely use, sell, or license this invention. This right protects intellectual property by providing the owner with a monopoly on the use of an invention for a specified period. Patents play a key role in stimulating innovation and technological development by allowing inventors to profit from their creations.
It took several decades for lawyers to develop effective methods of protecting graphical interfaces. The first court cases on this issue began in the mid-1980s. Since then, the legal system has adapted to new challenges posed by rapidly developing technologies and digital products. Protecting intellectual property in the field of graphical interfaces continues to be a relevant topic, given the ever-increasing importance of visual elements in the user experience.
How the approach to GUI protection has changed in the US
There are a number of key precedents in US judicial practice that have had a significant impact on the development of the country's legal system. These precedents form the basis for further court decisions and help define legal norms in various areas. Studying these data allows for a deeper understanding of the functioning of justice in the United States and the impact of court decisions on society.
Jaslow Dental purchased accounting software from Whelan Associates, retaining exclusive rights to the software. When Jaslow Dental created its own software with a similar structure, design, and logic, Whelan filed a lawsuit for copyright infringement. The trial confirmed that copyright does not protect ideas, but rather their implementation, including design and structure. The court ultimately ruled in favor of the plaintiff.
Courts are increasingly abandoning the look and feel doctrine for interface protection. This means that copyright protection no longer extends to the design as a whole, but focuses on the analysis of individual interface components. This approach allows for a more accurate assessment of the originality and protectability of various elements, which is important for developers and companies seeking to protect their innovations. It also becomes necessary to take into account unique aspects of a design that may be considered copyrighted.
Lotus Development accused Paperback Software of copyright infringement, claiming that the latter used interface elements of their Lotus 1-2-3 spreadsheet program in its VP-Planner product. This accusation highlights the importance of protecting intellectual property in software development. Lotus 1-2-3 is one of the first and most well-known spreadsheet applications, and any unauthorized use of its interface can negatively impact the company's reputation and finances.
The court developed a three-step test to determine whether the plaintiff has infringed its copyright. This test serves as the basis for assessing whether intellectual property rights have been infringed. It involves analyzing various factors that help determine how a particular use of a work relates to existing copyright. The test provides a structured approach to copyright cases and helps the court make informed decisions.
The court separated creative interface elements from standard ones, which allowed it to identify their presence in the defendant's program. As a result of this analysis, the court ruled in favor of the plaintiff.
Computer Associates International (CAI) developed the CA-SCHEDULER scheduler program for IBM System 370 computers, which used three different operating systems. To avoid creating three separate versions of the program, CAI engineers created an adapter program that allowed the scheduler to run on any of these operating systems. The adapter was included with the program and was not sold separately. This innovation provided CA-SCHEDULER with flexibility and versatility, making it a sought-after solution for companies using the IBM System 370.
That same year, Altai developed the ZEKE scheduler. To ensure software compatibility with multiple operating systems, Altai's director approached a former CAI developer to create an adapter. By chance, the developer used source code from his previous employer. As a result, the new OSCAR 3.4 adapter was 30% CAI code. CAI soon learned of this and sued Altai for copyright infringement and misappropriation of trade secrets. This case raises important questions about intellectual property rights in software development.

It is difficult to imagine that Altai was surprised by the discovery someone else's code in OSCAR. However, the company's management assembled a team of developers unrelated to OSCAR 3.4 and instructed them to rewrite the adapter using a clean room design method. As a result, a new version called OSCAR 3.5 was released. This version became more reliable and secure, which improved the functionality and performance of the system.
The court applied a three-step test to clearly separate ideas from their implementation. As a result, Altai was ordered to compensate CAI in the amount of $364,444 for copyright infringement in OSCAR 3.4. However, Altai incurred no financial liability for version 3.5, which also copied the adapter's functionality. Furthermore, the law on trade secrets at that time was no longer in effect, which also affected the outcome of the case.
For the first time, the court recognized that a program can consist of several subroutines, each of which represents an independent idea. This precedent also demonstrated that copyright does not protect standard software elements, including many graphical user interface (GUI) elements.
Apple vs. Microsoft and the Victory of Patent Law
One of the most significant cases in the field of graphical interface protection was the 1988 case. This event had a huge impact on the development of law in the field of copyright in software and graphical interfaces. Protecting graphical interfaces has become an important topic for developers and designers, as it touches on issues of intellectual property and innovation in technology. The 1988 case attracted public attention and became the basis for subsequent litigation in this area, defining standards and approaches to copyright protection for unique interface elements.
In the early 1980s, Apple licensed part of the Macintosh graphical user interface (GUI) to Microsoft for the new Windows 1.0 operating system. When Microsoft modified Windows 2.0 to incorporate elements from the Macintosh GUI, Apple filed a lawsuit alleging copyright infringement. Apple argued that copyright protection extended to the overall appearance of the Macintosh interface, regardless of individual interface elements. The case set an important precedent for software intellectual property protection and opened new horizons for future copyright and interface design litigation.
The court carefully analyzed 189 graphical user interface (GUI) elements and concluded that 179 of them were licensed to Microsoft. The remaining 10 elements were not protected by copyright because the court did not recognize them as unique or defined them as the "sole mode of expression of an idea." This particularly concerned the desktop, for which Apple was attempting to patent. The judge noted that there were limitations in implementing the desktop concept and, therefore, dismissed Apple's claim.
The lawsuit continued for several years, and in 1994, the US Supreme Court finally dismissed Apple's claim. This precedent became significant for developers of software with a graphical interface, encouraging them to more actively protect their products. As a result, many companies began to patent elements of graphical user interfaces (GUIs) en masse, which significantly changed the market for technology and software development.
How the law protects GUIs in the US and Europe
In US law, the design of an invention is referred to as "industrial designs." These designs can be protected through various legal instruments, such as copyright, design patent, and trademark. It is important to note that a patent and a trademark can be used simultaneously, but a patent and copyright protection cannot be applied jointly.
Patents for decorative elements and product shapes, including designs, prints, impressions, computer graphics, and interfaces, are registered to protect intellectual property. To obtain a patent, you must file an application with the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), which reviews applications and issues patents for industrial designs. Since 2015, it has been possible to file an application through the International Bureau of WIPO, which allows for protection in several countries that are parties to the Hague Agreement. Registering a patent helps owners protect their unique designs and prevent their unauthorized use.
A trademark in the United States is any word, phrase, symbol, design, or combination of these that serves to identify the goods or services of a particular company. It plays a key role in shaping a brand's image and helps customers distinguish one company's products from those of competitors. Trademarks protect the owner's rights and help build consumer trust in a brand, which, in turn, influences its competitiveness in the marketplace.
Trademarks are registered with the Patent and Trademark Office, where examiners check for originality and distinctiveness. Registration is only possible for marks already in use at the time of filing. A trademark owner in the United States has the option of filing an international application, which will ensure protection of the mark in countries party to the Madrid Agreement. This is an important step for businesses, as it will protect the brand internationally and prevent its unauthorized use.
Even if a trademark is not registered, the court will most likely support the company if it can prove its use in its products. However, it should be noted that such protection is limited to the territory where the trademark has become well-known. Registering a mark provides broader opportunities to protect rights and exclusive powers to use it, which is important for business.
In Europe, the rules for registering industrial designs are similar to other regions, but there are certain nuances. In European law, the term "industrial design" refers to the appearance of a product or part of it that gives it uniqueness. This includes lines, contours, colors, shapes, and textures. In addition, the concept of a product includes graphic design and typographic fonts. To protect an industrial design, it is necessary to take all these aspects into account, as they play a key role in creating the individual style of a product and its competitiveness in the market.
The law provides protection for both registered and unregistered designs. Unregistered designs receive legal protection from the moment they are publicly disclosed within the European Union, which may occur, for example, during pre-sale events or advance product publications. This protection is valid for three years, making it particularly relevant for products with a short life cycle. It is important that the design of the design is new and original, which contributes to its uniqueness and defensibility.
How to protect a graphical interface in Russia?
In Russia, legal protection is only granted to graphical user interfaces (GUIs) that are registered as "industrial designs." This means that to obtain legal protection, it is necessary to undergo the official registration process. Without this step, unique interface design solutions will not be protected from copying and use by others. The registration process protects intellectual property and promotes innovation in design and technology.
We fully agree with our Western colleagues regarding the definition of an industrial design. According to the Civil Code, an industrial design covers the appearance of a product. The key criteria for its protection include novelty and originality. These aspects are key to protecting intellectual property and promote innovation in various industries.
The term "new" implies that the design has not previously been created and, most importantly, has not been patented. This opens up opportunities for uniqueness and originality in development.
The originality of a product design implies its creative nature, meaning that it has no analogues in the world for similar products. The uniqueness of such a design allows the product to stand out from the competition and attract consumer attention. An original approach to product development contributes to the creation of new trends and increased interest in the brand. It is important to emphasize that originality is the key factor in the successful promotion and sale of products on the market.
To obtain a patent for an interface, you must submit an application to Rospatent. The application can be submitted for either a single design or several interconnected designs, which corresponds to the essence of the interface. The application process includes preparing the necessary documents and describing the interface features to ensure its protection.
The application shall include the following elements:
- application for a patent;
- set of product images;
- general appearance drawing of the product, if required;
- description of the industrial design.
When filing an application, you must provide a document confirming payment of the state fee. The date of filing of the application is considered to be the date of filing of both the application itself and the set of product images.
The application undergoes two key examinations: formal and substantive. The formal examination verifies the application's compliance with established requirements and standards. The substantive examination analyzes the content of the application, assesses its relevance and validity. Each of these stages plays an important role in the evaluation and decision-making process.
During the formal verification, the availability of the necessary documents and the accuracy of their completion are assessed. After successful completion of the formal examination, it becomes possible to file a petition for temporary legal protection of the interface. This protection takes effect from the moment the application information is published by Rospatent and continues until the patent is issued. Temporary legal protection allows you to protect your interface intellectual property until a final patent is issued, which is an important step for developers and owners of innovative solutions.
During the substantive examination stage, publicly available information is analyzed to verify the novelty and originality of your industrial design. Experts search for and compare your product with similar products available online to determine its uniqueness and compliance with requirements.
If your application successfully passes the examination, you will be granted a patent for a period of 5 years. This patent can be extended, but its maximum term cannot exceed 25 years from the date of filing. It is important to note that, beginning in the third year after filing, a patent maintenance fee must be paid annually. Patent information is entered into the Unified State Register, ensuring the transparency and accessibility of intellectual property rights data.
This article presents examples of current Russian patents related to interfaces. Interface patents play an important role in protecting intellectual property, providing developers with legal protection for their unique solutions and technologies. These patents can include various elements, such as graphical user interfaces, navigation and interaction systems, as well as unique approaches to interface design and functionality. Familiarization with current patents allows you to understand current trends in interface design and can serve as a source of inspiration for new developments. Patents can also help avoid infringing the rights of other developers, which is especially important in a rapidly evolving technological environment.
A graphical interface patent provides legal protection for unique design elements and functionality of the user interface. This patent covers innovative approaches to the visual presentation of information, as well as methods of user interaction with software. The graphical interface plays a key role in ensuring the usability and intuitiveness of applications, which in turn contributes to increased user satisfaction. It is important to note that a patent can include both static and dynamic interface elements, as well as unique navigation and interaction methods. Protecting such inventions allows developers to maintain a competitive advantage in the marketplace, stimulating further innovation in design and technology.
Patent Holder: Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd.
The patent for a graphical user interface for computer displays covers five different implementation options. This patent represents an innovative solution aimed at improving user interaction with computer systems. Each of the proposed interface options provides intuitive control and improves usability, which in turn can contribute to increased user productivity. The development of such interfaces is important in the context of modern technologies, where effective and simple interaction with devices is becoming a key factor for success.
Patent Holder: Facebook, Inc.
The patent for a "Set of Interface Pages" covers unique elements and functional aspects of the user interface designed to improve user interaction with digital products. This patent encompasses innovative solutions that improve the usability and efficiency of interfaces, providing users with a more intuitive and enjoyable experience. This set of interface pages can be applied in a variety of fields, including web design, mobile applications, and software. Patent protection allows developers and companies to maintain a competitive advantage by incorporating these unique solutions into their products and services.
The patent holder is PROTEK Group of Companies, LLC. The company is actively engaged in the development and implementation of innovative technologies protected by patents. Patents protect intellectual property and facilitate the development of new solutions in various industries. With unique rights to its inventions, PROTEK Group of Companies, LLC strives to improve the quality of its products and services, offering customers advanced technologies and high standards.
Patent protection for interfaces is in significant demand in Russia for several reasons. First, interfaces are an important part of the user experience, and their uniqueness can significantly impact the success of a product. Second, patenting interfaces allows developers to protect their innovations from copying and unauthorized use by competitors. This creates a competitive advantage and promotes business development. Third, possessing a patent for an interface increases a company's attractiveness to investors and partners, as it demonstrates its technological maturity and capacity for innovation. Thus, patent protection of the interface in Russia is becoming an important tool for protecting intellectual property and stimulating further development in the field of technology.
- it is the appearance of the components that is protected, and not what is under the hood, such as code;
- patent infringement is easier to prove;
- patents increase the investment attractiveness of a company.
However, patents also have several obvious disadvantages:
- you will have to spend time and fork out a decent amount to register a patent;
- you need to register a design in each country where you plan to sell the software;
- one patent protects one interface.
Court practice in Russia on cases of protection of graphical user interfaces (GUI) is practically not developed. The main focus in court proceedings is on issues of illegal use of website content. This creates gaps in law enforcement practice and requires further study and development of legal norms aimed at protecting unique interfaces and their elements. In the digital economy, GUI protection issues are becoming increasingly relevant, highlighting the need to develop clear legal standards in this area.
The Artsoft web studio has transferred the rights to use the Restoranonline system to Artsoft Labs. This system is designed to automate restaurant management processes and improve operational efficiency. Restoranonline offers a wide range of features, including order management, inventory control, and sales analysis. With this solution, restaurants can optimize their business processes and improve the quality of customer service.
- a set of electronic pages/sites;
- design of the restoranonline.ru website;
- corporate style of restoranonline.ru;
- all information contained on the website at the time of concluding the agreement;
- content of the restoranonline.ru website;
- SEO texts.
In August 2013, managers of the Artsofte Labs company discovered the website www.edavmig.ru, which, according to the plaintiff, used design elements, parts of the content and corporate style of the website www.restoranonline.ru without permission. It should be noted that both websites are currently unavailable. This case highlights the importance of upholding copyright in the digital space.
Artsoft Labs LLC has filed a lawsuit against Avto 1 LLC, Individual Entrepreneur I.V. Ivanov, and Master-Gruzchik LLC for copyright infringement on the content of the website www.restoranonline.ru. The company is seeking compensation in the amount of 3,000,000 rubles. The owner of the rights to this website is listed as Artsoft Web Studio LLC, with which an exclusive license was concluded in December 2012. This case highlights the importance of upholding copyright in the field of internet content and the need to protect intellectual property.
Who are these legal entities against whom the claims were filed? Individual entrepreneur I.V. Ivanov is the developer of the website www.edavmig.ru. Master-Gruzchik, a limited liability company, commissioned Ivanov to integrate this website, while Auto 1 advertised its services on it. In this situation, it is important to consider that all parties have their own interests and obligations, which could lead to legal disputes and litigation.
Court proceedings at all levels resulted in the plaintiff's claims being denied. He was unable to provide evidence of legal ownership of the website. There was also no evidence that the rights to the disputed resource had been transferred from the developer to Artsofte Web Studio, with which the plaintiff had signed a contract. This case highlights the importance of clear documentation and evidence of intellectual property rights in web development.
This situation appears unusual, but our focus is on the court's decision. The court's decision is key in this context, as it determines the further actions of the parties and may influence further developments. It is important to analyze not only the verdict itself, but also the reasons why the court reached this conclusion. This will help better understand the legal aspects of the case and its impact on similar situations in the future.
Structural elements, forms, buttons, icons, fonts, and individual pages of the website are technical and informational components that do not reflect the creative process or individual approach. These elements serve to simplify the perception of information and navigation, but do not constitute original works.
The court's opinion in the case of Artsoft Labs LLC contains key points regarding this legal proceeding. The document sets out in detail the main facts, the evidence presented, and the arguments of the parties. The court took into account all the presented data and rendered a decision that is of significant importance both for the company itself and for the market as a whole. It emphasizes the importance of compliance with the law and legal regulations in the area of activity of Artsoft Labs LLC. This case exemplifies how legal considerations can influence business processes and company strategy in the modern world.
Even if the copyright had been transferred from the website authors to the web studio and then transferred to the plaintiff under a license agreement, the court would likely have rejected Artsofte Labs' claims. Had the plaintiff attempted to register a patent, it is highly likely that this would also have been unsuccessful, as the website's interface clearly contained standard elements. Thus, the plaintiff could have avoided wasting time and resources on a sure-fire case.
If you have created a unique interface design and intend to use it commercially, it is recommended to register the graphical user interface (GUI) as an "industrial design." This will help minimize the risks associated with software copyright. Registration as an industrial design will provide legal protection for your design and prevent its unauthorized use by other companies. This way, you can confidently grow your business while protecting your intellectual property rights and development investments.
Looking for an opportunity to master IT contracting skills, deal-making, and effective legal communication? Enroll in the "Intellectual Property Protection" course at Skillbox and start learning today. This course will help you gain the necessary knowledge and practical skills to successfully manage intellectual property in IT. Don't miss the opportunity to improve your skills and protect your rights.
If you've created a unique user interface design and plan to use it in your business, we recommend registering the graphical user interface (GUI) as an "industrial design." This will minimize the risks associated with software copyright. Registering your design as an industrial design will provide legal protection for your design and help avoid potential infringement.

