Code

How Microsoft Fought Open Source and Why It Had to Embrace Linux

How Microsoft Fought Open Source and Why It Had to Embrace Linux

Learn: Administration of Linux OS

Learn more
The PDP-8/E is the most "personal" model in the PDP-8 line. Photo: Pete Turnbull / Flickr

In the 1960s, the legal understanding of software was still in its infancy. Each program, like a book, has its own author, but copyright does not limit the exchange of books. Based on this principle, one might assume that purchased software is permitted to be shared with other users. However, installing a program on a computer without paying for it results in the creation of an illegal copy, which causes losses to software developers. To protect the rights of software creators and prevent financial losses, the US Congress ruled in 1976 that computer programs are subject to copyright. This decision was an important step in the legal protection of intellectual property in the fields of technology and programming.

In 1973, Bell Labs released the open-source UNIX operating system, which quickly gained popularity. UNIX was designed with a wide audience in mind, was affordable, and ensured ease of portability between different machines. This system became the basis for many modern operating systems and had a significant influence on the development of computer technology.

The University of California at Berkeley developed the BSD operating system based on UNIX, which was regularly updated and sold for $1,000 per copy. AT&T realized they were losing profits and decided to close the source code. As a result, the price of UNIX, previously available for the price of a floppy disk, increased to tens of thousands of dollars.

In this article, we will look at how to legally protect software. Understanding the legal aspects of software protection is an important step for developers and IT companies. We will discuss key methods, including copyrights, patents, and licensing, that will help you protect your developments and prevent illegal use. Read on to learn how to effectively protect your program from a legal standpoint.

Harvard Student Declares War on Open Source

In 1975, Harvard students Bill Gates and Paul Allen developed a Basic language interpreter for the Altair 8800 computer. They transferred their development to the manufacturer, receiving a percentage of the sales. This step became a significant moment in the history of programming and laid the foundation for the further development of software and the creation of Microsoft. The development of Basic for the Altair 8800 opened new horizons for users, making programming more accessible and popular.

At this time, Microsoft was founded. Over time, the hyphen in the name disappeared, and the company became a major corporation with a market capitalization of $2 trillion. It was Microsoft that developed the MS-DOS operating system, as well as the legendary versions of Windows 95, 98, XP, and 7. In addition, the company created an office suite, the Visual Studio development environment, and the C# programming language with the .NET platform.

The young entrepreneurs earned about $100 for each copy of Basic sold, but were unable to get rich due to low demand for the interpreter. Meanwhile, Altair sales grew rapidly and exceeded software sales by tens of times. Bill realized that the reason was that people were willing to pay for the hardware, and copies of the software were distributed among users.

In 1976, Bill Gates published the landmark "Open Letter to Hobbyists," in which he sharply criticized users who used software without a license. In this letter, he emphasized the importance of respecting copyright and the need to support developers. Gates emphasized that without financial support, developers would not be able to continue to create high-quality programs. This letter became an important milestone in the history of software, marking the beginning of an active fight against piracy and a call for respect for intellectual property.

We have received many positive reviews of the Basic product. However, it is worth noting that most of these reviews come from people who never purchased Basic. In fact, less than 10% of Altair owners actually purchased the product. Furthermore, taking into account the received license fees, the time spent developing Altair Basic is estimated at less than $2 per hour. This highlights the need for a more careful approach to assessing reviews and actual demand for a product.

The reason for this phenomenon is that many users, called "hobbyists," resort to software theft. They believe that they should only pay for hardware, while programs can be freely distributed. This ignores the fact that software developers also need financial support to continue their work.

Microsoft's fight against Open Source began with Bill Gates' recognition of the threat posed by free software to its business model. At that time, the full-fledged Open Source movement had not yet emerged, and the Linux operating system would not appear until 16 years later. This fight became an important stage in the development of technology and the formation of market policy in the software sector.

Bill Gates's statement contains an important truth. Manufacturers should receive fair compensation for their popular and high-quality products. However, in the software sector, traditional copyright laws did not function properly: programs were easily copied, and effective protection mechanisms were lacking. This problem complicated the protection of intellectual property and undermined the incentives for developers to create innovative solutions. The need for new approaches to software copyright became clear, as intellectual property protection is key to the development of technology and ensuring fair compensation for creators. Bill Gates, who was famous in the 1970s and 1980s, was not always associated with fairness and justice. In 1981, he entered into an agreement with IBM, under which he and Paul Allen received a percentage of sales of the MS-DOS operating system. This deal earned the founders of Microsoft approximately $200 million over thirty years. Meanwhile, Seattle Computer Products, the company from which they purchased the operating system, received only a symbolic compensation of $50,000 and gratitude. As a result, a few years later, Seattle Computer Products went bankrupt. These events highlight the complex and contradictory aspects of the technology business and the development of companies in a competitive environment.

The Massachusetts Preacher and the "Windows Killer"

In 1983, a scientist at the MIT Artificial Intelligence Laboratory issued a letter titled "Free UNIX!" In this letter, he announced his intention to create an open system compatible with UNIX using free software. The author called on everyone to support his project financially, as well as to provide work time, programs, and equipment. This ambitious project was called GNU, which stands for "GNU is Not UNIX."

The author of the letter was Richard Stallman. Like Bill Gates, he studied at Harvard and was interested in computers, but their paths diverged. During 13 years at MIT, Stallman developed the Lisp machine and created the well-known text editor Emacs. Since his university years, he has held the idea that code and knowledge should not belong to anyone. In this context, he considers proponents of proprietary (closed) software an obstacle to progress and unlawful appropriation of the common heritage of mankind.

No, I thought it was some kind of hat. Photo: Wikimedia Commons

In 1984, Richard Stallman decided to leave his job to prevent the university from claiming copyright over the GNU project. He devoted himself entirely to the development of free software. Together with like-minded individuals, he created the legal basis for free software—the GPL license, which became an important tool for protecting the rights of users and developers.

The GPL (GNU Public License) is an official alternative to traditional copyright. For software to be considered free, it is not enough to simply publish it with the statement: "Take it whoever wants." There will always be people who will try to claim rights to your work. It was with this goal in mind that Richard Stallman developed the concept of copyleft, which allows authors to grant users the right to distribute and modify their works. At the same time, authors of derivative works are obliged to retain the same rights, thus ensuring the freedom to use and further develop the software. The GPL promotes the creation of open source software and protects the interests of developers, making it an important tool in the technology world.

Using open source software has its advantages and disadvantages. On the one hand, you can easily take a program you like and adapt it to your needs, copying the necessary blocks of code for your project. This provides flexibility and the opportunity for rapid development, as you gain access to existing solutions. On the other hand, it is worth remembering that when using open source technologies, your project also becomes open and available to others. This can affect its commercial attractiveness and uniqueness. Therefore, before implementing open source components, it is important to carefully evaluate all the risks and benefits to make an informed choice.

In 1991, Linus Torvalds posted the Linux kernel on an FTP server, which became the basis for the creation of the open source GNU/Linux operating system, according to the ideas of Richard Stallman. The new system quickly gained popularity among Minix OS users and Open Source supporters. Linux was immediately discussed as a "Windows killer," as many wondered why pay for an operating system when they could install a fully featured alternative with a suite of programs for free. These predictions proved partially correct, as Linux has indeed attracted a significant number of users, but competition with Windows continues.

Despite the computer community's enthusiasm for Linux, the product was significantly inferior to Windows in quality. Linux was developed primarily for programmers and tech-savvy users, not for the general public. Most people bought computers with Microsoft software preinstalled and didn't think twice about reinstalling. Installing software out of the box is much easier than assembling it from individual components and working with the command line. This explains why Windows remained the more popular operating system for most users.

In the late 1990s, Linux-based systems began to rapidly gain popularity, especially among professionals working with servers and supercomputers. More and more businesses and government agencies switched to Debian, which first displaced Windows NT and then became the leader in the server software segment. Soon, other distributions such as CentOS, SUSE, and Ubuntu Server appeared, also beginning to take market share from Microsoft. With the growing popularity of Linux solutions, these operating systems are becoming the preferred choice for organizations seeking reliability and security.

The Cold War, or the Empire Strikes Back

By the late 1990s, Microsoft had established itself as a monopolist in the software market, demonstrating impressive financial growth and achieving historically high stock prices. During this period, the company acquired a reputation as an "evil corporation," accused of distributing low-quality software and aggressive competition, backed by legal methods. Protests against Microsoft's practices raised questions about fairness and ethics in business, leading to discussions about the need to regulate large tech companies.

Bill Gates is a philanthropist now, but in the late nineties they joked like this. Photo: Frederic Legrand — COMEO / Shutterstock

The company's reputation was finally shaped by the leak of the so-called "Halloween documents." These materials discussed methods of technical and legal pressure on open source. One of the proposals was to "cleanse" open network protocols, replacing them with proprietary ones, which could undermine the foundations of open source. Microsoft confirmed the authenticity of these emails, but noted that they were the private memos of an ordinary employee and not the official company position. Nevertheless, this statement raises doubts in the public.

In 2000, Steve Ballmer replaced Bill Gates as CEO of Microsoft. Under his leadership, the company released iconic operating systems such as Windows XP and Windows 7. However, Ballmer became known not only for his achievements, but also for controversial statements about Linux and unfulfilled predictions. One of his most memorable statements is that Linux is not in the public domain. This operating system, based on open source principles, raises intellectual property concerns. The license under which Linux is distributed allows the code to be freely used, modified, and redistributed, which could threaten traditional licensing models. This raises important questions about copyright protection and the implications for software developers. Linux is an operating system that has been on the market for over 20 years. It is a clone of legacy systems adapted to modern requirements. Despite this, Linux finds its audience and is actively used in various fields, including servers, embedded systems, and personal computers. Although many consider it simply a repetition of past solutions, Linux offers unique features for users and developers, such as open source and high flexibility. Linus Torvalds responded with restraint to criticism from Steve Ballmer. However, when the corporation accused Linux and LibreOffice of infringing 200 patents, the developer responded in a manner that emphasized the absurdity of these accusations. His words were ironic, pointing to the groundlessness of such claims coming from a company that had once faced accusations of infringement itself.

Microsoft must provide information about the patents that it believes its open-source software infringes. If violations are found, developers are ready to rewrite their programs. However, there is a concern that Microsoft itself may infringe other people's patents and free software licenses. This is one of the reasons why all of its products are closed source. Closed products limit the capabilities of users and developers, which is contrary to the principles of open source software.

During Steve Ballmer's leadership, Microsoft initiated the "Get the Facts" campaign, the purpose of which was to discredit the Linux operating system. This campaign claimed that Windows Server was more cost-effective than Debian. However, this attempt failed: the IT community criticized Microsoft for its false data, and Linux continued to maintain its market position.

Microsoft Loves Open Source

In the new millennium, Microsoft's management recognized the benefits that open source software solutions could provide to business. Government agencies began actively supporting open source projects both financially and legally. Some countries even developed national operating systems based on Linux. In addition, some company employees sought to change the perception of Microsoft as a greedy monopoly.

How can you change the strategy of a company that has followed the same line for 30 years without scaring off investors? The ideas put forward by Richard Stallman still seem relevant and even revolutionary, and for some, they represent nothing less than a new kind of communism. It is important to note that in the United States, communism ideas provoke a negative reaction. Therefore, the company must approach change carefully to adapt its principles to modern requirements while maintaining the trust of investors and customers.

Microsoft began actively exploring the world of open source software. First, the company attracted experts in the field and formed a team to study open source, appointing a director of Linux strategy. Then, Microsoft ended the unsuccessful Get the Facts campaign and launched the BizSpark startup accelerator, which was replaced by the Microsoft For Startups program in 2018. These steps indicate a significant shift in the company's strategy aimed at supporting innovative solutions and collaborating with the developer community.

The corporation gradually implemented a new business strategy with open source at its core. In 2008, it invested $10 million to create a lab to ensure product compatibility with Linux. Subsequently, the company launched the Azure cloud platform, based on Debian and other open source solutions. It also open-sourced the .NET and Visual Studio platforms. In 2018, the corporation acquired the largest source code repository, GitHub, for $7.5 billion. These moves highlight the company's commitment to integrating with the developer community and supporting open technologies.

At the time of writing, Microsoft's GitHub account contains over 4,200 repositories. The most starred projects include Visual Studio, terminal source code, and the TypeScript programming language. Also worth noting are the MS-DOS repository, Objective-C, tools for the Azure cloud platform, and web programming tutorials in several languages. Unfortunately, Russian is again not represented in these tutorials.

The source code is published under the MIT License, which allows users to freely run, distribute, modify, and use the product in their own projects. The main condition of this license is that the license text and the author's name must accompany the source code and any derivative works. The MIT license gives developers flexibility and freedom in how they use their code, making it a popular choice in the programming community.

Well, you get the idea. Photo: Microsoft

Community members have mixed views on the changing relationship between Microsoft and the free software world. Linus Torvalds believes the company has changed its views and is genuinely interested in developing open source. In contrast, Richard Stallman believes Microsoft's commitment to open source represents the same "support, expand, destroy" strategy the corporation has always used against its competitors. These differing opinions highlight important aspects of the attitude toward free software and its role in the modern technological landscape.

The future plans of Microsoft's top managers will become clearer with time. However, it is already clear that over 30 years of confrontation, open source has transformed from an outsider into a significant movement with its own operating system, a vast body of useful software, and a clear philosophy. Open source is now an integral part of the industry, while its opponents are becoming a thing of the past. Reputable IT companies actively support open source and share the source code of their products, which fosters innovation and technological development.

Discover the world of Linux and learn why this operating system is becoming increasingly popular among young people. Enroll in the "Linux OS Administration" course and delve deeper into open source software. Gain the necessary skills to work with Linux and become part of a community that values ​​freedom and flexibility in using technology.

Linux OS Administration

You will get acquainted with the Linux OS and its advantages, learn how to work with the command line and manage network connections. You can become a Linux administrator, configure and maintain servers in the company.

Find out more