Code

How the University Teaching Profession is Changing: An Interview with a Researcher

How the University Teaching Profession is Changing: An Interview with a Researcher

Course with employment: "The profession of a Methodologist from scratch to PRO"

Find out more

Research project information

A research project is a systematic study of a specific topic in order to obtain new knowledge and practical recommendations. The project analyzes existing information, collects and processes data to form substantiated conclusions.

The project includes several key stages: problem statement, hypothesis formulation, data collection and analysis, and interpretation of results. The focus is on the scientific validity and relevance of the research topic, which allows us to create valuable recommendations for practical application.

It is important to note that research projects can cover various fields of knowledge, such as social sciences, technology, ecology, and medicine. The results of such projects contribute to the development of the scientific community and can be used to solve pressing societal problems.

Through our research project, we strive not only to deepen our understanding of the chosen topic but also to contribute to further research, which emphasizes the significance and usefulness of our work.

The project "The Human Dimension of Transformation Processes in Russian Universities: Historical Experience, Trends, and Responses to Modern Challenges" was launched in 2019 with the support of the Russian Science Foundation. As part of the study, the researchers conducted surveys and interviews with representatives of seven Russian universities participating in the "5-100" project. The universities selected for analysis differ in terms of their length of participation, funding levels, and geographic location, allowing for a comprehensive understanding of the transformational processes in higher education in the country. The project, funded by the Russian Science Foundation (RSF), is scheduled to be completed this year, after which the researchers intend to focus on the universities selected under the "Priority 2030" initiative. Furthermore, they plan to conduct a comparative analysis of the results of academic excellence programs in Russia, the CIS, and Europe. This will help identify best practices and develop recommendations to improve the competitiveness of Russian universities in the international arena.

Director of the School of Environmental and Social Studies (Anthroposchool) at Tyumen State University. Candidate of Historical Sciences with an emphasis on research in the field of history, anthropology and sociology of science, as well as higher education. Conducts research aimed at studying the interaction of society and the environment, analyzing the influence of scientific approaches on educational processes and social structures.

In this interview, you will learn about:

  • why universities are the most closed corporations;
  • what is new in the competencies of modern university employees and why the "university man" is hung with them like a Christmas tree with garlands;
  • what "three pillars of faith in the academy" currently motivate people to choose to work at a university;
  • why HR services have not taken root in most universities;
  • why employees are sometimes dissatisfied with the media activity of universities.

The Priority 2030 program, aimed at developing and improving the competitiveness of Russian universities, has been launched. This initiative, like previous programs, such as support for national research universities and the 5-100 project, sets ambitious goals for universities. The state expects program participants to integrate educational processes with scientific research and technology development. As a result, universities will strengthen their positions in global science, education, and technology markets. The Priority 2030 program creates new opportunities for Russian universities, facilitating their transformation and improving the quality of educational services. Educational transformation programs significantly alter the daily activities of university staff. Research conducted by an interdisciplinary team from Tyumen and Tomsk State Universities, the Higher School of Economics, Skoltech, the Vavilov Institute of the History of Natural Science and Technology of the Russian Academy of Sciences, and the University of Rochester (USA) analyzes how the teaching profession has changed in recent decades. In a conversation with project director Alexander Sorokin, we discussed the competencies needed by modern university staff and how faculty perceive these changes. Current transformations require university staff to be adaptable and prepared for new teaching methods, as well as to be able to integrate modern technologies into the educational process.

"A modern university student must be their own manager"

Our research examines the "human dimension" of universities, which involves analyzing the interactions and relationships between students, faculty, and administrative staff. We consider not only academic aspects, but also the social, cultural, and emotional factors that influence the educational process. Studying the human dimension allows us to identify how the university environment shapes students' personalities and contributes to their development. This research aims to improve the educational experience and create a more favorable atmosphere for learning and self-development at universities.

The main goal of our project is to analyze the transformation of higher education that took place in the 1990s and 2000s. Many of these projects were evaluated solely based on quantitative metrics, such as changes in faculty numbers and their publications. However, such dry data does not allow us to understand the programs' profound impact on the people working and studying at universities. A university is, first and foremost, a community of people: faculty, students, and administrators. It is a culture and atmosphere that shape the educational process and the personal development of each participant. It is important not only to consider quantitative metrics but also to study the qualitative changes occurring in the educational environment.

The first block of our project, which I have been working on for over ten years, is devoted to assessing the impact of various programs on professional change. We analyze how programs influence faculty competencies, personnel policies, and organizational culture. For example, as part of the "5-100" project, virtually every university we studied developed its own logo, created a unique identity, and shaped its brand "myths." This demonstrates the program's significant impact on the development of educational institutions and their image.

We strive to study current educational issues through in-depth interviews with faculty and administrators. At each university, we speak with so-called "leaders" and "average" universities. Leaders must have three publications in international journals over the past three years and grant management experience, while average universities participate in grants but have fewer publications. We conduct interviews with colleagues lasting from 40 minutes to two hours, asking questions to uncover their true thoughts and opinions. This research is a complex process from the perspective of anthropology and sociology, allowing for a deep understanding of the internal dynamics of educational institutions.

Modern universities, despite claims of transparency, remain closed structures. It is often easier to get an interview with a Rosatom employee than with a university representative. Educational institutions fear for their reputation and are concerned that conclusions could be drawn that negatively impact their image. In a competitive educational market, such secrecy hinders open communication and exchange of opinions, which can negatively impact trust among students and society as a whole.

We don't focus on finding fault, but rather on analyzing how federal policy is changing at the higher education level and how these changes impact students and faculty. In our publications, we avoid mentioning specific universities in order to focus on general trends and their impact on the educational process.

Still: the film "Another Round"

Over the past decades, the set of competencies required of a university teacher has changed significantly. Modern teachers must possess not only deep knowledge in their field but also the ability to adapt to rapidly changing educational environments. Key aspects include the integration of technology into the learning process, communication skills, and interaction with diverse student groups. Teachers must be prepared to implement innovative teaching methods, as well as continuously develop and improve their skills. The ability to work with digital resources and analyze information has become an integral part of the profession. In the context of globalization of the educational process, it is also important to consider cultural differences and student needs, which requires teachers to be flexible and open to new approaches to teaching. Changes in universities are becoming increasingly evident. Teaching and research remain the primary processes in higher education institutions. In the Soviet period, beginning in the 1930s, these processes were clearly separated. The competencies of an experienced teacher, capable of clearly explaining a problem and engaging students with an interesting topic, and those of a qualified researcher were in the hands of different specialists. Currently, the goal is to integrate these two aspects, aimed at creating a more holistic educational environment. This synergy between teaching and research contributes to the development of highly qualified specialists capable not only of imparting knowledge but also of actively participating in scientific research.

Modern university students must be effective managers of both their own lives and their teams. To do this, they need financial knowledge, including an understanding of project-related tax obligations. Most of our respondents confirm the importance of these skills for professional success.

A third important aspect is the need to develop soft skills, particularly in the area of ​​communication. The ability to communicate effectively with others is crucial, as many large projects require interaction with colleagues from different countries and professional fields. Sometimes, even if you communicate in the same language, you may encounter differences in terminology and approaches, which requires adaptability and the ability to find common ground. Developing these skills not only improves the quality of work but also facilitates successful collaboration in multinational teams.

What events and programs have significantly influenced these changes?

The rationale for educational reform was to expand faculty competencies, which became necessary for integrating research into the teaching process. An important aspect of this transformation was the involvement of faculty in research. Project 5-100 played a key role in this fundamental transformation, particularly in the context of higher education. It contributed to the creation of new standards and approaches, which in turn improved the quality of the educational process and strengthened the connection between research and teaching.

Previously, a course was assigned to a specific faculty member, who taught students for 15 years without significant changes. However, in a context of increasing individualization and intensifying internal and external competition, the guarantee of stable employment for a faculty member who did not update course content disappeared. Students have the opportunity to choose, making the selection of a teacher more competitive.

The "5-100" project pushed teachers out of their comfort zone. Since its launch, there has been significant resistance to the directives coming from above. These directives have fundamentally altered teachers' approaches and methods, causing discontent and concern in the educational community. Teachers sought to maintain their autonomy and individual approach to teaching, but the changes initiated by the project required adaptation and revision of established practices.

Still: the film "A Serious Man"

The modern labor market is constantly changing, and as a result, certain Previously essential competencies are becoming less relevant. For example, knowledge of legacy technologies or software may be unnecessary in the context of rapid technological advancement. Also, skills associated with routine tasks are often replaced by automated solutions, diminishing their importance. It's important to adapt to new conditions and develop modern skills, such as analytical thinking, data processing, and digital literacy, which are now in demand. Competencies that were once considered fundamental may lose their relevance, and professionals must be prepared for continuous learning and self-development to remain competitive in the labor market.

We try to find out this during interviews, but not a single respondent mentions that any skills have become irrelevant to them. It seems that the "university person" accumulates new skills and competencies, like a Christmas tree decorated with garlands, while no one removes old skills, and the person themselves are in no hurry to get rid of them. This can lead to information overload and decreased skill utilization. It's important to periodically reassess your competencies and adapt to changes in the professional environment to remain relevant and competitive. Many experts argue that some educational formats are losing their relevance. This is due to the rapid development of technology and changes in learning approaches. In today's environment, teaching methods must be adapted to meet the needs of students and modern society. Updating educational formats will improve learning effectiveness and better prepare students for the challenges of the labor market. Teachers are increasingly reducing the length of lectures, arguing that this is ineffective for some subjects. Instead of traditional lectures, they offer students theory lessons from renowned professors, such as those from Cambridge, and focus on project work during practical classes. This approach promotes greater student engagement and allows them to develop essential skills. As a result, education is becoming more practice-oriented and adapted to the modern demands of the labor market.

The change in teaching formats does not affect instructor competencies, but merely modifies the methods of delivering material. At the same time, the importance of professional skills remains high: instructors must still be able to deliver high-quality lectures and effectively interact with the audience.

Perhaps this is a positive development, as a global view of current changes reveals that our world is becoming more complex. We are not abandoning traditional methods, but actively integrating new opportunities. During the pandemic, for example, university staff began to apply modern approaches to management, teamwork, teaching, and research. These changes are becoming evident thanks to the recognition by instructors, researchers, and management of the need to acquire new skills and competencies.

The pandemic has significantly accelerated existing trends in shifting competency sets and opened new horizons for change. During the crisis, many companies began to reassess their employee requirements, emphasizing flexible skills and the ability to adapt to rapidly changing conditions. Remote work became the norm, requiring employees to master new technologies and communication methods.

Furthermore, there has been a growing interest in digital skills such as data analysis, programming, and digital marketing, which has also impacted the labor market. The pandemic has driven the need for continuous learning and professional development, which in turn has shaped new approaches to education and career advancement. Amidst uncertainty, employees and employers have begun to recognize the importance of cross-functional skills and an interdisciplinary approach, opening up new opportunities for career growth and development.

Research shows that the importance of digitalization has increased significantly, making the need to master modern technologies more pressing. In a rapidly changing world, we are seeing an increasing role for instructional design as a key mechanism and approach for transforming curricula for different target audiences. Instructional design helps adapt educational materials to student needs, ensuring their engagement and learning effectiveness.

Analyzing the opinions of our informants, we can see that the pandemic has accelerated existing trends. The need for digitalization did not arise unexpectedly, and before the pandemic, self-organization and work planning skills were important for both faculty and students. These aspects had been discussed for a long time, but the extraordinary circumstances forced everyone to adapt to new realities.

Three Pillars of Faith in the Academy

Challenges in renewing a university's corporate culture often arise due to faculty members' negative attitudes toward new requirements. One reason for such resistance may be the faculty's age. More experienced staff often prefer traditional working methods, which leads to a conflict with the need to implement modern approaches. However, the situation is much more complex. Resistance to reforms can be caused not only by age factors, but also by a lack of confidence in the effectiveness of new changes, insufficient preparation for them, or fear of losing status. It is also important to consider that insufficient communication and faculty involvement in the change process can exacerbate the problems. Successful corporate culture renewal requires incorporating the views of all stakeholders in the educational process and actively working to overcome barriers.

Our research revealed no clear age bias among critics. Both young and old voiced dissatisfaction. The reasons for this criticism are varied. Some note a lack of transparency within the university system, which makes it difficult to understand key aspects of its operations. Others, drawing on the experience of the 5-100 Project, point out that regulations can change as work progresses. Initially, the emphasis is on developing international educational programs, then the need for extensive publications arises, and soon new requirements emerge, creating confusion and complicating task accomplishment.

People don't always have time to adapt to change, and this can lead to negative perceptions of their work. It's important to remember that we adhere to pre-defined criteria for selecting informants and do not communicate with those who do not meet these requirements. All of our informants are successful individuals, but there are also critics among them.

There is an opinion that the Soviet Union and imperial Russia had an effective system of organizing and financing science. This opinion may be connected with nostalgia for the past. Currently, Project 5-100 is criticized for its excessive emphasis on international standards, which do not always correspond to national interests, especially among specialists in the exact and natural sciences. To successfully participate in Project 5-100, higher education institutions must comply with international requirements, but in some cases, it is more expedient and cost-effective to collaborate with specific partners within the country. Such an approach could contribute to the development of domestic science and strengthen the position of Russian universities on the international stage.

In this situation, several aspects of the problem can be identified. On the one hand, a lack of awareness of Project 5-100 among university staff may be one of the reasons. On the other hand, distortions may indeed arise in the implementation of this project at some universities. However, we do not examine individual aspects of internal information policy within the current analysis.

Young faculty members enter the profession with a variety of attitudes and motivations. The primary reason for choosing an academic career is often the desire to impart knowledge and inspire students. Many have a deep passion for their subject area, which draws them to work in educational institutions. Furthermore, the academic environment provides opportunities for research and professional growth. Young professionals may also be attracted by the stability and social status that a career in education brings. It is important to note that each faculty member has their own unique goals and ideals, making academia diverse and multifaceted.

Most of our informants make a conscious decision based on their own convictions, rather than being influenced by their supervisors, family, or the example of others. This underscores the importance of an individual approach to choice, shaped by personal experience and internal understanding.

Three key factors that contribute to motivation:

  • a certain freedom to build your own schedule;
  • communication opportunities, because in academia, unlike in other fields, you can freely build communication with colleagues and students;
  • and mobility—even the pandemic has not negated this positive aspect.

Many students choose a career in science, becoming part of a strong scientific school during their studies. This is especially true for representatives of the natural and exact sciences at the country's leading universities. There are also examples of people who came to science from the business sector. Their decision to move to academia is often driven by three main factors: freedom of scientific inquiry, the ability to communicate effectively, and flexibility in choosing research directions.

Still: film "Substitute Teacher"

A study of the personnel policies of universities has revealed key aspects that They rely on these principles when developing their teams. The primary focus is on developing highly qualified personnel, which is achieved through ongoing training and professional development. Universities also emphasize creating a favorable work environment, which contributes to increased employee satisfaction and motivation. Furthermore, attracting young specialists and implementing innovative approaches to personnel management are essential for successfully building teams. Thus, the universities' HR policies are aimed at sustainable development and improving the effectiveness of the educational process. The "5-100" Project marked an important stage in the development of Russian universities, facilitating the creation of specialized departments for developing human resources potential. As part of this project, universities began implementing programs aimed at developing existing employees and attracting new specialists. To achieve these goals, various methods were used, including consulting and programs developed at the Skolkovo School of Management. One of the most well-known initiatives is the "Rectors' School" program, but specialized programs were also developed to improve the qualifications of university faculty involved in the "5-100" Project. An important area of ​​focus was the creation of internal talent pool programs, which enabled the effective utilization of existing staff. At the same time, emphasis was placed on attracting new highly qualified faculty, such as postdocs, which contributed to the enrichment of the university's academic staff and improved the quality of education.

The new HR and personnel administration services faced a number of challenges. One of the main difficulties was the non-compliance of certain processes with current legislation at various levels. This led to internal conflicts between personnel development specialists and those responsible for process administration. Furthermore, conflicts even arose within a single department dealing with HR issues. Such situations require a careful approach to improve the effectiveness of HR services and ensure compliance with all legal regulations.

The academic market in Russia is still in its infancy. Inbreeding, a problem faced by many educational institutions, remains a pressing issue. Universities are striving to enhance the attractiveness of their job offers and to increase competition for teaching and research positions. However, in practice, high competition is rarely observed even at universities participating in the "5-100" project.

In recent years, most higher education institutions have eliminated separate HR departments. HR processes are now integrated into other business processes, such as education, research, and innovation. For example, a specialist in scientific policy is responsible for attracting scientists, while an educational policy coordinator is responsible for attracting faculty. Whether this is a positive or negative outcome remains to be seen. Personally, I believe this is not the best approach: research and educational processes are beginning to separate again. In our research, we found that most universities have criteria for assessing, hiring, and selecting researchers, and are also seeking forms and methods for assessing faculty performance. However, issues related to assessing the performance of administrative and managerial personnel remain unresolved. This can negatively impact the effectiveness of educational institutions and undermine their standing in education and research.

During the study, we provided practical recommendations to universities. These recommendations were aimed at improving educational processes and enhancing the quality of education. We emphasized the implementation of modern technologies, curriculum optimization, and strengthening interactions with employers. This approach allows universities to more successfully adapt to labor market demands and enhance the competitiveness of their graduates.

We primarily focused on analyzing the "Organizational Culture" section. In addition to interviews based on the approved guide, we use specialized methods to assess the level of organizational culture. One such method is Prigogine's "Metapore" method, in which the respondent creates a drawing reflecting their perception of the university. We carefully interpret the results and formulate recommendations, emphasizing key aspects of management interaction with the staff. This allows for a deeper understanding of the organization's internal atmosphere and the identification of areas for improvement.

"A university person is someone who transforms the environment around them"

How were the project results different from your expectations?

Attitudes toward the 5-100 project turned out to be multifaceted and contradictory. Many university employees actually support the program. Even after its completion, they emphasize that the project was successful and that a number of its positive aspects should be retained within the Priority program.

The second aspect concerns the perception of the teaching profession. We were of the opinion that universities retain a significant Soviet legacy and a corresponding attitude among teachers towards their role. However, this was not confirmed. Modern educators are demonstrating a more open and progressive attitude toward their profession, adapting to new educational standards and the demands of the times.

The third striking aspect is that many respondents demonstrate a willingness to truly internationalize and engage with the international community. These individuals strive to find colleagues abroad, create joint projects, and move from declarative statements about global excellence to proactive action. This openness to collaboration and exchange of experience can significantly enrich their professional practice and facilitate the development of new ideas in a global context.

Unpleasant moments associated with information bubbles also arise during work. Often, too much attention is paid to unimportant issues, distracting employees from the real challenges of their projects. Many employees report actively solving important problems and achieving significant results, yet public attention is focused on events unrelated to their efforts. This phenomenon is a consequence of universities' desire for openness and media visibility, which generates hype around topics that generate greater media interest but do not reflect the reality of their work.

The "5-100" Project has a number of shortcomings, including difficulties in predicting medium- and long-term results. Insufficient information and understanding of the nature of the changes underway are also noted. An emphasis on rankings often comes at the expense of addressing national issues, and the priority given to research can negatively impact the educational process. These factors require careful analysis to improve the project's effectiveness and achieve its goals.

Universities should preserve key elements of 20th-century university culture, such as the value of academic freedom, traditions of scientific exchange, and interdisciplinary collaboration. These aspects contribute not only to high-quality education but also to the development of critical thinking in students. It is also important to preserve the spirit of openness and inclusiveness that characterized universities of the past. The transformation of educational processes should not violate these traditions, as they form the foundation for future scientific and cultural progress. Preserving historical heritage and cultural traditions helps universities remain competitive and attractive to students, providing them with the opportunity to receive a quality education in a rapidly changing world. Universities need to maintain a culture of innovation, which implies the ability to create new knowledge and, based on it, develop technologies that help improve the quality of life and human interaction with the environment. "University man" is someone who makes changes to the surrounding reality. Supporting a culture of innovation and active work in educational institutions is essential for the development of progressive thinking and the effective solution of modern challenges. As professional activity develops, changes in established norms inevitably occur. This has always been relevant and will continue. However, the emergence of something new does not necessarily imply a complete rejection of the old. For example, I positively evaluate the lecture form of education. A teacher must have the ability to clearly and engagingly present material for an hour and a half. It's important not only to have a topic for discussion but also to use methods that foster student engagement. This skill is key, as lecturing presents a significant challenge. Sometimes, conducting ten seminars is easier than preparing and delivering one high-quality lecture. The ability to maintain audience attention and effectively convey knowledge is the foundation of successful learning. The issue isn't about abandoning anything, but rather about our attitude toward existing forms. We can both invent new ones and transform existing ones. Let's return to the concept of "university man": if we view him positively, he truly transforms life and creates something new. Moreover, the norms and mechanisms he uses are adaptable. This allows us not only to preserve traditions, but also to introduce innovations, which contributes to the development of society and the educational environment.

Read also:

  • Should in-person lectures at universities be cancelled?
  • Why do universities need management competency centers?
  • Digital transformation plan for higher education
  • What has the experience of distance learning given to university teachers?