Code

How to Protect a Computer Program

How to Protect a Computer Program

Free Python course ➞ A mini-course for beginners and experienced coders. 4 cool projects for your portfolio, live communication with the speaker. Click and find out what you can learn in the course.

Learn more

In the previous article, we discussed why computer programs are protected through copyright and analyzed the relevant legal precedent.

In this article, I will continue the discussion of software protection through intellectual property law. I will consider the tools of patent law, as well as their advantages and disadvantages. Software patents offer developers protection against the unauthorized use of their ideas and technologies. However, the process of obtaining a patent can be complex and expensive. It is important to keep in mind that not all types of software are eligible for patent protection, and this can limit developers' options. Patenting can provide a competitive advantage, but it can also lead to legal disputes and the need for ongoing monitoring for infringement. In this context, understanding the nuances of patent law is key to successfully protecting your software products.

Protection of program algorithms

In legal literature, it is often stated that an algorithm can be considered an idea, but it is more correctly defined as a method for solving problems faced by a developer. The concept of "method" is directly related to the objects of patent law. According to the Civil Code, an invention is recognized as a technical solution related to a product or method in any field. A patent for a method protects the sequence of actions performed by a program. This process is divided into logical stages, which describe in detail the operation of the algorithm embedded in the software. Thus, a correct understanding of an algorithm as a method for solving problems is key to its legal protection.

According to Russian legislation, some objects cannot be recognized as inventions. Such objects include:

— discovery, that is, the identification of previously unknown natural phenomena or patterns;
— scientific theories and mathematical methods;
— aesthetic and artistic solutions, including literary and artistic works;
— computer programs, if they do not contain technical solutions;
— methods of carrying out activities that are not of a technical nature, such as business management or organizational structures;
— biological processes related to the production of plants or animals, if they do not include technical means.

These limitations are important for understanding which developments can be protected by patents and how to properly file invention applications.

  • a computer program as a whole;
  • a mathematical method as such;
  • rules and methods of games, intellectual or economic activity;
  • solutions that consist only of presenting information.

Computer programs are protected by copyright, which provides their copyright holders with exclusive rights to use and distribute. It is important to note that, unlike other intellectual property, such as design solutions, programs cannot be protected by patents. This limitation is due to the specific features of the software and its functionality, which makes copyright the only means of protection. Properly registering copyright for software products helps prevent unauthorized use and copying, which is especially important in a rapidly evolving technology market.

In the 21st century, using computers and smartphones has become a daily norm for most people. In this context, companies are increasingly protecting their software products and their components with patents. However, approaches to intellectual property protection vary across countries. For example, in the United States, software is protected by both patents and copyright, providing a broader range of protection for developers and organizations. This difference in legislation highlights the importance of understanding intellectual property law, especially for companies operating internationally.

Russia and the European Union recognize copyright in software, but it is possible to patent individual components, including ideas and algorithms. Patent protection for computer programs and their components remains one of the most complex and controversial areas of intellectual property law globally. It is important to consider that effective intellectual property protection in the software field requires a careful approach to choosing protection methods in order to minimize risks and provide legal guarantees for developers.

Patent law does not extend to mathematical algorithms, laws of nature, and other abstract concepts without practical implementation. Therefore, it is impossible to obtain a patent for software elements that perform exclusively computational functions or serve as a means of automating various processes and business methods. This limitation is important to consider when developing and protecting intellectual property in the field of information technology.

The plot-role-playing part of the algorithm of a computer game, known as gameplay, is not subject to patenting. Also, the mathematical part of the information processing algorithm is not protected by patents unless it is associated with specific tangible objects. In addition, new accounting methods cannot be patented either.

In the United States, the possibility of patenting business methods exists, which has generated interest and discussion in legal circles. However, in disputed cases, US courts may interpret the validity of such patents differently. This creates uncertainty for entrepreneurs seeking to protect their innovative ideas. Patenting business methods in the US remains a hot topic, requiring attention and analysis in terms of legal implications and commercial viability.

How to file an application with Rospatent

To protect the idea and essence of a program through patent law, you must demonstrate that your algorithm is patentable. This means that it must meet the criteria of novelty, inventive step, and industrial applicability. Securing patent protection for your algorithm will help prevent its unauthorized use and provide you with exclusive rights to its commercial use. Understanding these criteria is an important step in the patenting process, as they determine the feasibility of obtaining a patent and its legal force.

To file an application with Rospatent, you must submit the appropriate document and pay the state fee for its consideration. In the description of the invention, it is important to clearly reflect the logical chain: the purpose of the invention, its features, and the expected technical result. This helps demonstrate the connection between the technical result and the features set out in the claims.

Once a patent application is filed, its priority takes effect. This means that similar applications filed later will be rejected. Therefore, no one will be able to patent your idea or algorithm, protecting your intellectual property. Understanding this mechanism is important for developers and inventors seeking to protect their innovative developments.

An invention application undergoes two main examinations: formal and substantive. The formal examination involves checking the application documents for completeness and accuracy. This process evaluates whether the claimed subject matter qualifies as an invention. If Rospatent examiners have questions or comments, the applicant may be asked to clarify or supplement the application. The applicant also has the right to make changes without affecting the claims. After successfully passing the formal examination, Rospatent publishes information about the claims and grants temporary protection, which is valid until the patent is granted. This procedure is important for protecting intellectual property and provides the applicant with legal protection while awaiting a final decision.

The substantive examination plays a key role in assessing the patentability of an invention. During this procedure, the level of inventiveness and the extent of disclosure of the invention claims are analyzed. A patent is granted only if the examination results are positive, which underscores the importance of this stage in the patenting process. Conducting a substantive examination helps determine whether the invention meets the criteria of novelty and originality, which are fundamental for the protection of intellectual property.

A substantive examination is carried out at the applicant's request. If the applicant is satisfied with the temporary protection for the invention, they may waive this examination.

At the final stage, Rospatent makes the final decision on granting a patent. The applicant is obliged to pay a fee at each stage of the application processing, including the filing, substantive examination, and patent issuance stages. This obligation is important for the successful completion of the patent process and the protection of intellectual property.

In practice, it is possible to patent both a method and a device that uses a computer program. As a result, a patent is issued for a device that includes a program considered an invention or utility model. Obtaining a utility model patent is easier because the law does not require an inventive step, but such protection is limited to the device with the embedded program. If you need to protect the program independently of the device or together with it, you should file a patent for an invention. This will provide broader protection and allow the program to be used in different contexts.

Pros and Cons of Patent Protection

The advantages of this method are worth considering. This method offers many positive aspects that can significantly simplify the performance of tasks. It allows you to save time and resources, improves process efficiency and increases overall productivity. This approach also helps reduce errors and simplify work, making it especially attractive to users looking to optimize their actions. Let's take a closer look at the specific benefits that can be obtained by using this method.

A patent protects the specific content of your invention. In the context of an algorithm, this means the sequence of actions performed by software. It is important to describe this process in detail in the patent application to ensure intellectual property protection. Proper execution and a clear presentation of the algorithm significantly increase the chances of successfully obtaining a patent.

A patent grants a monopoly on an invention, with several exceptions set out in Articles 1359–1361 of the Civil Code. These exceptions include the use of the invention for personal purposes or for scientific research. In other situations, a patent prevents others from patenting similar solutions or using them without the patent owner's permission. This protects the patent holder's interests and promotes innovation by ensuring that developed technologies are not illegally used by competitors.

Patents significantly increase the value of a company's intangible assets. They can be used within the company's own business or provided to other companies for a fee. To do this, the patent holder enters into a licensing agreement with the user of the invention. Furthermore, patents are usually easily sold, making them an attractive asset for investors and entrepreneurs. Effective patent management enhances a company's competitiveness and opens up new opportunities for monetizing intellectual property.

Patents are an important tool for attracting investment and obtaining grants. Access to funding from public and private foundations often requires a patent for a developed technical result. Obtaining a patent not only protects intellectual property but also increases the trust of investors and grantors, which can significantly increase the chances of successful funding.

Patent protection has certain drawbacks. Despite its benefits, such as protecting intellectual property and stimulating innovation, it can also create difficulties for developers and businesses. Obtaining a patent often requires significant time and financial investment. Furthermore, prolonged patent protection can lead to monopolization of technologies, limiting access to them for other market participants. It is also worth considering that patents can become the subject of disputes, which further increases the risks for owners. It is important to weigh all aspects of patent protection to make an informed decision about the need for it in a particular situation.

High Costs. Applicants face significant legal fees associated with patenting, averaging between 80,000 and 200,000 rubles. Additionally, government fees must be factored in at all stages of the patenting process, as well as subsequent patent maintenance costs. These financial obligations can significantly increase the overall cost of obtaining and maintaining a patent, which is important to consider when planning a patent strategy.

Obtaining a patent is a lengthy process. On average, it takes 18 months to two years from filing an application to receiving a patent. During this time, technologies may become obsolete, which can negatively impact the relevance of your development.

Patent searches and application preparation are complex tasks. Public information about a patent can create a competitive advantage for other companies, which discourages applicants from disclosing the patent claims in detail. The first complication is the need to file an application that will not be invalidated due to a overlap with an already registered patent. The second challenge is balancing sufficient patent disclosure for successful registration with protection against competitors' circumvention, which can occur if the claims are described in excessive detail. It is important to consider these aspects to ensure reliable legal protection and minimize risks during the patenting process.

Territorial boundaries of patent protection. To obtain a patent, you must apply to the patent office of each country in which you intend to use your device or method. International agreements that simplify the patenting process abroad can assist in this process. These agreements promote more effective intellectual property protection and reduce the time and cost of patent registration in different countries.

Difficulties of judicial protection in Russia. Disputes between copyright holders are most often resolved out of court, including through consideration of cases in the Chamber of Patent Disputes. Judicial practice in this area remains limited, which complicates conflict resolution. A lack of case law impacts the development of law enforcement practices and increases uncertainty for market participants.

The main difficulty lies in identifying and confirming patent infringement, especially if the program operates not on a single device, but in a client-server architecture. This technology is widely used to process user requests online. As a result, the copyright holder may not have access to all devices using this technology, complicating the process of proving infringement. Therefore, in the case of multi-tiered systems, it is necessary to develop effective strategies for monitoring and protecting intellectual property.

The copyright holder of the content is JSC Kaspersky Lab. This organization develops solutions in the field of information security and data protection. JSC Kaspersky Lab offers a wide range of products and services aimed at protecting users from cyberthreats. We recommend that you familiarize yourself with their offerings to enhance the security of your devices and data.

The patent for the system and method for treating website content represents an innovative solution for improving the quality and efficiency of web resources. This patent covers methods for analyzing and optimizing content, making it more relevant and appealing to users. This system is based on algorithms that automatically identify weaknesses in content, providing recommendations for improvement. This not only increases website traffic but also improves its ranking in search engines. Using the patent significantly improves user experience and engagement, which in turn contributes to increased conversion and the success of the online resource.

An antivirus program is software designed to protect computers and mobile devices from malicious programs such as viruses, Trojans, spyware, and other threats. The main task of an antivirus is to detect, block, and remove malware, as well as to ensure the security of user data.

Modern antivirus solutions use a variety of protection methods, including signature analysis, heuristic scanning, and behavioral analysis. These technologies not only detect known threats but also prevent attacks from new, unidentified viruses.

It is important to regularly update your antivirus software to ensure up-to-date protection against the consequences of cyberattacks. In addition, many antivirus programs offer additional features such as firewalls, antiphishing, password managers, and online privacy protection tools.

Having a reliable antivirus program is essential for the security of any device, especially in the face of the ever-increasing number of cyberthreats. Investing in a high-quality antivirus solution helps protect not only personal data but also important business resources.

Copyright holder: Yandex Limited Liability Company.

Patent for a method for processing a search query and the associated server. This patent describes innovative technologies that enable the efficient processing of user search queries. The method includes algorithms that optimize information search, increasing the speed and accuracy of result delivery. The server mentioned in the patent provides high performance and reliability, making it ideal for scalable search engines. The technologies presented in the patent can be applied in various fields, including web search, databases, and information systems, making them relevant to modern data processing requirements.

The invention consists of creating a search engine that provides fast and efficient access to information on the internet. The main goal of this system is to optimize the search process, allowing users to find the necessary information with minimal time investment. A modern search engine uses advanced algorithms and technologies to analyze and index web pages, which allows it to return the most relevant results to user queries. An important aspect of a search engine's operation is its ability to adapt to changes in content and user behavior, which ensures continuous improvement in search quality. Thanks to an intuitive interface and advanced filtering capabilities, users can easily find the data they need, making this invention an indispensable tool in the digital world.

Copyright holders of works are the individuals who author them. These authors have exclusive rights to their creations, allowing them to control the use and distribution of their works. Copyright protection ensures the opportunity to receive compensation for labor and creative efforts and promotes the development of culture and art. Copyright holders can transfer their rights to others, but the primary right of authorship always remains with them.

A patent for a method for scaling a distributed information system. This method effectively increases the performance and manageability of distributed systems, ensuring their reliability and stability. This technology optimizes data processing, increases access speed, and reduces infrastructure costs. This solution is relevant for organizations seeking to improve their IT systems and adapt to growing volumes of information. The development of this patent opens new opportunities for the implementation of advanced technologies in distributed computing and big data processing.

The essence of the invention lies in the development of a platform with a multi-tier structure consisting of interconnected blockchain networks. This innovative architecture ensures effective interaction between the various levels of the system, which optimizes processes and improves data security. The multi-tier structure of blockchain networks facilitates greater scalability and flexibility, making the platform an ideal solution for various industries.

When a patent is denied: the position of Rospatent and the Intellectual Property Court

In this article, we will consider an example from judicial practice concerning the problems of software patenting in Russia. Software patenting in our country is a complex process caused by legislative uncertainty and differences in the interpretation of patent law.

In practice, disputes often arise regarding the novelty and uniqueness of software solutions, which complicates obtaining patents. Court proceedings can concern both patent refusals and challenges to issued patents. These cases highlight the need for a clear understanding of the criteria by which the patentability of software is assessed.

Problems of software patenting in Russia are also associated with insufficient legal protection of intellectual property in this area. As a result, software developers may face risks of copyright infringement, which negatively impacts innovation and the development of the IT industry in the country.

Thus, an analysis of judicial practice shows that successful software patenting in Russia requires taking into account numerous factors and carefully preparing documents. This will minimize the risks of refusals and litigation, as well as protect your developments in the market.

Minister L. initiated the process of obtaining a patent for a group of inventions concerning a "Computer system and data management method." This development is aimed at optimizing the processing and management of information in computer systems, which can significantly improve work efficiency in various fields. Patenting such technologies promotes the protection of intellectual property and supports their further development in the field of information technology.

The technical result of this invention is to expand functionality and improve the arsenal of technical means, which contributes to increased reliability, security, and manufacturability of computer systems. However, Rospatent concluded that the submitted invention claims lacked novelty, which served as grounds for refusing registration. Citizen L. challenged the decision of Rospatent's Patent Dispute Chamber (PDC) in the Intellectual Property Court after receiving a negative opinion on his application. Filing a lawsuit is an important step in protecting intellectual property and allows one to challenge decisions that could negatively impact patent rights. The Intellectual Property Court dismissed the applicant's appeal challenging Rospatent's decision as unlawful. During the hearing, the court found that L.'s proposed solution merely represented a specific grouping of data stored in a storage device. The achievement of the claimed result is conditioned solely by the manner in which the information was presented, which, under current legislation, cannot be qualified as an invention.

The Presidium of the Intellectual Property Court, acting as the cassation court, overturned Rospatent's decision.

The cassation court identified procedural violations during the application's consideration by Rospatent, the Patent Dispute Chamber, and the Intellectual Property Court. The key points are that, if there are doubts about the patentability of a decision, Rospatent is obliged to request the necessary information from the applicant. The Patent Dispute Chamber must carefully analyze the applicant's arguments, including arguments regarding previously issued patents for inventions in the same category. If the Intellectual Property Court engages a specialist to evaluate the application, it must obtain a reasoned opinion on the claimed invention claims. This highlights the importance of following due process to ensure a fair and reasonable review of patent applications.

The case we are examining is notable because Rospatent's refusal is a common practice for software patent applications. Although the cassation court upheld the applicant, this decision was based on formal grounds. Ultimately, the applicant was never granted a patent. This case highlights the complexities and specifics of the software patenting process in Russia, which are important to consider when filing applications.

If you are planning to begin the process of patenting a software algorithm, it is important to carefully study the relevant materials. Review not only Part 4 of the Civil Code but also applications already registered with Rospatent. This will help you better understand how the patent system functions and increase your chances of successfully obtaining a patent. Understanding existing patents and applications will help you avoid mistakes and file your application correctly.

What's Next

In the next article, we'll discuss interface protection using a design patent. We'll also look at case studies from both domestic and international companies. Design patenting is an important tool for protecting unique designs and interfaces, allowing companies to maintain a competitive advantage. We will analyze successful cases and share recommendations for effective intellectual property protection in this area.