Contents:
- Vladislav Baimurzin
- Preparatory part
- Evaluate the sales market
- Evaluate the capital market
- Evaluate the start-up resources
- Evaluate the involvement of the project founders
- Evaluate the investments for the release of the first version of the product
- Calculate the number of advantages over competitors
- Evaluate the threshold for entry into business
- Calculate result
- Final part

Free Python Course ➞ Mini-course for beginners and experienced coders. 4 cool projects in the portfolio, live communication with the speaker. Click and find out what you can learn in the course.
Learn more
Vladislav Baimurzin
An expert is a specialist with deep knowledge and skills in a specific field. Experts often play a key role in decision-making and strategy formation based on their experience and analysis. They can work in a variety of fields, such as finance, marketing, technology, medicine, and many others. The role of an expert is not only to provide advice but also to teach, research, and develop new approaches. It is important to note that experts help not only companies but also individuals, providing them with valuable recommendations and advice. Having an expert on a team significantly increases the chances of successfully completing projects and achieving goals.
About the Author
The author of this text is an experienced specialist in his field, possessing deep knowledge and skills. He actively shares his thoughts and ideas through publications that help readers better understand complex topics and make informed decisions. The author's work covers various aspects, including research, analysis, and practical recommendations. Thanks to his experience and professionalism, the author has become a trusted source of information for many seeking self-development and understanding of current issues. My eight years of experience in startups includes participation in hackathons and business incubators, IT project evaluation, investment raising, team building, and company management. My professional path covers key aspects of startup development, allowing me to effectively implement innovative ideas and achieve success in a competitive market. Links play an important role on the web, providing connections between various pages and resources. They help users easily find the information they need and navigate the site. Internal links contribute to a better site structure, and external links can increase its authority in the eyes of search engines. Proper use of anchor texts and their optimization for keywords also contribute to improved SEO. Ensure that all links on your site are working correctly to avoid 404 errors, which can negatively impact user experience and search engine rankings. High-quality and relevant links not only help with promotion, but also in building trust with visitors.
Many startups fail due to a weak initial idea. This happens when a team develops a product that doesn't generate interest from consumers or doesn't meet their needs. To avoid such mistakes, I focus on selecting viable ideas at an early stage. In this article, I will share an effective methodology that will help prevent failures and create more competitive solutions in the market.
You will receive information about:
- why test a startup idea and what it means;
- how to test a startup without investment with just one test;
- what to do if you come up with a profitable idea, but don't want to launch the project.
Preparatory part
When evaluating a startup idea, I focus on commercial attractiveness, analyzing the earning potential of the project. At the initial stage, I don't delve into details, don't conduct paid research, and don't consider organizational or technical challenges. My goal is to determine the idea's potential for market and profitability before moving on to deeper analysis and strategy development.
The goal of this process is to conduct a quick and free intelligence test. If the startup passes this test, I continue evaluating it. Otherwise, I don't waste time on further testing. This approach can be compared to a multi-level conveyor belt that sorts large volumes of ore to extract precious metals. This method allows you to effectively filter potentially successful projects, focusing on those that have the highest chance of success.

The need to test some aspects of a startup may be overestimated. In this case, interviews with the target audience, creating a free prototype, or a landing page with an empty product are not mandatory steps. Basic knowledge and understanding of the market on which the startup idea was based are sufficient. The main thing is confidence in your proposal and an understanding of the needs of potential customers.
We will not discuss the rare cases when crazy ideas lead to the creation of trillion-dollar corporations. It is possible, but the secret of such success remains unknown.
How it works. I invite you to complete the instructions in the format of a simple test consisting of seven steps. At each step, select one or more answer options in the range from -3 to 3. After calculating the points, you will receive one of three possible results. This test will help you better understand your preferences and areas for further development.
The results of the points scored are deciphered immediately after the instructions are provided.
I propose considering an idea for training using the example of a fictitious startup. We will evaluate its concept by calculating intermediate points for each point of the instructions, and then summarize the results and draw conclusions. The main idea is to develop a cyberdog and a search neural network designed to hunt for white truffles.
Such a startup can combine innovative technologies and traditional truffle search methods, making it attractive to the market. The cyberdog will use special sensors and algorithms to locate truffles, and the neural network will be able to analyze data on soil, climate, and other factors affecting the growth of these delicacies.
Thus, this project has potential not only in agriculture but also in high technology, which opens up broad opportunities for its further development and commercialization. Ultimately, having assessed all aspects of the idea, one can draw a conclusion about its viability and market prospects.
The white truffle is a unique and expensive delicacy, with prices ranging from 2,000 to 4,000 euros per kilogram. The price of these mushrooms can increase significantly depending on their size and quality. For example, in 2007, a record-breaking case was recorded when a 1.5-kilogram white truffle sold for $330,000. This mushroom is prized not only for its rich flavor and aroma, but also for its rarity, making it a true delicacy for gourmets and collectors.
Truffles are found using trained dogs that are capable of detecting this valuable mushroom. However, I am confident that the use of big data and robotics can significantly improve the efficiency of truffle searches compared to traditional methods. In this context, I plan to develop an innovative product that will allow me to corner the truffle industry. It remains to be seen how successful this project will be.

Evaluate the sales market
The sales market is the geographic area where the product will be sold. It is important for founders not only to have a desire to sell in a certain region, but also to have a deep understanding of the peculiarities of this market. This includes an analysis of social, religious and cultural factors, as well as other aspects that may affect sales success. A clear understanding of these nuances will allow you to more effectively adapt your sales and marketing strategy, which in turn will increase the chances of successful product introduction in the chosen market.
Marvel Studios regularly creates multiple versions of its films, including one for international release and another adapted specifically for China. The Chinese version often includes additional scenes featuring local celebrities who interact with the main characters. This approach not only increases viewer interest but also contributes to increased box office revenue, making it an effective strategy for attracting audiences in this important market.
3 points. The most solvent audiences are concentrated in China, the United States, and the European Union. These first-tier markets are characterized by a high concentration of capital, investors, and numerous opportunities for business growth. If a startup aims to operate in one of these regions, I give its idea the highest score.
Second-tier markets include countries such as Australia, Canada, India, Japan, and Dubai. These regions have significant financial potential and developing economies, making them attractive for investment. Despite the availability of sufficient capital, the conditions for scaling a business in these countries may not be optimal. Here, it is important to consider local economic and legislative features, which can affect the growth and development of companies.
I do not like the concept of a startup that is focused on the global market from the very beginning. A broad geography of the launch means that the founder cannot focus on their target audience. This makes it difficult to understand where the greatest demand lies and to identify regions that are unprofitable. Focusing on a narrow market segment allows for a more effective analysis of customer needs and optimization of the business model.
Tier 3 markets include regions such as Russia, Africa, Latin America, and Eastern Europe. These countries are characterized by low purchasing power and inadequate conditions for business development. In such regions, entrepreneurs often face economic difficulties, which significantly complicates project implementation and limits investment opportunities. Given these factors, it is important to carefully analyze the market and adapt strategies to successfully compete and find paths to growth in a resource-constrained environment.
If at least one of the company's founders previously resided in the target market but subsequently moved to another country, this represents an increased risk. Local culture can undergo changes, and it is important to stay informed about these transformations. Continuous contact with the target audience is crucial for a successful business.
If none of the startup founders have experience living in the target market, this is a serious cause for concern. Most likely, the team is unfamiliar with the specifics of the region and made a decision without in-depth analysis. Understanding the local context and user needs is critical to successful business development.
I give our fictional startup a two-star rating. I award one star for its broad geographic reach, as potential customers could be restaurants all over the world. However, I would add minus three stars to this rating, since we are aiming to enter a first-tier market but do not have a clear understanding of its specifics. All the founders are from Russia and have no experience living abroad, which creates additional difficulties in understanding the international market.
Evaluate the capital market
Analyze the sales of competitors to find out their revenue from goods that are substitutes for your product. Substitutes are products or services with similar characteristics and functions. For example, instead of an iPhone, a consumer might choose Xiaomi. Understanding the substitute market will help you develop an effective promotion and pricing strategy for your product, as well as identify opportunities to improve your offering.
Determine annual revenue using data from available public sources or reports from major research agencies operating in a specific market. This data will help you gain an accurate understanding of the financial situation and competitive landscape in your industry.
An increase in the number of substitutes and an increase in annual revenue indicate a stable and developing capital market. These are positive indicators that point to a healthy competitive environment and investment potential. High revenue can also attract new investors, which further strengthens the market.
If a product has numerous substitutes and its revenue exceeds a billion dollars, this indicates high demand for it. Consumers are interested in high-quality new products and are willing to invest in products even from unfamiliar brands.
With moderate demand for a product, one can expect up to ten substitutes, as well as revenue of up to $500,000 per year. This creates a promising market with a loyal audience. However, entrepreneurs may face difficulties in positioning and promoting their startup. It is important to develop an effective marketing strategy and a unique selling proposition to stand out from the competition and attract the attention of the target audience.
Low market demand is characterized by two key indicators: first, there are no more than three substitutes for the product on the market, and second, there are no sales statistics available in public sources. In such conditions, a startup faces an unprepared audience, which must convincingly demonstrate the value of its product and its advantages over competitors. Effective marketing strategies and clear communication will help overcome these barriers and attract consumers to the new offering.
Zero points. I'm skeptical of unique products that have no analogues or competitors. Business is based on consumer needs: when a person experiences a shortage, entrepreneurs step up, offering solutions. Without competition, a product can struggle because there's no market feedback or room for improvement. Successful businesses thrive by analyzing needs and the competitive environment, allowing them to adapt and grow.
New products are often improved versions of existing solutions: they're more convenient, affordable, and technologically advanced. When a unique product, previously unparalleled, enters the market, consumers may not show interest, and significant time and resources are required to promote it. This strategy is often impractical for startups that need to quickly adapt to consumer needs and the market.
We present a unique product and give the startup a zero. It's unclear why no one has yet combined robots and neural networks to effectively find valuable resources. It's possible that such technologies already exist, but for some reason remain outside the public domain. We can't say for sure.
Evaluate your start-up resources
Start-up resources include funding, equipment, and a team of specialists who will develop the product. A lack of these resources can negatively impact the quality and success of the project. The more start-up resources you have, the higher your chances of successfully completing development and entering the market.
A startup has equipment and qualified specialists, but faces a lack of investment. This is a relatively safe approach to launching a business, as investors prefer to work with professionals capable of creating value. Having an experienced team and the necessary infrastructure significantly increases the chances of successfully raising funding and implementing the project.
A startup has qualified specialists, but lacks the investment and necessary equipment for a successful launch. The situation is similar to the previous one, but the team will need to further demonstrate its professionalism. If investors are familiar with an existing portfolio, this will significantly increase the chances of attracting funding. Having high-quality projects and successful cases can play a key role in attracting investment and providing the startup with the necessary resources for growth and development.
A startup has equipment, but will need to attract specialists and investment. The key factor is the quality and cost of the equipment. If it is expensive, valuable, and in good condition, this will be a strong argument for potential investors. Otherwise, if you only have outdated office equipment, investors may view such equipment as useless junk. Proper valuation and presentation of a startup's assets can play a decisive role in successfully raising funding.
At the early stages, a startup often faces a lack of key resources. They lack the necessary equipment, qualified specialists, useful contacts, and investment. Furthermore, the startup may lack relevant experience in implementing similar projects. In such circumstances, the only assets left are an idea and a PDF presentation. However, such projects usually fail to attract interest from investors and partners. To attract attention, a startup needs to develop its resources and accumulate experience, which will increase its chances of success.
Our startup is still at the concept stage. We have a brief description of the idea, an image, and the desire to launch successfully. However, our initial resources are estimated to be zero. We are looking for ways to develop and implement our idea to turn it into a profitable project.
Evaluate the involvement of the project founders
The level of involvement in a startup depends on the number of participants willing to actively work on its idea, as well as the time they are willing to devote to it. Both of these factors directly affect the speed of development and the sustainability of the project. The more participants and more time, the faster and more efficiently the startup is implemented. It is important that the team is motivated and goal-oriented, as this contributes not only to the rapid achievement of results but also to an increased chance of successful completion of the project.
High involvement in a project is achieved when the team has more than three founders, each of whom is ready to fully devote themselves to working on the idea. Part-time jobs, participation in other startups, and hired work are excluded. This approach confirms confidence in the project and the desire for a successful outcome. Full commitment from the founders fosters more effective teamwork and accelerates goal achievement.
Average team engagement is rated at 2 points when there are at least two founders, and one of them is fully dedicated to the project. It is important that if one founder is underperforming, they have the ability to quickly bring in other founders, who may be working part-time, or delegate their responsibilities to hired employees. This approach promotes team flexibility and efficiency, which is key to the project's successful development.
Low engagement in a startup occurs when there are multiple founders on the team, but none of them dedicates their full time to the project. In such an environment, there are no hired employees, and the founders work on the project only in their free time—during vacations, weekends, or after work on weekdays. This limits the project's development and reduces its chances of success. To increase engagement, founders should consider dedicating more time to the project or bringing in additional resources, which can accelerate the process of achieving the startup's goals. Zero engagement in a startup is characterized by a situation where there is only one founder on the team. This founder works on the project in their free time, significantly limiting the potential for growth and development of the business. In such an environment, the startup faces difficulties in attracting investment, building a team, and implementing ideas, as the lack of active participation from several team members reduces overall momentum and efficiency. To increase engagement and the chances of success, it is important to expand the team by attracting like-minded individuals willing to actively participate in the project. I am planning to launch a startup alone, without a team or co-founders. I do not plan to quit my current job, so all development will take place in my free time. This implies a low level of commitment and no points for this criterion.
Estimate investments for releasing the first version of the product
When analyzing a startup from an entrepreneur's perspective, it is critical to estimate upcoming expenses before the first sales. You need to understand what specific costs are expected: will these be investments in equipment, team building, or marketing campaigns. It is also important to understand how well the team understands the necessary financial resources. Clear budgeting will help avoid unforeseen situations and ensure a successful business launch.
A team that received a score of 3 has basic resources and needs funding of up to $100,000 to cover operating expenses. These funds are needed to pay salaries, pay taxes, purchase raw materials, and other ongoing costs. The team actively attracts investment, develops a product, and immediately begins sales, which allows them to effectively use the funds received and grow the business.
The team receives 2 points for raising up to $500,000 needed to cover operating expenses and purchase equipment. These funds allow the team to purchase and configure the necessary equipment, as well as develop the product and bring it to market. Proper financial and resource management contributes to the successful implementation of the project and the achievement of the set goals.
A team with a budget of up to $100 million will allocate funds to operating expenses, equipment purchases, and marketing. Advertising is a key element for successful sales, so about 50% of the budget will be allocated to it. After receiving investment, the team will be able to purchase and configure the necessary equipment, develop the product, and launch advertising campaigns to attract customers. Effective use of the budget and a competent marketing strategy will help achieve the set business goals and ensure the company's growth.
The team cannot clearly define the required amount of funding and the purposes for which it will be used. This indicates insufficient preparation of the founders, who do not understand the specifics of the market. As a result, they plan to compete with established companies without a clear strategy and understanding of their advantages. Without market analysis and financial planning, the chances of success are significantly reduced.
We can contact Boston Dynamics for information on the cost of a cyberdog. However, this is only one aspect of the costs. It is more difficult to estimate the costs of developing a search neural network, which leads us to uncertainty in the final amount. Therefore, we are faced with a lack of information to accurately estimate all related costs.
Count the number of advantages over competitors
A competitive advantage is any benefit that can be justified to investors. For example, having a larger number of suppliers allows you to offer lower prices compared to competitors. This is a clear competitive advantage that can attract customers and increase market share.
If you are developing a platform from scratch in Kotlin, viewing this as a competitive advantage, it is important to understand that not all investors will appreciate your technical solutions. You can expect a reactive architecture and improved performance, but these aspects may not be immediately apparent to potential investors. They often focus on more familiar criteria, such as market potential, customer demand, and financial metrics. Therefore, to attract investment, it's essential to not only demonstrate technical advantages but also clearly communicate to investors how these innovations will impact the project's success and competitiveness in the market.
A startup receives a score of 3 if it has more than three competitive advantages at launch. After launch, the project can continually expand with new features and capabilities.
At the launch stage, the project has only one competitive advantage. However, as the startup develops, there is scope to improve and refine various aspects, which will significantly increase its competitiveness in the market.
The project has one competitive advantage, but at the launch stage there is no clear vision of next steps. The founders have not developed a development strategy and do not have the technologies for consistent improvements. This creates a risk of stagnation and reduces the chances of successfully scaling the project. It is important to develop a plan that will determine next steps and integrate innovative technologies to continuously improve the product or service.
At the launch stage, the startup has no competitive advantages and plans to operate according to a model based on copying a successful business. The founders strive to use existing solutions, but this may limit their opportunities for long-term success in the market.
According to the founders, the startup has more than ten competitive advantages, and this number will continue to increase. This positioning may indicate a lack of real competition or a lack of sound strategy.
We don't compete with others because we create a unique product, which allows us to stand out in the market. This gives us the opportunity to highlight many advantages. In the current situation, we rate the position as minus three points.
Assess the barrier to entry for the business
The barrier to entry is a protective barrier from potential competitors. The more difficult it is to imitate your project, the more market share you can capture. High barriers to entry create advantages, allowing your business to strengthen its position and retain customers. This may include unique technologies, exclusive contracts, or significant investments in development. By increasing the difficulty of copying your offering, you ensure a sustainable competitive advantage.
You get 3 points for launching a unique project that makes copying pointless for competitors. For example, creating a second YouTube makes no sense, since the original service already occupies its niche and has a stable audience. The uniqueness of your project gives it a competitive advantage and reduces the risk of imitation.
A startup has limitless potential for scaling. This is a typical path for tech giants: start with a search engine, then move on to developing operating systems, and then expand their product line to include smartphones and other devices. This approach not only strengthens your market position but also significantly increases revenue by attracting new users and investors.
A startup's idea can be easily copied by many, but a successful launch requires specialized knowledge or significant investment.
A startup can be copied by several students if they temporarily give up entertainment and devote their efforts to working on their home laptops.
Our startup requires investment and experienced developers to implement our unique idea. It is important to note that, despite the attractiveness of our project, there is a risk that similar concepts may be copied by competitors. This factor influences the assessment of the prospects of our business.
Calculate the result
Add up all the points received and evaluate the result. If the result is from 19 to 21, this indicates a strong idea and a high probability of success for your startup.
A result in the range of 16 to 18 points indicates a promising idea that requires further development. Pay attention to the items with the lowest scores and analyze which aspects can be improved. If you find opportunities for improvement, make the necessary changes and repeat the test.
If your result is 15 points or less, you should reconsider the feasibility of the idea. This is not a reason for disappointment, but on the contrary, an opportunity to quickly identify the shortcomings of a potentially unsuccessful startup. You saved time and money by avoiding unnecessary risks.
A startup with a cyberdog faced serious problems and received a score of -4. This indicates that his concept is not aligned with real market conditions. Launching such a project is fraught with a high risk of bankruptcy and significant financial losses. Without proper analysis and a clear business model, such innovations can be ineffective and unprofitable.

Final Part
After successfully passing the test and receiving the required number of points, you will need to complete three additional steps before moving on to the next stage. These actions are important for further progress and will help you prepare for the next tasks.
Seek legal advice. Write down your startup idea on paper and provide it to several specialists for analysis. This will help you find out if there are any legal restrictions for your project, whether it violates the rights of third parties, and whether it is possible to collect the necessary documents for the work.
Look at your project from an external perspective. Find about ten people whose opinions you trust. Present your startup idea to them and carefully listen to their opinions on possible risks, prospects, and difficulties. Write down the main points and analyze what aspects may have been missed. This will help you better understand the strengths and weaknesses of your project and prepare for its successful implementation.
Listen to your inner voice. Imagine this: you spend several hours every day working on a startup that you've been developing for five years, but still aren't making a profit. The idea was initially promising, but unexpected difficulties have arisen, and now you need to redouble your efforts to complete the project. It's important to analyze which aspects of the business need improvement and what steps will help put the project back on track for success. Developing a clear action plan and assessing current results will help you make informed decisions and move forward.
Consider whether you are ready to take on responsibility for a struggling startup. Are you afraid of the lack of income at the beginning? Have you ever considered quitting? If you had the opportunity to go back and abandon the idea, would you do it? It's important to realize that working on a startup requires not only courage, but also perseverance. Success doesn't come overnight, and it is in difficult moments that true dedication is revealed.
If you are having difficulty answering questions about your startup idea, it's better to put it aside for a month. During this time, the idea won't fade away, and you'll be able to view it from a new perspective. This is an effective method that allows you to think more deeply about complex decisions and make more informed decisions in the future. Launching a startup solely for financial gain isn't the best approach. The reality of startups is often more complex than initially expected. Without internal enthusiasm, you'll struggle to cope with routine tasks, which can lead to burnout. If your goal is to make a quick buck, it's better to develop your skills and join a company that interests you. Startups are associated with ambition, dreams of implementing a unique project, and opportunities that are difficult to find in a hiring environment. This is a serious challenge that is not suitable for everyone.

