Contents:

Learn: Online tutor
Learn MoreHow an Educator Turned Students into Oppressed and Oppressors
Fall 2010. At Oberlin College in Ohio, 43 students take turns approaching a box and removing slips of paper. Each slip contains a different demographic. This experiment aims to study the diversity and social composition of the student body, allowing the college to better understand its audience and tailor its educational programs. Importantly, such initiatives contribute to the creation of an inclusive environment where every student can feel part of a unified community. Collecting data on demographic characteristics helps identify trends and needs, which in turn contributes to improving the quality of education and social inclusion.
- Country (e.g. Chile or Argentina);
- Gender;
- Year of birth (from 1930 to 1965);
- Place of birth;
- Parents' place of birth, if different;
- Parents' place of work and religion, if different from Catholic.
The resulting information is: “Chile; female; Valparaiso; 1950; father is a journalist for the newspaper Mercurio; mother is a teacher; both parents are from Santiago.”
Each student creates a unique character based on the data provided. Throughout the semester, students will blog as their character, without revealing their real names. This will allow you to develop creative skills and immerse yourself in the world of literary creativity, as well as interact with classmates in a fun and engaging way.
The author of this online role-playing game is history teacher Stephen Volk. In the 1970s, he lived in Chile and witnessed the coup carried out by Augusto Pinochet in 1973. This coup plunged the country into the dark times of military dictatorship for many decades. Under brutal suppression, mass arrests, kidnappings, and torture of opponents of the regime became commonplace. The game allows players to immerse themselves in this historical context, explore the consequences of dictatorship, and understand the importance of human rights.
The people of Chile were not alone in facing tragedies in the 20th century. Similar events affected many countries in Latin America, from Brazil, where a military junta came to power in 1964, to Argentina, which fell under military control in 1976. How do we explain to young people in the United States, who have no similar experience, the reasons why the Chilean government tortured 40,000 people? Why were ordinary soldiers in Argentina willing to kill dissenters by airdropping them into the Atlantic Ocean? Are democracies like the American one immune from such horrific fates? And what lies behind such human cruelty? These questions require a deep analysis of the historical, social, and psychological factors that contribute to such tragedies, and an understanding of the importance of protecting human rights and democratic values in the modern world.
To enable students to independently answer all the questions that arise, Volk developed the "Avatar" project. The teacher aimed to ensure that the students not only explore the topic intellectually but also gain a deeper understanding and experience of it.
Throughout the semester, the students regularly published blog posts dedicated to significant dates in Latin American history in the second half of the 20th century. Participants in the project assumed various roles: some portrayed workers and peasants, others played ordinary civil servants. Some students even portrayed soldiers defending dictatorships. To avoid any discomfort among young people defending the positions of oppressors, the project was conducted anonymously. This allowed participants to more freely express their thoughts and views, delving into complex aspects of the historical context.
Students, exploring the proposed topics, felt confident in their actions if they were Chileans or Argentines in the 1970s. However, the project forced them to confront a number of difficult questions. While preparing their posts, students conducted their own research and often discovered that their heroes were victims of circumstance. For example, many were unable to leave military service because they were obligated to provide for their families. These discoveries helped the students gain a deeper understanding of the historical contexts and moral dilemmas faced by people in difficult times.
Some attempt to find political justifications for their idols. One student, playing the role of a Chilean naval officer, expressed the opinion that Pinochet truly believed he understood his country's interests better than anyone else. She characterized the participants in the 1988 referendum, in which Chileans voted against Pinochet's reelection, as "impatient, spoiled children." Another student noted, "When you explore the world from someone else's perspective, black and white begin to take on nuances." This approach to analyzing historical events and personalities allows for a deeper understanding of the complex political realities and motivations behind the actions of individuals and entire societies.

One student noted that the project raised important questions about memory, pain, loss, repression, and history. Another student emphasized that history textbooks provide only facts, whereas this assignment encourages deeper reflection on people's emotions and experiences. Another commented on the importance of personal stories in the context of studying the past.
Writing a report in the first person creates a sense of responsibility that is unlike the process of reading. This approach requires deeper analysis and careful attention to detail, as every argument made and every idea presented relates directly to the author. This sense of responsibility fosters a more conscious and thoughtful approach to content creation, which ultimately improves its quality and value for readers.
The Avatar Project challenged me beyond my comfort zone and significantly increased engagement in the learning process compared to traditional assignments, noted Stephen Volk. This project not only deepened students' understanding of the historical period being studied but also contributed to the development of their empathy, which allows them to better understand complex moral choices. The teacher emphasizes the importance of such initiatives for developing critical thinking and social responsibility in students.
Why is Living History Necessary?
Stephen Volk uses a method known in English-language educational literature as living history, which translates as "living history" or "living history." This approach was first used in the United States in the early 20th century. Researchers associate it with the ideas of experiential learning by John Dewey. Dewey, an American philosopher and educator, argued that learning is more effective when students gain experience through direct interaction with the material, rather than simply listening to lectures. The living history method not only deepens understanding of historical events but also develops critical thinking and analytical skills in students.
The essence of the "living history" concept is to recreate the lives of people from past eras based on research and personal interpretation of historical data. A striking example of this approach is the "Avatar" project, which demonstrates how to visualize and convey the atmosphere of another era. Living history can take various forms, including documentaries, theatrical productions, and interactive exhibitions, allowing viewers to gain a deeper understanding of the cultural, social, and emotional aspects of people's lives in the past.
- Third-person narration—the interpreter dresses in the clothing of the period being researched but narrates about life in that era in language understandable to modern readers. For example, a role-player might say, "I'm making stew now, just like housewives or servants did in the seventeenth century. Today, we would simply call this dish soup."
- First-person narration—when it's necessary not only to imitate the costumes of bygone eras, but also to recreate their daily lives, thoughts, and behavior. They speak, as the name of the method suggests, in the first person: "I built this house last year" (although "last year" could be, for example, 1650), and so on. The character could be a famous figure, such as Napoleon, or an ordinary person, say, an American soldier during the Revolutionary War. Stephen Volk's students created a first-person interpretation, only in an online format.
The advantages of this approach include a high degree of immersion in the material being studied. Students begin to perceive themselves as full participants in the historical event. The unique format engages students and encourages them to explore the topic independently. This teaching method helps to increase interest in history and develop critical thinking.

What approaches are used to "Living History"
There are numerous examples of the successful use of engaging learning formats both abroad and in Russia. These methods are being actively implemented in educational institutions, making the learning process more interesting and effective. Innovative approaches engage students and promote better learning.
A number of universities and schools in the United States actively use the Reacting to the Past method, developed by Barnard College history professor Mark Carnes. This approach includes more than ten role-playing games created by Carnes and his colleagues, covering various historical events. For example, these games include "Rousseau, Burke, and the French Revolution" and "The Constitutional Convention of 1787: Building the American Republic." The method allows students to gain a deeper understanding of historical processes and develop critical thinking through active participation in discussions and debates.
The game kit includes teaching materials for students and teachers, containing a timeline of historical events and their general context, recommended reading lists, primary sources, and tips for written and oral assignments. In the game, students assume specific roles and lead debates, striving to persuade opponents and effectively convey their character's ideas to the rest of the participants. This learning format develops skills in critical thinking, argumentation, and public speaking.
Carnes shared that inspiration came to him at a time when it seemed all the conditions for successful teaching were ideal: talented students, small classes, and high-quality teaching materials. However, he felt the spark needed to create a truly inspiring learning environment was missing. "The more I tried to engage students in exploring new ideas, cultures, and societies, the more they clung to the familiar and withdrew, hiding their vulnerability behind a wall of silence," he shared. To increase student engagement, Carnes developed the Reacting to the Past method. This new lesson structure is designed to encourage student participation in discussions. "It's an alternative approach to learning. You don't just read Plato's Republic and other classics; you experience them," noted one student. This method allows for a deeper understanding of philosophical ideas and historical context, which promotes better learning and the development of critical thinking. While specialized teaching aids for the "living history" format are not yet available in Russia, this approach is actively used in game-based formats. One example is the board game "74," dedicated to Soviet history, where participants can "relive" significant historical events. Also worth noting are the online games of the educational project "Arzamas," where players enter into dynastic marriages to choose spouses for the children of Peter the Great. These games help develop a deeper understanding of the genealogy of the Romanov dynasty and Russian foreign policy in the 18th century. The use of game elements in teaching promotes more effective assimilation of historical facts and the development of critical thinking in students. In Hampshire, England, Oxford graduate Neil Bates teaches high school students a unique approach—he dresses up as various historical figures. For example, to illustrate events in the United States during the Great Depression, he transforms himself into Florence Thompson, known for the famous photograph "Migrant Mother." As another historical character, Bates chooses the English politician Cecil Rhodes, who played a key role in the colonization of South Africa. In one of his lessons, he also becomes the captain of the slave ship Zong, on board which a tragic massacre took place in 1781. This teaching method helps high school students gain a deeper understanding of historical events and develops their interest in history.
Bates uses this approach for several reasons. First, it makes learning more engaging. When lessons are interesting, students absorb the material more easily. Second, this method of conveying information is significantly more effective than simply taking notes. It helps students understand and remember the topic more deeply. Third, this approach promotes the development of public speaking skills, an important aspect of education. The teacher notes that he values it when his students actively participate in discussions, and this teaching method focuses on dialogue and interaction.
Moscow educator Alexander Odjo's approach to teaching history, particularly Ancient Greece, is noteworthy. The first lesson in which he used historical costume consisted of a chiton sewn from an ordinary bedsheet. But this was only the beginning: Odjo also appeared in his lessons wearing armor and an officer's uniform, borrowed from museums. In a comment to Mos.ru, the teacher expressed a desire to engage students in interactive lessons, inviting them not only to try on historical costumes but also to role-play, exploring the personalities and lives of their historical figures. This approach not only makes lessons more engaging but also fosters a deeper understanding of the historical context, an important aspect of education.
At some Russian universities, history is taking on new forms. For example, at Moscow City University, a trial was held for the Dominican monk Girolamo Savonarola, a renowned defender of the disadvantaged and critic of the vices of the church. One student played the role of the prosecutor, and another acted as the defense attorney. Historical figures such as King Charles VIII and artist Sandro Botticelli were "present" as witnesses at this trial. Initiatives such as these not only make studying history more engaging but also help students gain a deeper understanding of the significance of historical events and personalities.
"Living history" can sometimes be not only entertaining but also serious. While many aspects are intriguing, there are also aspects that require deeper reflection. Historical events can contain tragic or complex situations that are difficult to perceive lightly. Understanding these nuances allows us to more deeply appreciate the legacy of the past and its influence on the present.

What can
Attempts to reconstruct historical events in the classroom often led to oddities and sometimes even loud scandals, which could cause psychological trauma among students.
In 2011, a teacher in Ohio invited his ten-year-old Black students to role-play as African slaves so they could better understand the concept of a slave auction. In 2017, fifth-graders in Georgia were immersed in the Civil War era, where one student dressed as a plantation owner and declared to his Black classmate, "You are my slave." In 2018, a white teacher in New York City forced African-American students to lie on the floor and placed his foot on their backs to demonstrate the "realities of slavery." These incidents raise important questions about approaches to history teaching and the perception of race in the educational environment.
In 1967, one of the most shocking stories related to the educational process occurred in Palo Alto, California. Ron Jones, a popular history teacher among his students, faced a difficult question. During a lesson on World War II, tenth-graders asked him a reasonable question: why did the Germans ignore the horrors of Nazism and later claim to be unaware of the Holocaust, despite the fact that many Jews were their neighbors and friends? Ron Jones's answer was simple: "That's an important question. We'll discuss it on Monday." This incident began a discussion about moral responsibility and human nature under totalitarianism that remains relevant to this day.
On Monday, the teacher discussed the importance of discipline with the teenagers. He emphasized that without self-control, neither ballerinas, nor artists, nor basketball players can achieve greatness. Teacher Jones explained that discipline is the key to achieving goals and developing talents. "Pay attention to your posture!" he suddenly exclaimed. He then ordered the students to straighten their backs, press their legs and feet to the floor, and place their hands behind their backs. Jones and the class practiced this posture for an extended period of time. They also learned a new rule: if students wanted to ask a question, they were to stand up and use no more than three words. "That's discipline!" Jones added. The teacher planned to complete the experiment in one day, but when he entered the classroom the next morning, he found the students sitting in the exact position he had demonstrated. Jones decided to extend the experiment for a week. He explained the importance of unity to the students and then instructed them to shout in unison, "Strength in discipline!" and "Strength in community!" To these slogans, he added a unique gesture with which the students began to greet each other.

Jones explained that the participants The movements that demonstrate the greatest loyalty will receive the highest grade at the end of the experiment. Those who do not resist, but also do not show initiative, will be given a C. Participants who decide to take an oppositional stance will be "exiled" to the library. However, if the dissidents successfully revolt, they will receive A's. To prevent a rebellion, Jones organized a secret "police" from among the students, who monitored any suspicious activity. By the end of the third day, the movement had attracted about two hundred people. Students from other classes, having heard about it in the school hallways, expressed a desire to join. Jones explained that it was part of a new political party, branches of which are forming in thousands of schools across America. This new party intends to replace the Democratic and Republican parties, seizing power into its own hands. "You are the chosen ones," Jones declared. On the last day of the experiment, the teacher gathered the participants in the classroom in front of a television that was showing no images. For several minutes, the participants sat in silence, and soon began to feel discomfort. Soon, a film about Nazi Germany appeared on the screen, eliciting unexpected reactions and emotions among the students. The impact of this viewing became an important part of the discussion, revealing the influence of historical events on modern perceptions.
Jones admitted that no party actually existed, and that what was happening was merely his impromptu experiment. He sought to demonstrate how easily a group of people united by an authoritarian leader could be manipulated. Some students began to cry, others left the classroom, but most remained in silent bewilderment, realizing how quickly one can lose control of one's emotions and decisions under pressure. The experiment became an important lesson about the nature of power and influence, forcing one to consider the consequences of blind obedience.
Neither Jones nor his students shared information about the experiment for a long time. Almost ten years later, in 1976, Jones described it in an essay. The story soon gained worldwide fame and became the basis for numerous films and books, including "Experiment 2: The Wave." This experiment drew attention to issues of social dynamics and the influence of group pressure, making it a subject of study in various fields, such as psychology and sociology.

How to Prepare for Historical Reenactment in the Classroom Without Harming Your Students
Opponents of the "living history" approach argue that it should not replace critical thinking with emotion. They also emphasize that such a practice can negatively impact children's mental health. This is especially true when children play the roles of victims, such as slaves, during historical reenactments. Such scenarios can cause stress and trauma, which calls into question the appropriateness of using this method for educational purposes.
Identifying with the role of the oppressor can cause serious psychological harm to a child, says Cori Wright-Meili, a lecturer at Saint Mary's University in Canada. She emphasizes that conflicts between children should not be allowed, as this can negatively impact their emotional and mental well-being. It is important to create an environment in which children learn to interact and support each other, which promotes their harmonious development.
When working with first-person narratives, responsibility and careful preparation are necessary. Learning for Justice offers several key guidelines to help you do this effectively. It is important to consider the context and depth of the experience being represented to ensure accuracy and respect for the narrative. It is also important to embrace a diversity of opinions and perspectives to create a more complete and objective representation. Effective use of first-person narratives can promote understanding of complex social issues and broaden perspectives.
- Avoid role-playing, which can lead to psychological trauma;
- Avoid placing children in groups that re-enact real-life violent relationships from the past;
- Remember to remind children to de-role when the role-play is finished.
The Zinn Education Project integrates the principles of historical role-playing into the educational process. These games are designed to promote active participation, develop critical thinking, and deepen understanding of historical events. Participants are given the opportunity to assume the roles of various historical figures, which helps them better understand the context and complexities of the time. It is important that the games be based on reliable historical facts, which helps create a realistic atmosphere and deepen analytical skills. This approach not only makes learning history more engaging but also develops students' empathy and critical thinking about historical processes.
- Explore complex social phenomena, such as social division, economic inequality, or environmental exploitation.
- Tell the truth about the present and the past, including by shedding light on the stories of people and groups who are trivialized, underreported, or not talked about at all.
- Enhance children's willingness to act justly and develop their empathy and solidarity, countering cynicism and strengthening their readiness for civic activism.
Teachers should not force students into specific roles, especially if it makes them uncomfortable. If students are assigned the roles of characters who have been subjected to oppression, they are not obligated to re-enact this traumatic experience. Instead, students can imagine such characters in terms of their readiness to resist. Furthermore, those who play the roles of violent characters are not required to embody these characters or sympathize with their "antiheroes." It is important to create a safe learning environment where each student can express themselves and their feelings without pressure or coercion, which fosters a deeper understanding of roles and emotions within the learning process. Teachers should remember that the primary goal of these practices is to recreate the past with high historical accuracy, as educational theorist William Fetsko notes in his work "Living History in the Classroom." When preparing such lessons, it is important to thoroughly research historical sources. While interpretation will inevitably add a personal touch to the play, facts and accuracy must remain the foundation. This will help create a deeper understanding of history in students and increase their interest in the events being studied.
Reworked text:
Pay attention to other materials:
- American teacher turned history lessons into detective stories
- How the news agenda is used in teaching
- How chess is turned into a universal educational tool
Online Tutor
It doesn't matter what you teach—English, CrossFit, yoga, vocals, or culinary arts. Everything you previously taught in schools, studios, and offices can now be taught online. Promote your knowledge and skills and earn money from anywhere in the world.
Find out more
