Code

The History of Copyright: From the Iliad to Linux

The History of Copyright: From the Iliad to Linux

Free Python Course ➞ Mini-course for beginners and experienced coders. 4 cool projects in the portfolio, live communication with the speaker. Click and find out what you can learn in the course.

Learn more

More than 50 years ago, the first commercial software appeared on the market, causing numerous difficulties for lawyers. Programs could be easily copied, allowing users to bypass the purchase by receiving originals from friends or pooling their offices to purchase floppy disks with new applications. Developer companies expressed dissatisfaction with lost profits, which prompted them to tighten controls on software distribution. In response, progressive programmers and engineers developed the concepts of free software and open source, which became an alternative to commercial licenses and fostered the development of the developer community.

In this series of articles, we will take an in-depth look at free licenses and copyright in software. We will examine key pieces of legislation, analyze important court cases, and introduce you to the main figures in the world of free software (FOSS).

When Authors Had No Rights

Intellectual property law began to develop in the early 18th century, which is a relatively recent phenomenon in historical perspective. In ancient Greece and Rome, as well as in Renaissance Europe, copyright issues were not considered. This suggests that ideas for protecting creative works and innovations arose much later, reflecting changes in the perception of creativity and its value in society.

Historically, literature was copied by hand and distributed without the consent of the authors or the payment of royalties. We cannot know for sure what great writers like Homer and Seneca thought about this, but scholars agree that this practice did not raise particular concerns. At that time, copyright did not have the significance it has acquired in modern society. This phenomenon highlights how approaches to literature and intellectual property protection have changed over time.

The Romans perceived the establishment of a monopoly on copying as something unusual. It would resemble a ban on the establishment of a new similar business next to an existing merchant who had already established a customer base. Such restrictions raised questions about free competition and fairness in trade. The monopolization of copying limited access to knowledge and information, which, in turn, could negatively impact the cultural and economic development of society.

G. F. Shershenevich is a renowned lawyer and civilist who made a significant contribution to the development of civil law. His works and research cover a wide range of issues related to legal norms, obligations, and the rights of citizens. Shershenevich is known for his ability to analyze complex legal situations and propose practical solutions, making him an authority in the field of jurisprudence. His works continue to be relevant and in demand among lawyers and law students.

In the Middle Ages, copyright was of little importance. At that time, even members of royal families and the nobility often could not read and write. Secular literature was practically never published, and surviving works of antiquity were often censored by the Church. Books were created in monasteries in Latin, primarily in the form of religious and philosophical treatises. Since only monks knew Latin, demand for books remained low and their prices were high. Therefore, the need for copyright in that era was minimal, as access to literature was limited and concentrated in the hands of a few.

During the Renaissance, the Church's influence weakened, leading to a growing interest in ancient literature. With the invention of the printing press by Johannes Gutenberg, book sales became profitable. This attracted many enterprising individuals who began to profit from selling copies of works without significant investment. Thus, literature became more accessible, which contributed to the spread of knowledge and cultural ideas.

That very press. Photo: Wikimedia Commons

Privileges for publishing works first appeared in Venice in 1469. These rights were granted not only to professional printers but also to close friends of monarchs or princes, a rather progressive step for the time. With such a privilege, a publisher could freely publish and sell popular books for several years without fear of competition. This contributed to the development of the book industry and the formation of a market for printed materials.

Income from book sales went primarily to printers, while authors were paid only symbolic fees, barely enough to survive. Privileges in this process primarily protected the interests of publishers and facilitated state censorship, as they were granted only for "reliable" works. Later, authors began to be provided with documents, but real exclusive rights were still out of the question.

In England, the book business was governed by the London Printers' Guild. Authors could sell their works only through representatives of this guild, receiving a one-time payment for doing so. At the same time, they were prohibited from printing their own books or joining a guild. This system limited the freedom of authors and controlled the printed market, creating certain barriers to the distribution of literature.

How Monopolists Lost to Creators

In the modern era, significant changes occurred in philosophy and law, when Spinoza, Montesquieu, and other thinkers proposed the theory of natural law. This theory states that every person has inalienable rights, such as the right to housing, freedom of opinion, and work. The concept of natural rights was adopted by progressive Europe, which led to the development of many laws based on these principles.

In 1709, the Statute of Queen Anne was passed in England, which significantly changed the situation in the printing market and reduced the monopoly of English book publishers. Under this law, authors were granted the right to exclusive publication of their works for 14 years. After this period, they could renew their copyright for another 14 years. After this period, the work entered the public domain, allowing anyone to use it. However, certain restrictions applied: it was forbidden to claim authorship or change the title of the original book. This law became an important milestone in the development of copyright and contributed to the spread of literature in England.

That same Anna. Image: Willem Wissing and Jan van der Vaart / National Galleries of Scotland

Former monopolists have long fought in court, attempting to defend the right to perpetual copyright. They claimed to act in the interests of authors, arguing that their sales models ensure better returns for writers, while allowing authors to focus on their creativity. Publishers even attempted to change the law through their parliamentary allies, but their efforts were unsuccessful. The situation surrounding copyright remains relevant, as questions about fair distribution of income and the protection of intellectual property continue to fuel public debate.

The Berne Convention and Modern Copyright

Modern copyright began to take shape towards the end of the 19th century, when countries such as Belgium, France, Spain, Great Britain, Tunisia, and Switzerland signed the Berne Convention. This document sets out the basic requirements for copyright protection that all parties to the convention are obliged to observe, taking into account the specifics of their national legislation. As of 2020, 179 countries have joined the convention, demonstrating global recognition of the importance of copyright protection.

The Berne Convention established a uniform standard for copyright protection, similar to how the TCP/IP protocol standardizes data transmission on the network. Before its adoption, countries had to negotiate individually, which meant that separate agreements had to be developed, agreed upon, and signed with each partner state. This process was complex and time-consuming. The Berne Convention simplified this task by providing universal rules that facilitate cooperation between countries in the field of copyright.

Russia signed the convention in 1994, following a government decree. However, this accession was accompanied by reservations. Specifically, the provisions of the convention did not apply to works already considered public domain in Russia. With Russia's accession to the World Trade Organization (WTO), the need for this reservation disappeared, and the relevant part of the decree was repealed. Thus, Russia simplified copyright protection and brought its legislation into line with international standards.

Modern legislation protects copyright in literary, artistic, and scientific works. Only the author or persons who have received rights from them may dispose of the results of their creativity. This means that copying, distributing, or selling a work without their permission is a violation of the law. In general, copyright in countries that have acceded to international conventions has similarities, but there are also specific features specific to each country. For example, in most countries with an Anglo-Saxon legal system, rights to works must be registered as property, whereas in countries with a Romano-Germanic legal system, such registration is not required. This distinction is important to consider when dealing with copyright internationally.

Why Traditional Copyright Cannot Apply to Software

The first computer programs began to appear in the late 1940s, when the cost of software was included in the overall price of a computer. In 1957, the Fortran programming language was developed, significantly simplifying and speeding up the development process compared to machine code and assembler. Fortran programs could run on any computer, regardless of the CPU architecture, providing greater versatility. At the same time, magnetic tape recording devices began to be sold, making data copying more accessible and cost-effective. These events marked important milestones in the development of programming and computer technology, opening new horizons for developers and users.

Until the 1960s, computers and software cost hundreds of thousands of dollars, making them affordable only for large research institutes and large companies. However, in 1964, IBM introduced the low-cost System/360 series computers, and Applied Data Research released the first commercial software. This marked the beginning of a new era, when software development became a profitable business. As a result, companies began to consider legal protection for their software, as users exchanged copies of programs without purchasing the original versions. This problem became especially relevant given that many users remembered the stickers from Microsoft, which symbolized the licensed version of the programs.

The basic model of such a baby cost only 40 thousand dollars, and the top one - up to 240 thousand. Photo: Wikimedia Commons

In In 1964, the Copyright Office of the Library of Congress issued Circular 61, which concerned the copyright registration of computer software. From that point on, computer programs began to be registered as copyrighted works in the United States. In 1976, the Copyright Act was passed, and in 1980, amendments were made aimed at protecting software. These changes were an important step in ensuring the rights of developers and owners of software, which contributed to the development of the software industry and the protection of intellectual property in this area.

In the early 1970s, lawyers, politicians, and academics actively debated the legal status of software. Attempts were made at this time to classify programs within the framework of traditional copyright or patent law. Variants of mixed copyright-patent protection, as well as trade secret regimes known as know-how, were also considered. These debates formed the basis for the formation of modern software intellectual property law and remain relevant in light of rapid technological developments.

Experts have criticized the traditional approach, which holds that the technical idea plays a key role in software, while copyright protects only the external form. Importantly, the idea can be preserved, while the form can be changed in such a way that current legislation cannot provide protection. This situation highlights the need to reconsider approaches to software intellectual property protection in order to more effectively protect innovative ideas and developments.

The know-how regime was used exclusively at the program development stage. Patenting also presented a number of difficulties. Lawyers faced problems when drafting the description and claims of an invention, unsure to what extent the essence of the development can be disclosed and how to assess its novelty. Programs cannot be classified as devices or methods, and do not meet the traditional understanding of "technical solutions" in the context of patent law. Therefore, the importance of properly drafting and understanding patent requirements becomes especially relevant for software developers.

World Intellectual Property Organization and Regulations

In 1967, the World Intellectual Property Organization was founded, bringing together scientists, lawyers, and businessmen. In 1971, this organization held a meeting to consider the status of computer programs.

Opinions on this issue were divided. The representative of the United Kingdom believed that in order to ensure the rights and obligations of the parties, it was sufficient to clearly spell out the terms in the agreement between the developer and the user, and the code should be protected as a trade secret. At the same time, the representative of the United States insisted on the need to create a new protection mechanism different from traditional copyright. An expert from the USSR proposed introducing a regime for the protection of utility models for a period of 5-10 years, believing that protecting rights for a longer period is inappropriate. Although no consensus was reached, the parties agreed to continue the discussion and organize a new meeting for further work.

In 1978, the organization introduced Model Provisions for the Protection of Computer Software, calling on states to consider their adoption as an international treaty. These provisions provided a unique software protection regime, combining elements of copyright and patent law. However, national legislators refused to support this initiative and chose to develop their own protection systems based solely on copyright.

In the Soviet Union, the concept of a "patent" did not exist, and software was classified as new technology. Such objects were subject to copyright and invention law, similar to patents. Over time, the United States also came to this approach, which indicates a global change in the perception of the legal protection of intellectual property.

Modern Copyright and Software

In the nineties, companies selling software demonstrated rapid growth. New laws and international agreements were adopted in the United States, Europe, and Russia, spurring the development of the software market. These changes allowed companies to expand their business models, implementing innovative solutions and adapting to the demands of a rapidly changing technological environment. Thus, the 1990s became a landmark period for the software industry, opening new horizons for developers and users.

  • The Council of the European Communities Directive on the Legal Protection of Computer Programs, 1991 (in 2009, it was replaced by the EU Directive of the same name);
  • The Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS), 1994, adopted within the framework of the World Trade Organization (WTO);
  • The WIPO Copyright Treaty, 1996.

After the collapse of the USSR, the legal system in Russia was completely revised. Laws began to focus on market realities, as well as international and European standards. During this period, our legislators actively borrowed from the West, which significantly influenced the formation of new legal norms and institutions.

In 1992-1993, the State Duma of the Russian Federation approved the laws "On the Legal Protection of Computer Programs and Databases" and "On Copyright and Related Rights". These bills clearly define software as having unique characteristics that distinguish it from traditional copyrighted works such as books, musical works, and paintings. These legislative changes were an important step in protecting the rights of software developers and creating a legal basis for the further development of the IT industry in Russia. They also contributed to an improved legal environment for innovation and investment in technology.

Computer programs, unlike literary works, are not designed to convey information to people, but to control a computer to achieve a specific result. Without a computer, a program loses its value. The key aspect is not the source code, but how the program functions and what results it produces. When creating code, a programmer is guided by pragmatic considerations, not aesthetic or emotional ones. What matters is not how beautiful a command sounds, but how effectively it accomplishes its intended tasks. If a program does not provide value to the user, they will not purchase it, regardless of the originality and creativity of the source code.

A. In his work "Software Licensing in Russia: Legislation and Practice," I. Savelyev examines key aspects of software licensing regulation in Russia. The text analyzes current regulations, as well as practical examples of the application of legislation in this area. The author emphasizes the importance of complying with license agreements and their impact on the protection of intellectual property. The work contains useful recommendations for software developers and users seeking to comply with the law in the use of software. Savelyev also discusses current issues and trends in licensing, making his work an important source of information for professionals and legal entities working in the field of information technology.

In 2006, the "Copyright" chapter of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation was amended to include provisions concerning the legal protection of programs for electronic computers, which in Russian law is referred to as software. Importantly, software was expressly excluded from the objects of patent law, emphasizing its protection under copyright law. This change marked a significant step in regulating intellectual property rights in the IT sector, providing a clearer framework for software developers and users.

According to international standards, authors have exclusive rights to their works. These rights are divided into personal and property rights. Property rights allow authors to transfer them to other individuals or companies, which opens up opportunities for the commercialization of their creative work.

According to the Berne Convention, copyright lasts for the author's lifetime and for 50 years after their death, after which the work enters the public domain and becomes available for use by everyone. In Russia, the term of copyright protection has been extended to 70 years after the author's death, providing additional protection for intellectual property and the rights of heirs.

Personal rights to works are non-transferable and last indefinitely. These rights include the right of authorship, the right to the author's name, the right to the integrity of the work, and other related rights. These rights protect the author's individuality and creative vision, ensuring that the work will be used in accordance with the author's intentions.

As software sales increased, companies began to realize the benefits of closed-source programs. As a result, they began to enter into confidentiality agreements with developers, which deprived them of the right to publish or distribute the source code as they saw fit. The property rights to use and modify the programs remained with the companies. However, not everyone liked this system. Some developers believed that it limited creative freedom and slowed the development of the entire software industry.

What are free licenses and how did they appear?

Free licenses are agreements that contain a number of conditions, among which open source code is key. Unlike proprietary licenses, free licenses allow users to modify the code and use it in their own projects. This creates opportunities for collaboration, innovation, and improvement of software, making it more accessible and flexible for developers and end users.

In the 1970s, progressive minds began to ask important moral and philosophical questions about the need to protect software through copyright. They considered whether this protection would restrict the freedom of users and society as a whole. With each passing year, the number of opponents of "regulation" and "proprietaryism" grew, which in turn contributed to the emergence of free licenses. These licenses provided opportunities for more flexible and open use of software, which was an important step towards ensuring user freedom and fostering innovation in technology.

Richard Stallman, a programmer and founder of the Free Software Foundation (FSF), is the author of the first free license. His work played a key role in shaping the principles of free software, promoting the development of open technologies and facilitating the dissemination of knowledge and innovation in programming. Stallman continues to actively support software freedom, inspiring a new generation of developers.

In his younger years, while working at MIT, he encountered problems with proprietary software. Xerox provided the lab with a defective laser printer, and Richard, eager to fix the problem, approached colleagues at a nearby university asking for the driver source code. However, his request was refused, citing a confidentiality agreement. This experience taught him a valuable lesson about the shortcomings of closed systems and spurred him to pursue open source software.

If Stallman hadn't invented GNU, he would have created a new religion. Photo: Wikimedia Commons

In 1984, Richard Stallman left the lab and focused entirely on the GNU Project, which is a recursive acronym for the phrase GNU is Not UNIX. The project's goal was to create a free analogue of the proprietary UNIX operating system. The GNU Project became the foundation for the development of free software and had a significant influence on the further development of technology and programming.

In 1991, Linus Torvalds presented the first version of the new operating system, which in 1992 became the Linux kernel. An important aspect of this project was the use of utilities from the GNU Project, including the gcc compiler and the GNU Emacs text editor. This is why Richard Stallman emphasizes the need to call the system GNU/Linux. This innovative operating system gave rise to many distributions such as Debian, Fedora, Ubuntu and many others, making Linux one of the most popular solutions in the software world.

In 1988, Richard Stallman developed the first version of the GPL (General Public License), which has become one of the most popular free licenses. GPL provides users with four basic freedoms: use the software for any purpose, access to the source code, the ability to change the program, and the right to distribute modified versions. These principles promote the development of open source software and support the philosophy of freedom in using technology.

  • run the programs for any purpose;
  • study the program code and adapt it for your own projects;
  • distribute copies of the programs;
  • improve the programs and distribute the improved versions for the benefit of society.

The user, having received certain freedoms, undertakes to distribute derivative programs under the same conditions and with open source code. Licenses like the GPL are called "viral" because they "infect" the code: all changes and modifications to programs licensed under the GPL must also be released under that license. This principle of inheritance of rights is known as copyleft, which contrasts with traditional copyright.

International human rights instruments recognize the freedom to receive and impart information and ideas as one of the key inalienable human rights. This freedom sometimes conflicts with copyright. However, the author's exclusive right is not absolute, and there are cases when free use of works is possible. In this context, Richard Stallman develops the concept of free information exchange in the field of software, emphasizing that this is possible not only through free use, which is regulated by law, but also through licensing agreements such as the GPL. Thus, free access to information and programs supports the development of technology and contributes to its democratization.

In the Anglo-Saxon legal system, a contract takes precedence over the law if it does not harm third parties. When an author agrees to the terms of the GPL license, they effectively waive exclusive rights to a program created using the source code of free software. However, the author remains the copyright owner and can use traditional copyright remedies in the event of a violation of the license terms for their work. This highlights the importance of adhering to license agreements and protecting the rights of authors in the context of free software.

The free software movement is sometimes criticized for its alleged lack of copyright recognition. However, this is not true. The GPL license denies copyright monopoly over software products. You may be acknowledged as the author, but you have no right to control how your software is used. This approach promotes community development, innovation, and knowledge sharing, creating a more open and accessible environment for all users.

The primary goal of the Free Software Foundation (FSF) is to ensure the open exchange of knowledge and creative freedom. Projects licensed under the GNU General Public License (GPL) bring together independent developers from all over the world, with diverse experience and skills. A prime example of this approach is Linus Torvalds, who immediately after creating Linux released it into the public domain and invited users to contribute their improvements and suggestions. This created a vibrant community that fostered innovation and collaborative software development.

From the very beginning of Linux development, the project involved many volunteers who coordinated their efforts entirely via the internet. System quality was maintained not by strict standards or authoritarian management, but by a simple approach of weekly releases based on user feedback. Linux's evolution resembled an accelerated Darwinian selection process, where "mutations" proposed by developers were tested and improved. This strategy proved remarkably effective, surprising many observers.

In his essay "A Brief History of Hacking," Eric Raymond explores the development of hacker culture and its impact on the modern world. He analyzes how hacking became an integral part of information technology, highlighting the core principles and philosophy underlying this movement. Raymond emphasizes the importance of open source and collaboration within the programming community, which fosters innovation and the development of new technologies. The essay also examines the social and ethical aspects of hacking, demonstrating how hackers strive for freedom of information and the protection of user rights. This work serves as an important source for understanding not only the history of hacking, but also its role in shaping modern digital society.

Open Source Initiative - A Different Look at Open Source

In 1998, Eric Raymond and Bruce Perens founded the Open Source Initiative (OSI) - a more pragmatic alternative to the Free Software movement. The movement's core idea is that open source software is highly effective and that it is profitable for businesses to support such projects. The Open Source Initiative seeks to popularize the use of open source software, emphasizing its benefits, such as transparency, security, and customization. Supporting open source projects fosters innovation and growth in the IT industry, making them essential for modern business.

Raymond and Perens were inspired by the story of the Netscape Navigator browser. During its popularity, the company faced fierce competition from Microsoft, which threatened its existence. To address these market challenges, Netscape decided to open the source code for its browser and invite the Internet community to participate in its development. This move led to the creation of Firefox, which has become a favorite browser for millions of users thanks to its flexibility and support for open standards.

OSI developed criteria that a software license must meet to qualify as open source. Licenses that pass this review receive a certificate and can be called open source. Such licenses include Apache 2.0, LGPL 3, and Affero GPL 3. To simplify understanding, the Open Source trademark was registered, which helps avoid confusion. Unlike GPL licenses, OSI-approved licenses do not require authors of derivative programs to distribute their code under the terms of the original license. This makes them more flexible for developers and promotes the wider use of open source software.

Large corporations such as IBM, Oracle, HP, and Google have recognized the potential of open source as an effective business model and actively support this initiative. Despite differences in ideological approaches, the Free Software Foundation (FSF) and the Open Source Initiative (OSI) continue to collaborate. However, recently, a rift has been observed in the community, caused by Richard Stallman's controversial reputation, calling into question the unity and further development of open source software.

The history of copyright and free licenses covers important aspects of intellectual property protection. Copyright arose in response to the need to protect creative works from unauthorized use. In the 18th century, the first laws regulating authors' rights to their works began to appear in Europe.

Over time, copyright evolved to cover not only literary works, but also music, painting, film, and digital media. A key milestone was the adoption of international agreements such as the Berne Convention, which established general principles for copyright protection.

The late 20th century saw the emergence of open licenses such as Creative Commons, which allow authors to share their works under certain conditions. These licenses promote the dissemination of knowledge and cultural products by balancing the rights of authors with the interests of society.

Today, copyright and open licenses continue to evolve, reflecting new technologies and changing consumer habits. It is important to follow current changes in legislation in order to effectively protect your rights and use the works of other authors within the established norms.

  • the first copyright law was adopted in England in the 18th century;
  • at the end of the 19th century, several countries signed the Berne Convention, which formed the basis of international copyright law;
  • in the 1980s and 1990s, states adopted a number of amendments to copyright law regarding computer programs;
  • in 1988, Richard Stallman published the text of the free GPL license and then founded the Free Software Foundation;
  • in 1992, thanks to the joint efforts of Linus Torvalds and volunteer hackers, the first version of GNU/Linux appeared;
  • in 1998, Eric Raymond and Bruce Perens created the Open Source Initiative, a less radical alternative to the Free Software Foundation.

You can study the source code of programs on the GitHub platform. However, to effectively understand and analyze code, it is recommended to master programming languages. The best way to do this is to take courses at Skillbox, which offer structured training programs and practical tasks to consolidate knowledge.