Contents:

Free Python course ➞ Mini-course for For beginners and experienced coders. 4 cool projects in the portfolio, live communication with the speaker. Click and find out what you can learn in the course.
Learn moreIn this article, I will begin exploring an important and relevant topic in the field of jurisprudence – the legal protection of intellectual property, with a special emphasis on copyright. My experience in this field allows me to better understand how computer programs are protected as the results of intellectual activity in Russia and other countries. I will share key aspects of the law and practice related to the legal protection of software, and compare the approaches of various jurisdictions.
You will learn how to optimize your content for search engines, improve your website's visibility, and attract your target audience. We will cover key aspects of SEO, including keyword research, creating high-quality content, optimizing meta tags, and using internal and external links. You will understand how to properly structure the text so that it is easy to read and meets the requirements of search engines. You will learn about the importance of mobile responsiveness and fast page loading for improving rankings. In addition, we will consider methods for analyzing the results and adjusting the strategy for maximum effectiveness.
- Why computer programs are protected by copyright;
- Which program components are protected by copyright and which are not;
- What is the situation with judicial practice and what difficulties arise when protecting software with copyright.
Why computer programs are subject to copyright
Since the end of the 20th century, the protection of computer programs at the international level is carried out primarily through copyright. The Treaty of the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) establishes that computer programs are protected as literary works. The TRIPS Agreement specifies that this protection extends to both the source code and object code of software. This ensures comprehensive protection of intellectual property in the field of information technology and promotes the development of innovative solutions.
Russia actively participates in all key international agreements concerning copyright. Domestic legislation uses the outdated term "computer program," while contractual and judicial practice widely use the term "software." This distinction is important to consider when developing and protecting intellectual property rights in the field of technology.
Copyright was chosen to protect computer programs for several reasons. First, computer programs are original works created by developers, requiring creativity and intellectual labor. Second, copyright provides legal protection by allowing developers to control the use and distribution of their programs. This helps prevent illegal copying and distribution, which, in turn, stimulates innovation and development in the software field. Furthermore, copyright provides opportunities for generating income from works, which is an important factor for many companies and individual developers. Ultimately, the use of copyright to protect computer programs creates a balance between the interests of developers and consumers, promoting healthy competition in the software market.
In the 1940s and 1950s, with the advent of the first electronic computers, the terms "software" and "hardware" were intertwined. Large computer manufacturers became the owners of the software, using patent rights and trade secrets to gain complete control over their developments. This provided them with a significant advantage in the market and facilitated the development of computing technologies.
As computer technology developed, it became clear that programs for electronic computers could not be protected by patent law. This is because they often do not meet the criteria of patentability, such as novelty and non-obviousness. Thus, protecting software requires the use of other forms of intellectual property, such as copyright or licensing, which allow developers to protect their creations and control their use.
Novelty means that an invention is not previously known anywhere in the world. Non-obviousness implies that a person skilled in the art cannot independently derive the claims for the invention based on previously known data. These two criteria are fundamental for assessing patentability and the possibility of protecting intellectual property.
The distribution and use of computer programs has become a mass phenomenon, which has had a significant impact on the choice of the most effective legal protection options. With the software industry rapidly growing, it is important to consider how this impact shapes legal approaches and mechanisms for protecting intellectual property. Legal protection of software requires adaptation to new market realities, which emphasizes the need to develop effective copyright and patent protection strategies to ensure security and fairness in the technology industry.
In the early 1970s, the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) proposed creating unique legal protection for computer programs, considering them as a special type of intellectual product. By 1983, WIPO had drafted an international treaty that became the basis for the further development of software protection. This initiative contributed to the formation of a legal framework for the protection of copyright in software products and facilitated the development of the software industry globally.
Within the framework of contractual relations, the protection of computer programs combines elements of copyright and patent law. However, this proposal was not supported by developed countries. Large corporations, which had become monopolies in the software market, believed that the legal regime of copyright provided them with the greatest advantages.
By this time, the United States had already begun to protect computer programs in accordance with the Copyright Act of 1976. In 1980, this law was supplemented with a special mention of computer programs. Since then, leading countries such as the United Kingdom, France, and Japan have begun amending their copyright laws to include provisions for software protection. These changes have marked an important step toward establishing a legal framework for protecting intellectual property in technology and programming. There are several key reasons why copyright is an effective tool for protecting computer programs. First, copyright grants developers exclusive rights to use, distribute, and modify their software. This helps protect intellectual property and prevent unauthorized copying and use of programs. Second, copyright helps create incentives for innovation and the development of new technologies. By protecting their programs, developers can derive economic benefit from their work, which in turn encourages them to invest resources in further research and development. Furthermore, copyright provides legal protection in the event of copyright infringement. This allows developers to go to court to protect their interests, making copyright a reliable tool in the fight against piracy and copyright infringement.
Finally, copyright helps set standards of quality and security in the software industry, as protected programs are often accompanied by a quality guarantee from the developers. Thus, copyright plays an important role in the protection of computer programs, promoting the development of technology and ensuring the protection of the rights of developers.
- Computer programs meet the criteria for the protectability of a work: they are expressed in an objective form accessible to human perception and are creative in nature.
- Legal protection of works does not require compliance with formalities, that is, the copyright holder does not need to go through an expensive and lengthy patenting procedure - the rights to a computer program arise from the moment of its creation.
- Since there is no need to obtain a patent, there are no problems with registering rights to a program abroad: these arise for companies and programmer-authors on the basis of international copyright agreements. In the age of the Internet and the widespread use of software products, this argument becomes decisive.
The application of copyright law in the field of software is not always without difficulties. Although the law provides mechanisms for protecting intellectual property, a number of key issues of interest to both programmers and users remain unresolved. These controversial issues require careful analysis in order to ensure fairness and transparency in the use of software products.
- Which structural components of a program are protected by copyright?
- How can those components that are not covered by copyright be protected?
- What can a software developer use from existing solutions to create new programs?
A computer program includes several structural components, each of which has a unique legal status. These components may include source code, object code, documentation, and other elements, all of which are subject to different legal standards and protection. Understanding the legal status of these components is an important aspect of software development and use.
What Copyright Protects
The literal components of a program include source code, source code, and object code. Although the law does not provide a clear definition of source code, GOSTs mention the concept of source code. In a legal context, these terms can be considered synonyms, since both reflect the basic elements of software. Understanding these components is important for copyright protection and the proper use of software products.
Source code is the text form of a computer program containing source code. Object code is the result of compiling this source code and represents the executable version of the program. These program elements, source code and object code, are subject to copyright protection, which confirms their significance in the field of intellectual property. Protecting these components is important to ensure the rights of developers and prevent unauthorized use of their software products.
Non-literal components of a program are visual and audio elements that are formed during its operation. Audiovisual displays created by a program are an integral part of it, which can receive independent legal protection under certain conditions. For example, the graphic design of the user interface can be protected as an industrial design. This emphasizes the importance of protecting non-literal components of software, thereby ensuring their uniqueness and commercial value.
The original name of a program plays a key role in its identification and perception. It should reflect the essence of the work, giving it uniqueness. At the same time, the name must meet the criteria of originality, being the result of the author's creative process. Otherwise, it will not be able to receive legal protection. Creating an original name requires a careful approach, as it forms the first impression of the product and affects its success in the market.
Preparatory materials represent an important stage in the process of developing a computer program. Although they cannot be considered part of the code, they serve as the foundation for the effective creation and implementation of software. These materials include diagrams, specifications, requirements, and other documents that help developers clearly define the goals and objectives of the project. Proper preparation of such materials improves the quality of the final product and simplifies the development process.
What Copyright Does Not Protect
Ideas, methods, and principles play an important role in software development, especially in the area of user interface design. According to the Civil Code, copyright does not protect ideas in themselves. Protection is granted only if the idea is realized through the author's creative activity and materialized in an objective form, such as text, images, audio recordings, or video recordings. This emphasizes the importance of not only the originality of an idea but also its implementation in concrete results, which is directly related to the development of a high-quality and intuitive user interface.
An algorithm is a key structural element of a program, reflecting its content and meaning and determining the final result. It is important to note that algorithms fall outside the scope of copyright, which protects only the original form of a work, not its content. In some cases, an algorithm may receive legal protection, but exclusively through patent law. This emphasizes the importance of algorithms in programming, as they form the basis for the development of software products and technologies.
Programming language is an important aspect in the field of intellectual property. According to the Civil Code, programming languages are not subject to copyright protection. This means that source code written in one programming language can be transformed and adapted to another language. From a legal perspective, such a transformation is considered a modification of the software. This provision emphasizes the need to understand the legal aspects of software development, as well as the importance of complying with license agreements that may govern the use and modification of software code.
Unoriginal Program Name. Computer program names serve an important function, as they not only identify the application but also reveal its purpose and features. Often, such names lack creativity, which can make them difficult to remember and attract users. In such cases, developers should consider protecting names through intellectual property rights, such as trademarks. Registering a trademark will not only help protect the uniqueness of the name but also increase its recognition in the marketplace.
Some computer programs require state registration for legal use. State registration of software provides intellectual property protection and ensures that the product meets established standards.
Such programs include those that have specific functions or are intended for professional use, such as medical, financial, and engineering applications. State registration is also required for programs that work with users' personal data or access government databases.
The registration process includes filing an application with the relevant authority, providing documentation, and checking for compliance with security and functionality requirements. Software registration not only protects the rights of developers but also builds user confidence in the product.
Copyright protection for works, including computer programs, begins upon their creation. However, voluntary state registration with Rospatent is available for software. Registration can provide additional benefits, such as confirmation of ownership and simplification of the copyright protection process in the event of disputes.
If you plan to use your program in commercial or other business activities, or wish to confirm authorship and rights to it, you must submit the relevant documents to Rospatent and pay the state fee. This will ensure the protection of your rights and help establish the legal ownership of the program by a specific author or copyright holder. Registration with Rospatent is an important step in protecting intellectual property and preventing potential disputes over software ownership.
The cost of legal services for software registration typically ranges from 15,000 to 25,000 rubles. The state fee is 3,000 rubles for individuals and 4,500 rubles for legal entities. Proper software registration is important for protecting intellectual property and ensuring the legality of its use. Consulting with professional lawyers will help avoid mistakes and speed up the registration process.
The Rospatent website provides all the necessary document forms and details for paying the state fee. After submitting the documents, information about the program will be entered into the state register, and you will receive a state registration certificate.
Court practice: expert opinion decides everything
We will examine the difficulties that arise when protecting software using copyright, using case law as an example. Protecting software through copyright involves a number of legal nuances. First, the originality and creative nature of the program must be proven. Second, disputes often arise over the legality of using certain code fragments. Court cases show that insufficient documentation and a lack of clear evidence can lead to a loss in court. It's also important to remember that copyright does not protect ideas and concepts, but only their expression in a specific form. Therefore, software developers must consider these aspects to effectively protect their rights and interests.
OOO NPP Deimand, the manufacturer and exclusive owner of the MedIS-T Medical Information System computer program, filed a lawsuit against OOO Medotrade. The plaintiff claims that the defendant illegally registered a modification of its program, thereby violating its exclusive rights. In the lawsuit, the plaintiff demands that the use of the modified program be stopped and monetary compensation for copyright infringement. In turn, the defendant claims to have developed the program independently and independently of the plaintiff. The proceedings in this case highlight the importance of protecting intellectual property in the field of medical information systems.
The Moscow Arbitration Court concluded that the plaintiff did not provide sufficient evidence of illegal use of the software. Higher courts upheld this decision, supporting the position of the trial court.
The forensic examination provided key data that could significantly impact the course of the case. It revealed facts confirming or refuting the accusations and determined the degree of guilt of the participants. The results of the analyses and studies conducted by the experts formed the basis for further legal action. Forensic examination plays a vital role in establishing the truth, as it ensures an objective approach to collecting and evaluating evidence. This data may include the results of forensic examinations, medical reports, and other evidence that can be used in court.
The results of the forensic examination, on which the Arbitration Court based its decision, were of key importance. These findings formed the basis for the judicial act and had a significant impact on the final decision. The forensic examination provided objective data and facts that helped the court understand the situation and render a fair verdict.
After analyzing the source codes of the disputed programs registered with Rospatent, the first expert concluded that certain fragments of the source code provided by the defendant for examination constituted an independent result. The programming language elements, their syntactic features, and their location in the analyzed source code fragments are unique and do not match the corresponding elements of the plaintiff's source code. Therefore, the originality and independence of the presented materials can be confirmed.
The expert emphasized that the study only included fragments of the source code of software products such as the MedIS-T MIS, the Patient MIS, and the Patient 2.0 MIS. The full source code for these programs was not provided, meaning that the study's conclusions apply only to specific sections of the program code. This limitation should be taken into account when interpreting the results.
The second expert concluded that it was impossible to establish the presence or absence of modifications. A visual inspection of the source code fragments submitted for examination revealed no overlaps in the functionality of the software modules or executable procedures. Reliably measuring the percentage of code matches in the fragment under study is also impossible, making it difficult to identify specific features of the author's style.
The court found that the examination must use only those parts of the program code registered by the plaintiff and defendant with Rospatent. This is due to the fact that the program can be modified at any time by employees of the plaintiff and defendant, as well as by third parties, including end users. This opinion was supported by experts during the trial, emphasizing the importance of using registered code fragments to ensure the correctness and reliability of the examination.
It is important to note that until 2016, Rospatent had restrictions on the number of source code pages submitted for registration. The maximum permitted number was 50 pages, which could significantly affect the examination results and court decisions in plagiarism cases against registered programs. The limitation on the volume of source code created risks for the development and protection of intellectual property, since a smaller volume of information might not provide a complete understanding of the essence of the work. This circumstance emphasizes the importance of properly preparing materials for registration, as well as the need to consider all possible consequences in the event of copyright infringement.
Today, it is possible to fully register source code with Rospatent. However, disputes over the infringement of the rights of software owners through source code modification continue to be among the most difficult for experts and courts. These issues require in-depth analysis, since law enforcement in this area often encounters ambiguities and contradictions. Registering source code provides some protection, but cases of its modification give rise to difficulties in determining the boundaries of legal use.
What's Next
In this article, we will discuss software protection through patent law, consider the advantages and disadvantages of patent protection, and also touch on the difficulties that may arise during the patenting process. Software patents are becoming increasingly important in the context of rapid technological advancements, and understanding their features will help developers effectively protect their ideas and innovations.

