Code

What is open source license compatibility?

What is open source license compatibility?

Free Python Course ➞ Mini-course for beginners and experienced coders. 4 cool projects in the portfolio, live communication with the speaker. Click and find out what you can learn in the course.

Learn more

License compatibility is the ability to integrate programs or their components that are under different licenses. Legally combining such programs is possible only if the terms of these licenses are consistent. It is important to keep in mind that when using different licenses, you must carefully study their terms to avoid violations and ensure the lawful use of the software.

Proprietary licenses clearly define the terms of software use, making them incompatible with each other. In contrast, open source licenses can vary: some are completely incompatible, while others allow a combination of open source and proprietary software. This diversity of licenses opens up opportunities for developers and users, allowing them to choose the appropriate option based on their specific needs and goals.

What you need to know before using

When using open source solutions in your project, it is important to consider potential compatibility issues. This can occur when different code components are under different open source licenses. Failure to comply with the license requirements of the borrowed code may result in a violation of the developer's rights, giving them grounds for claims. To avoid these situations, it is recommended to carefully study the licenses of each component and ensure their compatibility at all stages of development. This will not only protect you from legal consequences but will also allow you to take advantage of open source technologies more effectively.

Open source licenses can be classified into two main categories: reciprocal and permissive. Cross-licenses require derivative works to be released under the same license, ensuring that freedom remains for all users. Permissive licenses, by contrast, allow the use, modification, and distribution of works with fewer restrictions, which can attract more developers and users. Understanding these categories of free licenses is important for choosing the right licensing model that suits your goals and philosophy.

Cross-licenses, or copyleft licenses, including those in the GNU family, are often incompatible with each other and with other free licenses. This is because new products, as well as those that incorporate code or portions of it licensed under GNU, are required to be distributed exclusively under a specific version of GNU. This strict adherence to a license protects user freedom and supports the free software philosophy, but can create difficulties when integrating different software solutions.

Permissive licenses are compatible with each other and with other free and proprietary licenses. The most popular permissive licenses include BSD and MIT, which provide developers with flexibility in using and distributing software. These licenses allow users to modify and adapt the code, as well as integrate it into their own projects, making them attractive to many developers.

Permissive licenses can often coexist with reciprocal licenses. In such cases, individual parts of the code remain under their original licenses, while the entire program is licensed under a reciprocal license. An exception is 4-clause BSD licenses, which require mandatory citation in advertising of products containing code licensed under 4-clause BSD. This is an important aspect to consider when choosing a software license.

What Affects Compatibility

Richard Stallman classifies free licenses into three categories: licenses without copyleft, licenses with weak copyleft, and licenses with strict copyleft. Each of these categories has its own characteristics and purposes, allowing developers and users to choose the most appropriate terms for working with software and content. Licenses without copyleft grant users the freedom to use, modify, and distribute without placing restrictions on derivative works. Licenses with lax copyleft permit use and modification of the software but require that derivative works also be freely licensed. Licenses with strict copyleft, on the other hand, impose strict conditions under which derivative works must remain under the same license as the original.

Licenses without copyleft, known as lax permissive licenses, offer a high degree of compatibility and allow developers to use licensed code in proprietary projects. This means they can integrate open source code into closed products, as well as build commercial solutions based on it. Licenses such as 3-clause BSD, X11, Expat, Apache, Python, and others fall into this category. These licenses provide flexibility and freedom for developers, making them attractive for use in a variety of software solutions.

When combining pieces of code released under different licenses, each piece retains its own license. If separating these pieces becomes difficult, the entire program should be licensed under all applicable licenses. This approach ensures copyright and protects the interests of developers, and also allows users to understand the terms of use for each code component.

Licenses with weak copyleft, also known as intermediate licenses, allow the integration of proprietary code, provided that the developer meets certain requirements. Such licenses include the Eclipse Public License and the Mozilla Public License. These licenses strike a balance between free software and commercial interests, allowing developers to use open components in their products while keeping some code closed.

Intermediate licenses are often incompatible with cross-licenses, as they do not include terms requiring the combined programs to be distributed under copyleft licenses. This limitation can impact developers and users seeking to integrate various software solutions, as the lack of compatibility can lead to legal and practical difficulties in using and distributing the software. Therefore, it is important to consider licensing requirements when selecting and using software products.

Hard copyleft licenses, also known as reciprocal licenses, prohibit the use of the licensed code in proprietary products. The software and its modifications may be distributed exclusively under the terms of the original license. Such licenses include the GNU GPL versions 2 and 3. These licenses protect the freedom to use, modify, and distribute software, making them popular among developers seeking to maintain the openness of their projects.

Reciprocal licenses are incompatible with each other, as they require that any software product developed based on the licensed one be distributed under the same license. However, it is possible to circumvent this limitation.

How to Combine Different Licenses and Different License Versions

There are various ways to overcome the incompatibility of mutual licenses. One of the most effective methods is to use compatible licenses, which help avoid legal conflicts. You can also consider adapting existing licenses to meet the requirements of both parties. It is important to carefully analyze the licenses and their terms to determine the most appropriate solution. Consulting with legal experts in the field of copyright can significantly simplify the process of agreeing on licenses and minimize risks.

License compatibility should be explicitly clarified. For example, source code licensed under the GNU GPL v3 can be combined with code licensed under the GNU AGPL. The result is a new product that will be distributed under the GNU Affero GPL.

It is recommended to add a clause about compatibility with later versions of the license. When dealing with different versions of the same cross-license, the Free Software Foundation encourages developers to include the clause "the program is released under the GNU GPL version N or later" in their GNU GPL licenses. This clause facilitates the sharing of software released under different versions of the GNU GPL. The decision to include this clause in the license text is up to the developers.

Including a license upgrade clause is an important aspect of ensuring compatibility between different versions. An effective approach is to add a clause allowing the license to be upgraded to a later version. This principle is already actively used by organizations such as PHP, the Mozilla Foundation, and Creative Commons. Their licenses clearly state the upgrade clause, which eliminates the possibility of arbitrary interpretation by developers. This provides users with confidence that they will always have access to the latest licensing terms.

Richard Stallman argues that an approach based on clear and precise rules is more reasonable. He emphasizes that the subjective discretion of authors can lead to incompatibility between software versions. Stallman also believes that if GPL v4 is released, a clause allowing users to upgrade to later versions of the license should be included. This will ensure greater flexibility and compatibility in using the software, which is especially important in a rapidly changing technological landscape.

Software relicensing is an important process in open source software development. This practice is necessary when the licenses for different program modules are incompatible and need to be integrated into a single solution. In such cases, relicensing becomes the only possible way to ensure compatibility and legitimate use of all components. This allows developers to effectively combine the functionality of different modules and create more complete and versatile software products.

How to relicense a program

In order for relicensing to be legally binding, it is necessary to obtain the consent of all interested copyright holders to change the license. In the case of free software, given the large number of contributors to open source projects, achieving 100% agreement among authors is difficult. In most cases, obtaining approval from an overwhelming majority of copyright holders is sufficient. This avoids legal disputes and ensures the legitimacy of the new license agreement.

The Mozilla Foundation set a standard of 95% coverage as sufficient for successful work. The Mozilla Firefox browser was one of the first open source projects to successfully implement the concept of relicensing. This approach helped ensure the flexibility and accessibility of the software, which contributed to its popularity and widespread adoption among users.

The source code for the Netscape Communicator 4.0 browser was initially released under the Netscape Public License and the Mozilla Public License. However, this choice of license drew criticism from the Free Software Foundation (FSF) and the Open Source Initiative (OSI) due to its lack of compatibility with other open source licenses.

In 2001, Time Warner, in accordance with the terms of the Netscape Public License and at the request of the Mozilla Foundation, relicensed its entire code. This code, which included work by other authors, was relicensed under the terms of the MPL v1.1 / GPL v2.0 / LGPL v2.1. This change was an important step in the development of open source software and contributed to improved compatibility and accessibility of code for developers.

Some strict copyleft licenses allow programs to be relicensed under other copyleft licenses. One example is the CeCILL license, which contains a clause guaranteeing compatibility with the GNU GPL version 2.0 and later. The GNU LGPL 2.1 license also explicitly permits relicensing under the GNU GPL version 2.0 and later. This allows developers the flexibility to use and adapt the software while preserving the authors' rights and complying with the copyleft terms.

The GNU LGPL v3 is an extended version of the GNU GPL v3, offering additional permissions for users. Section 7 of the LGPL v3 states that these additional permissions may be revoked, resulting in the program being relicensed under the standard GNU GPL v3. This means that developers can choose stricter licensing terms if desired. Thus, LGPL v3 provides flexibility in the use and distribution of software, allowing developers to adapt the license terms to suit their needs.

If a program permits use under the GNU LGPL v2 or later, it can be relicensed under GPL v3 or later. Richard Stallman emphasizes that for each future version of the GPL N (where N > 3), the Free Software Foundation (FSF) will develop corresponding versions of the LGPL N with additional permissions. This provides flexibility in the use and evolution of software, allowing developers to adapt their projects to changes in licensing.

One-Way License

Relicensing is an effective tool for resolving license incompatibility issues. However, it is important to understand that this process is not universal. If License A allows relicensing to License B, this does not guarantee that License B also allows reversion to License A. Each license has its own terms and limitations that must be considered when using and redistributing the software.

The CC BY-SA 4.0 license allows relicensing of modified versions under the GNU GPL v3, but relicensing from GPL v3 to CC BY-SA is not possible. Creative Commons licenses are not generally intended for software. However, in some cases, such as hardware designs or artistic elements in computer games, it may be necessary to combine materials released under CC BY-SA with materials licensed under the GNU GPL. This is possible thanks to the relicensing provision provided by CC BY-SA.

Relicensing is permitted only if explicitly stated in the agreement. It is important to note that the compatibility clause and the relicensing clause have different meanings and are not interchangeable.

The GNU GPL v3 and GNU AGPL both have compatibility clauses, but relicensing a program from one license to the other is not possible—neither license allows it. It is important to note that the GNU AGPL v3 is not a "later version" of the regular GNU GPL v2, as the GNU AGPL and the GNU GPL are two different licenses. This distinction is important to consider when choosing a license for software, as it affects the terms of use and distribution of the code.

It is important to remember that a license is version-specific. If the clause is not specified for "versions X and later," then relicensing to a later version is not possible, let alone to earlier versions. The Free Software Foundation encourages developers who use relicensing clauses to list themselves as the agent determining the license version. You can also contact the program's authors for permission to relicense. Following these guidelines will help avoid legal problems and ensure the correct use of licenses.

Free License Compatibility and Dual Licensing

Dual licensing is one of the main business models in the Open Source space. This model allows the same program to be distributed under two or more licenses, which is called multi-licensing. Software users have the opportunity to choose which of the offered licenses they want to subscribe to. In some situations, it is required to accept the terms of all licenses at once, which may happen, for example, if the software has multiple owners. Dual licensing provides flexibility to both developers and users, promoting wider distribution and adoption of software products.

This scheme is an effective way to overcome the incompatibility of free licenses. If at least one of the free licenses of one program is compatible with the free license of another program, this allows you to use both programs in your product. This approach promotes the maximum use of open source software and simplifies the integration of various solutions, which is especially important for developers and companies striving to create high-quality products while taking into account the legal aspects of licensing.

The Mozilla Application Suite source code previously used triple licensing, including MPL 1.1, GNU GPL v2.0, and LGPL v2.1. With the release of the GPL-compatible MPL v2.0, triple licensing is no longer necessary. This simplification facilitates more efficient license management and improves compatibility with other open source projects.

Examples of dual-licensed programming languages ​​include Perl and Ruby. Perl is distributed under a dual license that combines the GNU GPL and the Artistic License. Ruby also offers dual licensing, including the terms of the GNU GPL in its license agreement. Dual licensing allows developers to choose the most appropriate license for their projects, promoting flexibility and software redistribution.

When choosing dual or multiple licensing, the FSF recommends using the GNU GPL v3.0 or later, as well as other compatible licenses. This will ensure compatibility with most free software. Strict copyleft advocates believe that the GPL and AGPL v3 and later versions best protect users' freedom. Choosing these licenses will preserve the benefits of open source while protecting users' rights.

The FSF website provides a GNU License Compatibility Chart and a list of free software licenses that are compatible or incompatible with the GNU GPL. These resources can help users better understand how different licenses interact with each other, which is important for complying with the terms of use of the software.

How Free License Terms Work Together When Combining Software

If you have selected several free programs with compatible licenses for your project, it is important to choose the right license for the combined program. In this case, the license for your program must combine all the licenses of its components. The question you face is: under which license will your program be released? The choice of license matters both for legal protection and for compliance with the terms of use of the source code. Make sure you carefully review each license and understand its requirements to avoid legal issues when distributing your program. Choosing the right license will not only protect your interests but also ensure that the rights of original program authors are respected.

To answer this question, you need to list all the licenses for the combined program and identify which ones are key to the successful implementation of the project. This will help you clearly understand which licenses need to be considered and how they may affect the development of the project.

Some free licenses may be compatible with each other, meaning the terms of one license can be satisfied by another. If all the requirements of a certain license are satisfied by the terms of other licenses, it can be excluded from the list of licenses used. This simplifies license management and allows you to focus on the most relevant ones.

  • The GNU GPL version N and the GNU Affero GPL version N cover the LGPL version N, and all three cover the LGPL version 2.1.
  • Any GNU version N license covers the Apache 2.0 license when N > 3.
  • The GNU GPL version N covers all versions of the Mozilla Public License that are compatible with it.
  • The Apache 2.0 license covers the BSD, Expat, X11, ISC, and CC0 licenses.
  • Three-clause BSD covers two-clause BSD.
  • The BSD licenses cover the Expat, X11, and ISC licenses, as well as CC0.

In summary

To ensure the legality of using open source code, When creating repositories in your program, it is important to consider license compatibility. This is important for protecting the rights of authors and developers. Choosing the right license will help avoid legal issues and ensure compliance with the terms of use of the source code.

Free licenses that do not contain mutually exclusive terms are generally considered compatible. Compatibility can often be determined by the license text. The developer can also specify the compatibility of different types of licenses or new versions with previous ones. Proper understanding of the licensing terms is important for copyright compliance and the effective use of the software.

License compatibility can be achieved through relicensing and dual licensing. However, it is important to note that license compatibility does not automatically mean the ability to switch from one license to another. The copyright holder must explicitly indicate the possibility of relicensing in the license terms. This clarification helps avoid misunderstandings and ensures transparency in the management of rights to use works.

Read also:

This section invites you to familiarize yourself with additional materials that may be of interest to you. We have collected a variety of articles and resources to deepen your knowledge and broaden your horizons on this topic. Don't miss the opportunity to learn more and improve your skills. Each of the presented materials has been carefully selected to provide you with relevant and useful information.

  • A Guide to Free GNU Licenses: What They Are and What Types They Are
  • Internet Building Blocks: Top 10 Concepts of Modern Web Architecture You Definitely Need to Know
  • Mike Pound: What Are Feedback Shift Registers and What Are They Used For