Contents:

Free Python Course ➞ Mini-Course for Beginners and Experienced Coders. 4 cool projects for your portfolio, live communication with the speaker. Click and find out what you can learn in the course.
Learn moreA few months ago, the Rambler v. Sysoev case came into focus, in which the company attempted to wrest rights to the Nginx web server from its former system administrator. Rambler's legal team argued that Nginx is a work made for hire, and therefore, all rights to it should belong to Rambler. This case raises important questions about software ownership and how the status of a work made for hire affects the rights of developers.
Works made for hire are an important topic that raises many questions for both employers and developers. We decided to delve deeper into this issue to understand what these works are, how they are created, and why problems often arise with them. Understanding these aspects will help employers protect their interests and developers better understand their rights. This knowledge will be useful for all participants in the work process striving for high-quality results and compliance with the law.
What is a work made for hire?
A work made for hire is the result of intellectual activity created by an employee under an employment contract. Such works include various types of work, including articles, web designs, architectural designs, computer programs, and other products of mental labor. A complete list of works made for hire can be found in Article 1225 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.
A work is considered made for hire only if its creation is part of the author's job duties. This means that when hiring a developer to create software or databases, the employment contract must include the appropriate wording, for example: "Development of computer programs and databases." This approach ensures legal clarity and protects the interests of both employer and employee.
The question of who owns the code requires careful consideration. The company holds exclusive rights to a work made for hire, allowing it to legally use it or transfer it to third parties. However, the copyright remains with the creator. If, for example, you wrote code using a neural network, you remain its author. This means you have the right to compensation and protection against appropriation of your work by another party. It is important to understand that a balance must be maintained between the company's rights and the creator's copyright to avoid legal conflicts and ensure fair compensation for intellectual work.
Sometimes, the author transfers exclusive rights to their work to the employer. This occurs three years from the date of transfer, if the employer:
- does not use the work made for hire themselves;
- does not transfer it to a legally protected secret;
- does not transfer the rights to it to a third party.
Previously, Russian legislation had a different approach to copyright. Until 2008, all works created by employees on behalf of the employer were automatically considered to be made for hire. This rule applied even in cases where the creation of the work was not explicitly stated in the employment contract. Such changes in the legal field highlight the evolution of approaches to intellectual property protection in Russia.
If a dispute arises over a work created before 2008, it will be resolved in accordance with the rules in effect at that time. For example, in judicial practice there is the Rambler v. Nginx case, which we have already mentioned. This case illustrates how old norms continue to influence the resolution of copyright disputes.

Read also:
Comparison of Rambler & Lynwood and Sysoev & Nginx codes
The question of code quality between Rambler & Lynwood, Sysoev, and Nginx are generating significant interest among developers and web technology specialists. Rambler and Lynwood are significant projects, each with its own unique features and advantages. Sysoev and Nginx, on the other hand, are known for their efficiency and performance in processing requests. Rambler and Lynwood's code is characterized by a certain architectural complexity, which allows for high functionality but also makes it less flexible in some cases. Lynwood, as part of the Rambler ecosystem, enables the integration of various services, which can be both an advantage and a disadvantage depending on the specific tasks. Sysoev and Nginx, on the other hand, are known for their simplicity and high performance. Nginx's code is optimized for handling large volumes of traffic, making it an ideal choice for high-load sites. Its asynchronous request processing model allows for quick and efficient management of server resources.
Thus, the choice between Rambler & Lynwood and Sysoev & Nginx depends on the specific requirements of the project. If integration and multifunctionality are important, Rambler & Lynwood may be a good choice. If high performance and load stability are required, Nginx will be the preferred option.
Risks for the Employer
A company risks losing exclusive rights to its work if it does not use it for three years, does not transfer it to another person, or does not transfer it to a protected secret. This is important to take into account in order to protect your intellectual rights and avoid possible legal consequences. Regular use of the work, compliance with the terms of transfer of rights, and maintaining confidentiality will help preserve exclusive rights to intellectual property.
However, there are some complexities that should be considered.
Ongoing software development process. Most programs on the market are created and maintained over many years. Unlike writing text or creating graphics, in software development it is more difficult to clearly define the moment of completion of the work and the transfer of the product to the employer. This is due to the fact that software requires constant updating, optimization, and improvements. Therefore, it is important to consider that a successful development process includes not only code creation, but also support, testing, and implementation of updates throughout the product's lifecycle.
A collaborative approach to software development is an important aspect in the IT field. Utility software is often created as a collaborative effort, which raises questions about who can be considered a co-author. According to the law, co-authors are only those employees who have made a creative contribution to the development of the program. It is important to note that material, technical, or organizational support cannot serve as grounds for recognizing co-authorship. Therefore, a clear understanding of the rights and responsibilities of team members is essential for the successful completion of a project and the protection of intellectual property.

Remote work is becoming increasingly popular among developers who do not always work in the office and are not limited by fixed working hours. This format of work provides flexibility, allowing specialists to choose a convenient time and place to complete their tasks. However, the remote nature of work can complicate the process of determining the service status of programs, as there is no traditional office context. It is important to consider these aspects when organizing the workflow and interacting with the team.
Employers should carefully formalize employment relationships with employees, taking into account the specifics related to intellectual property. Incorrect formalization can lead to legal consequences, including the possibility that the employee will be able to assert their rights to software developed at the initiative of the employer and using its resources. This emphasizes the importance of a clear and comprehensive contract that will protect the interests of both parties and prevent conflicts in the future.
What rights does the employee have to service programs?
The employer receives exclusive rights to the work, while all other rights remain with the employee. This means that the author retains the right to use their creation for other purposes unrelated to work. It is important to note that this distribution of rights protects the interests of both the employer and the employee, ensuring a balance between commercial interests and the rights of the creator.
- right of authorship;
- right to a name;
- right to the integrity of the work;
- right to protect the author's reputation.
The author has the right to publish their work, but this situation is not so simple. Exclusive rights to the work are usually transferred to the employer, and in this case, the author cannot independently publish their creation unless specified in the employment contract. This means that if you create the world's first AGI while working, you will have to keep this information secret - publication in open repositories such as Hugging Face will be impossible without the consent of the employer.
Continuing. If the employer begins to use the work made for hire, transfers it to the regime of a secret protected by law, or transfers the rights to it to a third party, the employee acquires the right to remuneration. The amount of remuneration and the payment procedure are established in the contract. It is also worth noting that this right is not subject to inheritance; it can only be exercised by the author of the work.
It is important to understand that salary and remuneration are different concepts. This distinction creates additional difficulties for the employer. What should be done in a situation where the employee's primary function is to create works? For example, a programmer receives a salary for developing an application, but may also expect additional compensation for their work. It is important to find a balance between these concepts in order to properly evaluate the contribution of each employee and ensure a fair remuneration system.
There are two options: you can enter into a separate remuneration agreement with the employee or include the relevant terms in the employment contract. However, in practice, parties often approach this issue formally, specifying minimum remuneration amounts in contracts. Nevertheless, such payments cannot be ignored, as the employee has the right to demand them through the courts in the event of non-payment. It is important to properly formalize the terms of remuneration to avoid possible legal consequences.
In this article, we will consider an example from judicial practice that illustrates important aspects of law enforcement. Court cases often provide clear examples of how legal norms operate in real-world situations. In this context, let's consider a case in which the court made a decision based on an analysis of evidence and legal norms. Such examples help us understand how courts interpret laws and what factors influence their final decisions. Studying case law is an important tool for lawyers and specialists seeking a deeper understanding of the legal system and its dynamics.
Plaintiff: writer Alexey Alekseev (name changed).
Defendant: Progress LLC (name changed). In this context, it is important to understand that Progress LLC is a key participant in the case under consideration. This organization is actively operating in the market and has a certain reputation. It is important to keep in mind that all actions and decisions concerning Progress LLC may influence further developments. Understanding the role of the defendant will help better assess the situation and make informed decisions within this process.
Alexey co-authored a book, which was classified as a work for hire. His employer published the book and began distributing it for a fee. However, Alexey received no compensation for the use of his work. Therefore, he filed a lawsuit, demanding compensation for the use of the work made for hire.
The court ruled against paying the plaintiff compensation. This is because the plaintiff created the book as part of his employment. He had already received wages for his work, which included royalties for the employer's use of the work made for hire. Thus, the plaintiff's employment fully covered his rights to compensation for the work he created.
The cassation court found that the previous conclusions were inconsistent with the law and therefore overturned the decision of the court of first instance.
Why is compensation established by copyright law, and not labor law? Remuneration provided for by copyright cannot be replaced by wages, since it is related to intellectual property rights. Copyright protects creative work and the results of intellectual activity, ensuring authors the right to receive remuneration for the use of their works. This remuneration is the result of the author's unique contribution and is not subject to replacement by standard labor payments.
Wages paid to an employee within the framework of an employment relationship for the performance of his duties are not considered copyright remuneration. Copyright remuneration, in turn, refers to the amount the author receives for the use of a work created for hire. This distinction is important to consider when determining the legal aspects of labor and copyright relations.
We recommend that you read the Resolution of the Presidium of the St. Petersburg City Court dated November 30, 2016, in case No. 4G-4337/2016. This document contains important information and legal aspects that may be useful for studying judicial practice and understanding the decisions made by the court in similar cases.
In accordance with the agreement between the employee and the employer, the author may retain exclusive rights to the created work. In this situation, the employer has the right to use the work made for hire based on the terms of the agreement, which implies a simple (non-exclusive) license. The employer is also obligated to pay the author the remuneration stipulated by this agreement. This ensures the protection of the author's rights and guarantees fair compensation for the use of their creative work.
When Russian courts do not recognize software as proprietary
The Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation contains a number of key rules regarding the resolution of legal disputes related to works made for hire. These rules are aimed at ensuring a fair hearing and protecting the rights of parties involved in disputes over works made for hire. Judicial practice in this area is based on a clear delineation of the rights and responsibilities of both employers and employees creating works as part of their official duties. Understanding these rules will help avoid legal conflicts and ensure proper protection of intellectual property.
- The court will examine whether the creation of the work falls within the scope of the employee's job duties. If not, the work is not considered to be made for hire; the exclusive right to it belongs to the employee.
- The fact that the author used the employer's material resources (for example, official equipment) to create the work will not be considered grounds for recognizing the work as made for hire.
- In the event of a dispute, it is the employer who bears the burden of proof that a specific work created by the employee is made for hire.

This article will examine a case study that illustrates important aspects of law enforcement. Court cases often serve as the basis for the further development of legal norms and practice. This real-life example demonstrates how courts interpret laws and make decisions based on the evidence presented.
An important element of judicial practice is the analysis of the specific circumstances of the case, which allows the court to make an informed decision. For example, in a situation where the parties were presented with a convincing set of evidence, the court took into account all factors, including the factual circumstances and the provisions of current legislation. This confirms that judicial practice often serves as the basis for legal conclusions and recommendations.
Thus, examples from judicial practice not only help understand how laws are applied in practice but also form an idea of what actions can lead to the successful resolution of disputes in court. These cases serve as an important reference point for lawyers and individuals seeking to protect their rights and interests.
The plaintiff in this case is Amedico Limited Liability Company.
Defendant: TelePat LLC. This legal entity is actively operating in the field of telecommunications services, offering a wide range of solutions for businesses and private clients. TelePat LLC has established itself as a reliable partner, providing high-quality communications services, internet access, and other telecommunications solutions. We strive to continually improve our services and meet our customers' needs.
Amedico has filed a lawsuit against TelePat for the illegal use of the Medsenger medical messenger. The plaintiff claims that the software was developed by an employee while working at Amedico. He then founded TelePat LLC with another employee and transferred exclusive rights to use the program to that company. Since Medsenger is service software, the plaintiff considers all these actions illegal. The case is of significant interest in the IT and medical fields, raising questions about intellectual property rights and the legality of software transfer.
Evidence may include an employment contract, correspondence with the author, and witness testimony from other employees involved in the project. Furthermore, the fact that the author registered the program while working at Amedico is an important argument. These materials will help confirm the legality and validity of the copyright to the developed product.
The court dismissed the claim. This means that the stated claims were not satisfied. The court's decision may affect the parties' further actions, including the possibility of filing an appeal or retrial. It is important to understand that a dismissal of a claim is not always final, and in some cases, additional legal steps are possible.
Why is it important to understand the reasons? Understanding the reasons allows us to better understand the consequences of our actions and decisions. It helps us make informed decisions and avoid mistakes in the future. Understanding the reasons allows us to analyze situations more deeply, which in turn contributes to personal and professional growth. This knowledge also helps us build better relationships with others, as we begin to better understand their motivations and needs. Thus, understanding the reasons is a key element in the decision-making process and improving the quality of life.
- The documents provided do not prove that Amedico has exclusive rights to the Medsenger program.
- From the correspondence with the author, it does not follow that the disputed program was created as part of work duties, nor does it follow that exclusive rights to the program have transferred to the employer.
- TelePat Company is the legal copyright holder of the program, since it acquired exclusive rights to it. The agreement confirming the transaction was registered in the Register of Computer Programs on March 20, 2018.
The court of appeal upheld the findings of the trial court, noting that the case file lacked the necessary evidence. Such findings emphasize the importance of careful preparation of the evidence base in court proceedings. The absence of key documents can significantly affect the outcome of the case and lead to the denial of the parties' claims. This underscores the need for a careful approach to collecting and presenting evidence in court.
- documents confirming the existence of technical specifications;
- evidence of program creation during working hours;
- acceptance certificates for a work made for hire;
- documents certifying the creation of the program as part of the performance of work duties.
The Court of Cassation upheld the findings of the lower courts, recognizing the exclusive rights to the disputed software for its author. This decision underscores the importance of copyright protection in the field of information technology and sets a precedent for future cases related to intellectual property rights.
We recommend that you read the Ruling of the Intellectual Property Court dated August 1, 2019, number C01-446/2019, concerning case No. A40-202764/2018. This document contains important legal findings and reasoning that may be useful for understanding issues related to intellectual property protection. Studying this ruling will provide a deeper understanding of the application of legal norms in the field of intellectual property rights and their protection.
An intriguing case is that of Anton Mamichev, an IT specialist from Rostov who developed a unique learning management system. It is important to note that all of this was done in his spare time, as programming was not part of his job description. Nevertheless, he decided to apply for exclusive rights to his invention. This case highlights how proactive employees can make a significant contribution to the development of educational technologies, even outside their primary responsibilities.
Anton turned out to be a challenging person—he took a step that many would consider risky and went all the way to the Constitutional Court to restore justice. However, this is only part of his story. To learn more about his journey and motivation, read our article.

The Anton Mamichev Case: How a Programmer Influenced Changes to the Civil Code
Anton Mamichev, a programmer and technology innovator, became a central figure in a case that had a significant impact on Civil Code. His approach to legal issues and the use of modern technologies in legal practice led to the need to revise certain legislative provisions.
The core of the case is that Mamichev used software to automate processes, which raised questions about the legality of such actions. The court proceedings demonstrated how digitalization and new technologies can change traditional legal norms.
This case became a landmark moment, highlighting the need to adapt legislation to the realities of the digital age. As a result, amendments were made to the Civil Code concerning the regulation of intellectual property and the use of technology in commercial activities.
Thus, Anton Mamichev not only became a pioneer in his field but also contributed to the development of the legal system, making it more relevant and compliant with modern requirements.
In practice, it does not matter much whether the employee created the program during working hours or at home, for example, sitting on the couch with the cat. The court, of course, takes such circumstances into account, but mainly considers them as additional factors. The main criterion for recognizing a work as proprietary is whether its creation is part of the author's job responsibilities.
How to formalize employee relations to avoid legal drama
In this text, we have compiled the main provisions of legislation and judicial practice to help employers properly prepare documents for the development of proprietary software. This process includes several key steps, such as defining the terms of the employment contract, formalizing work transfer certificates, and respecting intellectual property rights. It is important to keep in mind that proprietary software belongs to the employer if it was created within the scope of job responsibilities. It is also recommended to record all agreements with employees in writing to avoid potential conflicts in the future. Properly executed documents will protect the company's interests and avoid legal problems.
When drafting an employment contract, it's important to clearly define the employee's job title. It's recommended to use terms such as "programmer," "software developer," and similar expressions. This will avoid misunderstandings and ensure clarity in the responsibilities and functions associated with the position. Properly defining the job title also facilitates more effective recruitment efforts and improves SEO rankings when posting job openings.
Define the employee's functions. In the employment contract, under the "job function" or "job responsibilities," specify "creation and development of computer programs and software." If possible, provide as much detail as possible about the specific programs the employee develops. This will help avoid misunderstandings and accurately define the employee's responsibilities within the framework of his professional activities.

Create a job description if the employee's functions are specified in the employment contract are described unclearly. In the instructions, detail the employee's responsibilities and the list of programs they are developing. In the employment contract, include a clause confirming that the employee has read and agrees to the job description. This will help avoid misunderstandings and increase the transparency of labor relations.
Develop a local act if the program is being developed as part of a project. Include the program's name and the names of the developers involved in its creation in the document. It is also recommended to prepare a technical specification and a work schedule to ensure clear planning and implementation of the project.
Draft a job description for each program and each employee. The completed program must be submitted with an acceptance certificate, which confirms the creation of a work made for hire and the transfer of exclusive rights to the employer. Properly drafted job descriptions will ensure the legal protection of the company's interests and simplify the process of transferring intellectual property rights. Furthermore, this will help avoid potential disputes and misunderstandings in the future.
Agree on compensation payments by creating an additional section in the employment contract or by signing a separate agreement with the author of the utility software. The agreement should clearly state the work in question, the timeframe for its creation, and the documents on the basis of which the work was transferred to the employer. This will ensure legal clarity and protect the interests of all parties.
Court practice is an important source of legal norms and precedents that help shape the understanding of legal issues. An example from court practice can demonstrate how courts interpret and apply laws in specific situations. Consider a case in which the court considered the issue of contractual obligations. In this case, the plaintiff sued the defendant, alleging breach of contract. The court, analyzing the evidence presented and the testimony of the parties, concluded that a breach had occurred. A case study demonstrates how courts consider facts, establish the circumstances of a case, and apply relevant legal provisions to achieve a fair decision. Such examples are useful for lawyers and students, as they illustrate real-life situations and help better understand complex legal issues.
Employee: Ivan Ivanov, Programmer (name changed).
Laser-Export LLC is a leading supplier of high-quality laser equipment. We specialize in the development and sale of laser systems, providing reliable solutions for various industries. Our products include laser engravers, cutters, and markers, which are used in manufacturing, construction, and the arts. We strive for innovation and continually improve our technologies to meet modern market demands. Our team of professionals is ready to offer customized solutions tailored to the needs of each client. By choosing Laser-Export LLC, you gain a reliable partner with experience and high-quality service.
Project: Software for the Elaniq laser spectrum analyzer.
The Elaniq software is designed for efficient control of the laser spectrum analyzer. It ensures high accuracy and reliability of analysis, making it an indispensable tool in scientific research and industrial applications. The Elaniq laser spectrum analyzer is capable of determining the composition of materials using advanced technologies, allowing for reliable results in a short time. The software development takes into account modern analysis requirements and provides a user-friendly interface, as well as the ability to integrate with other systems. Optimization of analysis algorithms significantly increases data processing speed, making Elaniq one of the best solutions on the market.
The development team, which included Ivan, developed software for the laser spectrum analyzer, which was recognized as know-how and received the status of a trade secret. During the application process, Ivan identified himself not only as the author of the application but also as the copyright holder, which resulted in this information being entered into the Computer Program Registry. As a result, Laser Export filed a lawsuit challenging this information. This case raises important questions about intellectual property rights and software copyright compliance.
The court upheld the employer's rights to the disputed software. This decision underscores the importance of documents regulating the use of intellectual property in employment relationships. Employers must ensure clear terms regarding the rights to software developed by employees in the course of their work. Properly drafting such agreements will help avoid conflicts and protect the interests of both parties in the future.
During the development of the program, Ivan performed the duties specified in his employment contract. Therefore, the software created is considered a work made for hire, and the exclusive rights to it belong to the employer. This confirms the legal connection between Ivan's work activity and the results of his work, which is important to consider when discussing intellectual property rights.
To confirm that Elanik is a work made for hire, Laser-Export's lawyers presented convincing evidence.
- The program was created according to the technical specifications and work schedule issued by the company's management.
- The results of intellectual activity were registered with Laser-Export LLC in December 2017 as a trade secret (know-how) in accordance with Article 1465 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.
- The Elanik laser analyzer, of which the program of the same name is a part, was registered in the register of measuring instruments on April 23, 2018, and a certificate was issued.
Study the decision of the Nagatinsky District Court of Moscow dated December 14, 2021, Case number 2-6474/2021. This document contains important information and conclusions that may be useful for understanding case law and law enforcement in this area. By reviewing the case materials, you will gain insight into the application of law and court decisions in specific situations.
Learn more about the world of programming and coding in our Telegram channel. Subscribe to stay up-to-date with useful content and the latest news!

