Design

"The version for the visually impaired is one big drawback"

"The version for the visually impaired is one big drawback"

Try 4 top professions in design. Free ➞ In 5 days, you will get acquainted with illustration, UX/UI, web and graphic design. Add 4 great cases to your portfolio and decide on your next step.

Learn more

I am a member of the strategic group for the accessibility initiative at the IAAP and a member of the expert council of the Polytechnic Museum. I have also developed an educational course on digital accessibility and run the Telegram channel "Not an Exception". My work is aimed at raising awareness of accessibility issues and implementing best practices in this area.

Valeria and I discussed the importance of interface accessibility for people with disabilities in the global and Russian contexts. We explored the role of designers in this process and how their approach can significantly impact the quality of a company's product. Accessible interfaces are not just a trend, but a necessity that contributes to the creation of a more inclusive society. Designers, recognizing their responsibility, can implement solutions that make digital products accessible to all users, regardless of their physical abilities.

In this interview, you will learn about:

  • why you should adhere to Russian GOST when designing an interface;
  • how to find the golden mean between usability and beauty of the interface;
  • how a designer and developer should interact;
  • what mistakes designers make when designing an accessible interface.

About Inclusive Design

Inclusive design is an approach to design that considers the diversity of users, including people with different abilities, ages, cultural and social characteristics. The main goal of inclusive design is to create products and services that are accessible to everyone, regardless of individual disabilities. This approach helps improve the user experience, as it takes into account the needs of different groups. Inclusive design embraces universal solutions and principles that help ensure information accessibility, functionality, and ease of use. Inclusive design is becoming increasingly relevant in today's environment, where it's crucial to consider audience diversity and strive to create more equitable and convenient solutions for all users. Inclusion, translated from English as "inclusion," means creating interfaces that take into account all potential users. Inclusive design involves designing products and services with the diverse needs of people in mind. It is an approach that strives to ensure accessibility and usability for everyone, regardless of their individual characteristics or limitations. Inclusive design contributes to the creation of more effective and attractive solutions that can satisfy a wide range of users, which, in turn, increases audience reach and engagement. Exclusion can affect anyone, and this applies not only to people with disabilities but to everyone else as well. A striking example is the incident with soap dispensers in Facebook bathrooms. The sensors failed to detect the African-American man's hand, preventing him from receiving soap, while a white napkin and a white colleague's hand worked without issue. This case illustrates how engineering errors can lead to racial discrimination.

If you're struggling to understand the importance of diversity in technology and its impact on society, we recommend watching this video.

Inclusive design is an approach that ensures products and services are accessible and usable for everyone, regardless of their physical abilities, age, or other characteristics. People engage in inclusive design to create a more equitable and accessible society. This approach allows for the needs of diverse user groups to be considered, which in turn contributes to a better quality of life and improved interactions with products.

Inclusive design also brings significant benefits to business. It expands the audience by making products and services accessible to more people. This can lead to increased sales and increased customer loyalty. Moreover, inclusive design contributes to a positive company image by demonstrating its social responsibility and commitment to diversity.

Therefore, inclusive design not only helps people with disabilities but also benefits companies by strengthening their market position and contributing to a more inclusive and accessible world.

In this context, important aspects of fairness and equality are discussed. These concepts can serve as key arguments for many people who strive for social change. Fairness and equality are key values ​​in modern society, and respecting them helps create a more harmonious and sustainable environment for everyone.

Some companies need to expand their consumer base. The more non-standard or extreme use cases a product has, the wider the target audience becomes. For example, a ramp at the entrance to a building allows not only people in wheelchairs but also women with strollers or workers with shopping carts to enter the building without hindrance. This not only improves accessibility but also helps attract a diverse customer base, which in turn can positively impact sales and a company's reputation.

Compliance with legal requirements is an important aspect for many organizations. For some, this may be just a formality, while for others, it can lead to litigation. It is important to understand that compliance with the law not only protects the rights of companies but also builds trust among customers and partners. Proper compliance with legal regulations minimizes the risk of lawsuits and promotes business stability.

About Inclusive Design in Russia and Around the World

In Russia, there are laws that require consideration of the needs of people with disabilities. The main regulations are aimed at ensuring equal rights and opportunities for this category of citizens. Legislation includes federal laws, such as the Law on Social Protection of Disabled Persons, which establishes requirements for the accessibility of facilities and services and guarantees the right to medical and social assistance. These laws promote the creation of an inclusive environment and ensure the protection of the rights of people with disabilities, which is important for their full integration into society and active participation in the life of the country.

In 2016, Russia adopted a federal law that defined the legal framework for creating a barrier-free environment for people with disabilities. This law was the result of the ratification of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, which began in the 2010s. It requires that all public services, including transportation, healthcare, education, and other areas, be accessible to people with disabilities. Thus, the law aims to ensure equal rights and opportunities for all citizens, which contributes to the integration of people with disabilities into society and improves their quality of life.

Since 2016, Moscow has undergone significant changes in the physical environment, largely due to the development of design and inclusion. Tactile buttons and signs have appeared throughout the city, as well as escort services on public transport. Museums are actively implementing inclusive programs, which contribute to improving the accessibility of cultural sites for people with disabilities. These changes create a more comfortable and welcoming environment for all residents and visitors to the capital, emphasizing the importance of inclusive design.

Accessibility of interfaces and digital environments plays a key role in ensuring equal access for all users. When interfaces are designed with accessibility principles in mind, it allows people with disabilities, including those with visual, hearing, and mobility impairments, to use digital resources without difficulty. Inclusive design improves user experience and satisfaction, which in turn leads to a wider audience reach and improved conversions.

To achieve accessibility, it is important to consider aspects such as text contrast, keyboard navigation, the use of alternative text for images, and compliance with web accessibility standards such as WCAG. The more accessible the interface, the more people will be able to use digital services, which will positively impact the brand's reputation and its competitiveness in the market.

The implementation of accessible technologies not only complies with legal requirements but is also an ethical obligation to create an equitable digital space. Accessible interfaces contribute to the creation of a more inclusive digital environment where every user can obtain the information and services they need.

In Russia, the state of digitalization still leaves much to be desired. Banking is a leader, outpacing other industries in both digital technologies and usability. One reason for this progress is the Central Bank's initiative to create a mobile app accessibility rating. The Central Bank actively supports and develops accessibility, which is contributing to the growth of this sector. These measures lead to improved quality of services and increased convenience for users.

An example of a user-friendly adaptive design with scalability and an increase in all elements up to 200%. Image: Sber

Most websites and applications that work on accessibility do so at a high level. However, many other areas, including e-commerce, lag significantly in this area. This creates barriers for users with disabilities, making it difficult for them to access online stores and services. Improving accessibility in e-commerce is an important task that requires attention. Improving the user experience for all categories of customers not only helps expand their audience but also increases the competitiveness of businesses.

In Russia, there are standards that regulate the requirements for the accessibility of interfaces and applications. The main document in this area is GOST R 52630-2019, which defines accessibility criteria for users with disabilities. This standard includes recommendations for the development of software and web resources to ensure equal access for all users, regardless of their physical abilities. Compliance with these requirements contributes to the creation of an inclusive environment and improves the user experience. It is important to note that compliance with accessibility standards is not only a legal obligation but also demonstrates the social responsibility of companies striving to create comfortable conditions for all users.

In Russia, there was previously a GOST that regulated information accessibility standards for the visually impaired. However, the latest version of this document was released on April 1, 2020 and no longer contains specific requirements for people with visual impairments. Instead, the new standards cover all users, ensuring a universal approach to information accessibility. This change emphasizes the importance of inclusive design and the desire to create conditions for equal access to all resources.

Modern web content accessibility requirements outlined in the latest GOST take into account the needs of people with disabilities, including those who are visually impaired, blind, and those with hearing or motor impairments. For users with hearing impairments, alternative audio content formats, such as transcripts and subtitles, must be provided. For blind users, it is important to ensure the ability to interact with the interface through screen readers that read aloud the information displayed on the screen. People with limited mobility should be able to operate the computer without using a mouse, relying only on the keyboard. In all cases, the website must ensure proper functioning and responsiveness to meet the needs of all users. Content accessibility not only meets modern standards but also expands the reach of the internet, making it more inclusive.

This is a translation of the international WCAG standard, and it is the one you should follow. The WCAG (Web Content Accessibility Guidelines) standard defines recommendations to help create accessible content for people with disabilities. By following these recommendations, you ensure that your website is accessible to all users, including those using assistive technologies. This not only improves user experience but also helps increase your site's visibility in search engines, as content accessibility is one of the factors influencing SEO. It is important to consider all aspects of accessibility to create an inclusive and user-friendly environment for everyone.

The version for the visually impaired does not meet modern accessibility standards. It may not provide sufficient contrast between text and background, making it difficult to read. In addition, site navigation may be unintuitive, and interface elements are not optimized for use with screen readers. This creates barriers for visually impaired users and limits their access to information. It is important to consider these aspects when developing web content to make it more accessible for all users.

A low-vision version can be an ineffective solution, as it fails to account for the diverse needs of people with visual impairments, including the blind, colorblind, and dyslexic. This approach also assumes that the user is unable to independently choose what is most convenient for them to see, which can lead to the removal of important blocks and the creation of an illegible interface. Instead of creating a separate version of the site, it is better to implement a responsive design that takes into account font settings, contrast, and high-quality alt attributes. When these elements are implemented correctly, a separate version for the visually impaired becomes unnecessary, ensuring accessibility and convenience for all users.

Inclusive design is becoming an important topic in global practice, as it aims to create accessible and user-friendly products for all users, regardless of their abilities or limitations. In recent years, there has been a growing interest in inclusive design among both professionals and companies seeking to improve user experience.

Many leading brands are implementing inclusive approaches in their projects, recognizing that a product's accessibility can significantly impact its success and expand its audience. Furthermore, legislative initiatives in many countries require compliance with accessibility standards, which also contributes to the spread of inclusive design.

An important aspect is training professionals working in the field of design and development in the basics of an inclusive approach so that they can consider the needs of different user groups from the very beginning of the product creation process. This includes the use of adaptive technologies, compliance with accessibility standards, and product testing with people with various disabilities.

Thus, inclusive design is becoming an integral part of the modern approach to development, allowing companies not only to meet requirements but also to improve the quality of services and products for all users.

Around the world, the situation with accessibility for people with disabilities is gradually improving, albeit slightly. It is important to note that there is a direct correlation: the longer the time since the necessary laws were passed and the more actively people with disabilities advocate for their rights, the higher the level of accessibility. This underscores the importance of action and public participation in improving living conditions for people with disabilities.

The idea of ​​a magical world where empathy reigns and inclusive spaces are created is idealistic. This concept, although attractive, does not correspond to reality. In reality, creating an inclusive environment requires conscious effort and the active participation of each person. Empathy does not arise on its own; it is formed through understanding, respect, and interaction. Inclusive spaces require not only an understanding of diversity but also a willingness to work to remove barriers that may hinder the full participation of all people. Real change is possible only through joint action and the desire to build a more equitable society.

America, being one of the most progressive countries in terms of accessibility, has not always had ideal conditions for people with disabilities. The history of the struggle for accessibility here has not been easy. People, facing various obstacles, climbed the steps of the Capitol, demonstrating the serious shortcomings in infrastructure and society that limit the rights and freedoms of persons with disabilities. This action has become a symbol of the fight for equal rights and the need to create a barrier-free environment for all citizens.

In the United States, there is legislation requiring companies to ensure the inclusiveness of their equipment for educational institutions, including universities and colleges. This regulation emphasizes the importance of inclusion in American society and promotes the creation of an accessible educational environment. As a result, the educational equipment market in the US has seen a noticeable emphasis on inclusive solutions, making education more accessible for all students, regardless of their abilities.

At the everyday level, changes remain minor. During the last US presidential election, it was recorded that candidates' websites were not accessible to people with visual impairments. This is unacceptable both from a legal standpoint and in accordance with the principles of political accessibility. The need to ensure online resources are accessible to all citizens, including people with disabilities, is becoming increasingly important in modern society.

There are no perfect places in life. I do not seek to create a tragic atmosphere around this topic, but each of us faces many challenges. People working on disability issues should actively promote this topic. At the same time, it is important for people with disabilities to express and highlight their needs. This collaboration will help create a more inclusive society in which attention to the needs of everyone will become the norm.

On the Connection between Beauty and Interface Accessibility

A designer faced with top management or a client's indifference to interface accessibility should take several steps. It is important to convey to them the importance of accessible design, emphasizing that this is not only a matter of ethics but also of commercial benefit. An accessible interface allows you to attract a wider audience, including people with disabilities, which can increase the customer base and increase user loyalty.

It is recommended to prepare data and examples of successful companies that have implemented accessible design and received positive feedback from users. It is also worth offering to conduct interface testing with real users to demonstrate in practice how accessibility affects interaction with the product. If top management or the client sees the results, they may change their attitude towards this issue.

Furthermore, the designer can suggest integrating accessibility principles into the development process as a standard practice. This will help create a culture where accessibility becomes an integral part of design and development.

To do their job successfully, a designer must adhere to high standards. I believe that the issue of interface accessibility should not be brought up for discussion with management. Creating a contrasting font and ensuring a high-quality user experience (UX) are mandatory tasks that a designer should address independently, without the need for approval. Such aspects are basic design principles and do not require additional permissions. Designers must intuitively understand the importance of these elements for creating effective and user-friendly interfaces.

The problem lies not only in the need to coordinate the designer's decisions with top management or clients. Designers often don't realize how their work impacts accessibility. Many feel that achieving the desired results requires constant discussion with other professionals. It's important to understand that designers can and should actively participate in the accessibility process, using their skills and knowledge to create a more inclusive and convenient user experience.

A designer who understands the impact of their decisions on accessibility is capable of creating high-quality and user-friendly interfaces. Understanding accessibility principles helps them develop products that meet the needs of users with various disabilities. This knowledge not only improves the user experience but also increases the product's competitiveness in the marketplace. Creating accessible interfaces is a key aspect of modern design, making technology more inclusive for everyone.

To achieve harmony between aesthetics and functionality, it's important to consider several key aspects. First, it's essential to understand the target audience and their preferences. This will help adapt the design so that it is not only attractive but also easy to use. Secondly, it's worth embracing usability principles, such as ease of navigation and an intuitive interface. Thirdly, consider the color palette and fonts, which should be harmonious and easy to read. Finally, testing and collecting user feedback will help identify shortcomings and improve both the visual and functional components. As a result, a beautiful and user-friendly design will contribute to a more positive user experience.

In 2016, I gave my first lecture on inclusive design at SberTech. During the lecture, the designers asked me a question that interested them, which became the starting point for our experiment. We decided to explore how inclusive design can change the approach to creating products and services, ensuring accessibility for all users. This experience was an important step in our team's development and deepened our understanding of the importance of inclusivity in design.

One of the students was tasked with designing the interface. We worked together to improve the color palette to meet WCAG contrast requirements. As a result, the interface has become more attractive. This confirms that claims about the impossibility of combining accessibility and aesthetics are unfounded. Instead of empty talk, it is better to immediately move on to practical actions.

Image: Skillbox Media

I recently visited the Guggenheim Museum in New York. This unique multi-story building, distinguished by its spiral shape without traditional staircases, is impressive both outside and inside. It is a shining example of how talent can create spaces that are not only aesthetically pleasing but also accessible to all. It is important to note that lack of talent is no excuse for missed opportunities.

Guggenheim Museum in New York. Image: Wikimedia Commons
Guggenheim Museum in New York. Image: Wikimedia Commons

About the interaction of the designer with developers

To organize the process of creating an accessible interface, it is necessary to take into account several key aspects. First of all, it is important to conduct research of the target audience to understand the needs of users with disabilities. At this stage, it is recommended to involve accessibility specialists who can give valuable recommendations.

The next step is to develop interface prototypes taking into account accessibility principles. It is necessary to use clear fonts, contrasting colors, and provide keyboard navigation. Interface accessibility testing should be carried out at the early stages of development to identify and fix problems.

It is also important to implement standard methodologies into the development process, such as WCAG (Web Content Accessibility Guidelines), which provide the necessary recommendations for creating accessible content. Training the development team in accessibility principles and regularly auditing the interface will help maintain high standards.

Finally, it is necessary to obtain feedback from users with disabilities to improve the interface based on their experiences. Therefore, organizing the process of creating an accessible interface is a comprehensive approach that requires attention to detail and continuous improvement.

During the product development stage, it is crucial to consider the needs of users with disabilities, including those with low vision and color blindness. It is necessary to think in advance about how these users will interact with the product. Consideration should also be given to communication methods for people with hearing impairments and how the courier can organize delivery according to their needs. Talking to representatives of these groups will help identify their real needs and avoid unnecessary assumptions. Incorporating such aspects into the design helps create a more accessible and user-friendly product for everyone.

The user experience of blind users depends largely on the work of developers, but designers also play an important role. For example, to ensure a sighted user understands what they are interacting with, an icon in the interface must contain a clear image. For a blind user, a voice prompt should be added. If the interface includes a shopping cart icon, the blind user should hear: "Shopping cart button." This improves accessibility and makes the interface more intuitive for all user groups. Properly formatted and described interface elements contribute to a more inclusive digital space.

If the designer has not provided a caption for an element, the developer may attempt to create one themselves. However, the problem is that the developer may not know what metaphor or idea the designer intended to convey with the element. This can lead to miscommunication and conflict between design intent and implementation. This highlights the importance of collaboration between designers and developers to achieve a shared vision for the project and ensure its integrity.

I want to demonstrate how the same photograph of football players is perceived differently by neurotypical and colorblind people. If a developer doesn't grasp that I'm emphasizing the differences in color perception among different categories of people, they might simply label the illustration "Football Players." In that case, a blind person wouldn't be able to understand what I was trying to convey. It's important to consider the differences in information perception to ensure content is accessible to everyone.

The importance of collaboration between a designer and a developer during interface development cannot be overstated. These specialists must actively interact and exchange ideas, allowing them to effectively support each other and leverage their knowledge to achieve better results. Collaboration helps create a more intuitive and functional interface, which in turn has a positive impact on the user experience. Therefore, synergy between the designer and the developer plays a key role in the successful implementation of web design and development projects.

Testing is a key stage in interface development. Interfaces must be tested with real users who have real needs. Otherwise, using these interfaces can become difficult or even impossible. Effective testing helps identify problem areas and improve the user experience, which ultimately increases user satisfaction and contributes to the success of the product.

Communication between the designer and the developer plays a key role in the successful implementation of the project. Effective communication begins with a clear understanding of the goals and objectives that need to be solved. The designer should present their vision and concept, while the developer provides technical capabilities and constraints. Regular meetings and discussions allow both parties to stay on the same page and make adjustments to the development process.

It is important for the designer and developer to use common tools to exchange ideas and feedback. Project management and prototyping software helps visualize ideas and facilitate communication. Open discussion of deadlines, budgets, and potential issues helps build trust and improves the quality of the final product.

A key aspect is a willingness to compromise. The designer and developer must be open to change and take each other's opinions into account. This not only improves the end result but also promotes professional growth for both parties. Maintaining transparency and mutual understanding within the team is the key to successful project implementation and achieving goals.

We accidentally discovered the importance of interaction between the designer and the developer during the first course of my course. This came as a surprise to us, as the issue of communication between these two roles turned out to be quite relevant and problematic. During the discussion, we also touched on the topic of feedback in Russian culture. Unfortunately, we had to admit that we aren't taught effective feedback skills, and we lack experience delivering it.

We discovered that the interaction between the developer and designer is often insufficiently active. Ideally, this should be a productive collaboration, where the designer avoids one-sided assignments and instead engages in a discussion of the project. In this format, the developer can provide the designer with constructive feedback. For example, they might say, "Your layout has various curves. I can implement this, but it will take a lot of time and will complicate accessibility. If you change the curves to simpler ones, the development process will be significantly faster and more user-friendly." This approach not only optimizes development time but also improves the final product.

The lack of communication between the designer and the developer affects users, as the designer assumes the developer must strictly adhere to the specifications. This leads to flaws in the final product, which can negatively impact the user experience. Effective collaboration between teams is essential for creating a high-quality product that meets user expectations.

Everything I'm talking about concerns not only inclusive design but also overall accessibility. High-contrast fonts are essential for all users. Applying these basic accessibility principles helps avoid situations where users who experience discomfort end up in situations where people with disabilities cannot use the interface at all. Ensuring interface accessibility is essential for creating a convenient and comfortable space for everyone, regardless of their abilities.

About Common Design Mistakes and Growth

When developing interfaces, designers often overlook important accessibility criteria. One of the key aspects is ensuring text readability. Font size, color, and contrast are of great importance for users with visual impairments. It's also important to consider interface navigation—it should be intuitive and accessible for everyone, including people with disabilities.

Another criterion is the use of alternative text for images. This allows users with visual impairments to obtain information about the visual content. Equally important is ensuring accessibility for users with motor disabilities, which means ensuring easy interaction with interface elements such as buttons and links.

Designers should also consider the adaptability of the interface to ensure it displays correctly on different devices and screens. It is important to test interfaces with various assistive technologies to ensure their full accessibility. Applying these criteria will help create more inclusive and convenient user interfaces.

Blind users interact with web interfaces using screen readers. If the link address is not integrated into the text, the screen reader will read it out loud, for example, "Ash-ti-ti-pi...", which creates unnecessary noise on the page. This not only hinders the perception of information but also negatively impacts the user experience. When a blind person sees commands like "Continue this link" or "Click here," they don't provide clear information about what will happen after clicking. Each button and link should contain a clear description so the user understands the consequences of their action. For example, instead of a generic "Click here," it's better to use more informative phrases like "Get a list of documents for applying for a passport" or "Continue registration." This significantly improves accessibility for users with visual impairments.

Designers may find gray on a gray background appealing, but this combination creates serious readability issues. Text in these shades becomes difficult to read not only for people with visual impairments but also for those without vision impairments. Choosing the right color scheme is a key aspect in design, as it directly impacts the accessibility and readability of content.

The gray text on the Apple website is unreadable not only for the visually impaired, but also for a person without visual impairments. Screenshot: Apple website

Inclusive design is an approach that enables the creation of products and services that are accessible to all users, regardless of their abilities, age, or life circumstances. It is important for designers to understand the principles of inclusive design to create effective and usable solutions.

To learn about inclusive design, you can start by studying specialized literature and online courses that cover the basic principles and practices. It is also useful to follow the work of leading experts in the field through blogs, webinars, and conferences.

Practice is a key element in mastering inclusive design. Designers can participate in projects that focus on accessibility and also test their work with different user groups. This will help identify problems and clearly demonstrate the importance of an inclusive approach.

Thus, familiarity with inclusive design will enable designers to create higher-quality and more versatile solutions that can meet the needs of a wide audience.

Before focusing on inclusion, I worked as an engineer and was looking to change my professional field. This transition caused me anxiety, so I talked a lot with a psychologist. She noted that in the modern world, any profession becomes obsolete in about seven years, including that of a doctor. However, this is only true if you do not engage in self-education and do not strive for new knowledge.

A good designer constantly reads, learns, and strives to improve. The issue of accessibility becomes an important part of their professional development. At the initial stages, when a designer is not yet familiar with fonts and layout, their interests are focused precisely on these aspects. However, as the professional grows and develops, he begins to pay more attention to users, including people with disabilities. Understanding usability and accessibility allows you to create more inclusive and accessible solutions, which is an important step in any designer's career.

My digital accessibility course has already had three cohorts. Participants are primarily professionals with experience in design, although there are also those just starting out. The course focuses on digital accessibility principles, enabling designers to create more inclusive and user-friendly solutions.

Graphic Designer PRO Profession

You will learn how to create corporate identity elements and graphics for business. You will build a portfolio that reflects your style and demonstrates your design skills. You can start a career in a studio or as a freelancer.

Find out more