Contents:

Course with employment: "The Methodologist Profession from Beginner to Advanced"
Learn MoreTheorists continue to discuss the ideal assessment system, while practicing teachers experiment with creating a balanced approach to assessment. Their innovative ideas inspire colleagues and contribute to the development of the educational process. It is important to find optimal assessment methods that will take into account the individual characteristics of students and promote their development.
One interesting approach to assessment is labor-based grading. This method differs from traditional systems because it emphasizes the process of student work, not just the final results. Let's take a closer look at its features and advantages.
- What is work-based assessment and why was it created by racism;
- Why is work measured in minutes and how is the "labor" contract with students structured;
- In what areas is this system already used and how are curricula being changed to accommodate it;
- What are the pros and cons of this system.
What is work-based assessment?
Labor-based grading is an alternative approach to student assessment. In this system, grades are awarded not for the quality of the work, but for the amount of effort put into the process. Thus, the focus is on students' efforts, not their end results. This method can help increase student motivation and engagement, as they are recognized for their work and effort, and not just their end results. Labor-based grading can be especially useful in educational institutions seeking to create a more inclusive and supportive environment for students of varying backgrounds.
Under normal circumstances, a professor evaluates a student's essay, focusing on the quality of the text, the logic, and the structure of the presentation. In the alternative grading system, the criteria are modified: attention is paid to the length of the essay, the number of additional sources used, and the time spent on writing the work. This way, the professor focuses not only on the final result, but also on the effort put into creating the work.
How the new grading system grew out of an attempt to counter racism
One of the founders and pioneers of labor-based grading is Asao Inoue, a professor of rhetoric and composition in the College of Integrative Arts and Sciences at Arizona State University. He taught creative writing courses and found that traditional grading systems are often unfair, particularly due to the underlying racism that manifests in the educational environment. Inoue emphasizes the need to rethink assessment approaches to ensure a more equitable and inclusive environment for all students. The professor emphasizes that our perceptions of others' words and cultural characteristics can be distorted by bias and unconscious resentment. This makes evaluating the quality of others' work challenging. We must recognize that personal biases can influence our understanding and perception, so it is important to approach assessment with an open and objective mind. Understanding and respecting cultural differences allows us to more objectively analyze and evaluate the work of others. There are situations where a student whose first language is not English has difficulty reaching the level of their native English-speaking peers. This may mean they will struggle to achieve the grade they desire. Learning English to a native level takes time and effort, and not all students can achieve this task quickly. Improving language skills depends on many factors, including individual ability, motivation, and the quality of instruction. Therefore, it is important to create a supportive learning environment that helps each student develop their skills and confidence in using the language.
Asao Inoue, a Japanese national, came to these thoughts based on his personal experience. In the United States, he was often mistaken for Mexican and repeatedly faced discrimination, particularly in the form of unfriendly glances.
In his book on the grading system, Asao gives an interesting example. In high school, he received an A in French, a difficult subject for him. Meanwhile, in standard English, his native language, he received only a B, despite his excellent proficiency. This case highlights the problems with the current assessment system, which does not always adequately reflect students' knowledge and skills. Asao reflected on the reasons for his failure and concluded that the problem was not with him. He formed the belief that, despite his lack of high grades, his ability to work was of great importance. This realization led him to understand the value of effort and, subsequently, the importance of assessing students' work. In his teaching, Asao has applied various methods of assessing students' knowledge. He has experimented with approaches that help more accurately reflect the level of mastery of the material. These methods include both traditional exams and alternative forms of assessment, such as project work and group discussions. This varied approach to assessment allows for the individual characteristics of each student to be taken into account and promotes a deeper understanding of the subject matter. Asao strives to create a supportive educational environment in which students can develop their skills and abilities, as well as receive honest and objective assessment of their achievements. Community-Based Approach. In this case, students reflect and receive feedback from their peers and the instructor. At the beginning of the course, they establish assessment criteria with the instructor, can defend their project during the course, and receive a grade based on how well the process and result of their work met the specified criteria.
The professor came to the conclusion about the shortcomings of these systems. On the one hand, student participation in assessment seems positive. However, there is also a negative side: students, just like instructors, can exhibit bias. As a result, their feedback may contain unfair stereotypes and personal attitudes, which affects the objectivity of the assessment.
In the second case, the decision is made by the instructor, which may result in the inaccessibility of the highest grade for students who did not receive a high-quality school education or for those whose native language is not English. However, it is precisely these groups of students who typically put in more effort to achieve success and meet the requirements. It is important to consider that equal opportunities for all students contribute to a fair assessment of their knowledge and skills.

Asao combined various approaches, which he studied and developed a unique method of assessing students based on their efforts and achievements. This system allows for a more accurate reflection of the real contribution of each student to the educational process.
What work-based assessment looks like
The Asao system is based on three key components that determine the quality of student work. These components include academic preparation, research skills, and critical thinking. Academic preparation provides students with the necessary theoretical knowledge and practical skills. Research skills help in collecting and analyzing information, which is an important aspect of any student work. Critical thinking allows students to objectively evaluate information and form their own conclusions. Together, these three elements create the foundation for the successful completion of student assignments and the achievement of high academic results.
- The process. Here, step-by-step instructions explaining a particular work and student reflection are important for assessment.
- The work itself. Here, the amount of work is taken into account—it is calculated in time spent, the number of words (remember: written work is assessed). The duration of various activities is recorded in a work log and diary.
- The meaning of work. This includes metacognitive development, engagement, and mindfulness practices. All this is designed to help students evaluate the meaning and significance of what they do.
All of these criteria are contained in a symbolic contract that the professor concludes with their students. This document explains the conditions under which students can receive grades and obliges both students and the professor to strictly adhere to the established rules. At the beginning of the course, Asao provides students with a draft contract and leads a discussion of it, and mid-course, the terms can be revised. It is important to explain exactly how this contract is structured.
Professor Asao presented a contract template written in English to his colleagues. We will outline the main points and content of this document.
The 2023 grading template establishes a standard grade of A+, or A+ in the American system. However, according to the instructions in the 2022 book, only a B could be earned by default. The term "default" implies that the student has fulfilled all the terms of the contract and strictly followed them. Students who have not missed a single class, have conscientiously submitted all assignments, have completed additional recommendations, and have spent the most time studying can expect to receive the highest grade. Optimizing the learning process and strictly adhering to the requirements will help achieve successful results.
ASAO sets clear criteria for the final grade in advance. These rules are presented in a table, with grades listed in the left column and acceptable errors, such as missed deadlines or failure to submit assignments, in the right column. If a student meets all deadlines and successfully completes assignments, the instructor does not enter any marks. However, in the event of missed classes, unsubmitted homework, or incomplete completion, the teacher records the corresponding mark on the report card. This approach ensures transparency in assessment and encourages students to take a more responsible approach to learning.
The distribution of marks in the contract is an important aspect that affects the quality and outcome of the parties' fulfillment of their obligations. This document should clearly indicate how marks will be distributed to avoid misunderstandings and disputes in the future. Proper distribution of marks helps ensure transparency and fairness in the assessment of completed work and also builds trust between the parties to the contract. It is important that each mark meets specific criteria and is justified, which will allow for a more accurate assessment of achievements and results. A clear description of the grading system in the contract facilitates effective project management and increases the likelihood of achieving the set goals.

Students have the opportunity to receive incentives and bonuses at the end of the semester. Each student is entitled to one incentive, which can be used after consultation with the instructor. For example, if a student misses a deadline for an assignment, the instructor may accept the work and credit it as on time. This allows students to approach the learning process flexibly and accommodate individual circumstances.
The contract contains a detailed description of the instructor's reasons for choosing this learning system. The main advantages of this system are highlighted, as well as how it will benefit students.
Asao encourages students to begin by discussing the overall work process: its structural components and the sequence of steps. Each project is accompanied by clear step-by-step instructions, which indicate the approximate time required to complete each step, as well as the number of words to be written or read. Asao believes this approach helps students focus not on the end result, but on the process itself, which allows them to better understand how thoughts and ideas are formed.
While completing homework, students keep track of their work, recording the number of minutes spent, words written, their mood, and their level of engagement in the process in a work log. This helps them approach learning mindfully. After completing the task, the teacher asks students to record something they have learned or done, which helps consolidate the acquired knowledge and improve the effectiveness of learning.

The journal is a table that each student completes. The instructor emphasizes that the information in the journal will not be used against students when assigning final grades. This clarification is necessary to avoid artificially inflating scores. At the end of the semester, the instructor may reward students who have demonstrated the greatest activity (assessed by the number of minutes spent) with additional points. However, as practice shows, students do not always receive this information.
Asao's journal emphasizes the importance of meditation practice for students. He argues that mindfulness plays a key role in the learning process. Short meditations and breathing exercises help improve concentration and focus on specific tasks, which can significantly improve learning efficiency and productivity. Regularly practicing these techniques helps reduce stress levels and improve overall well-being, which also has a positive effect on academic performance.

Each week, students record their impressions of the learning process in a work diary. In this diary, they answer three key questions, which allows them to reflect more deeply on the knowledge and skills they have acquired. This not only facilitates self-reflection, but also contributes to the improvement of the learning process, as students can analyze their achievements and difficulties. Regularly keeping a work diary becomes an important tool for developing critical thinking skills and self-monitoring.
- where and in what conditions they worked;
- what internal and external aspects made the task meaningful and engaging for them;
- what they learned about their work through reflection on the task.
Students receive feedback from their peers and teachers, which allows them to discuss and defend their work. However, this feedback does not affect the final grade. It is important to note that there are a number of rules for providing feedback, set out in a document known as the "Compassion Charter". This document outlines principles of polite and ethical communication. Students are encouraged to choose their words carefully, maintain a calm dialogue, and, if they feel uncomfortable, openly share their feelings with the group. It is important to take feedback seriously and use it to improve your work in the future.

Read also:
Formative feedback in an online course: key principles
Effective formative Feedback plays a critical role in learning in online courses. To achieve the best results, it is important to consider several principles that will help make feedback more constructive and useful for students.
The first principle is specificity. Feedback should be clear and specific so that students understand exactly what they need to improve. Instead of general comments, it is better to point out specific aspects of their work that require improvement.
The second principle is timeliness. Feedback should be provided as soon as possible after completing the assignment. This will allow students to respond to comments and make changes to their work more quickly.
The third principle is developmental focus. Formative feedback should focus on how the student can improve their skills, and not simply on what was done incorrectly. It is important to encourage a desire to grow and learn.
The fourth principle is leveraging the positive. It is important not only to point out mistakes, but also to celebrate successes. This will help maintain student motivation and create a positive learning climate.
The fifth principle is student engagement. Encourage students to ask questions and discuss the feedback they receive. This will contribute to a deeper understanding of the material and improve the quality of learning.
The sixth principle is using a variety of formats. Feedback can be provided in text, audio, or video formats. This variety will help convey information better and make the learning process more engaging.
Following these principles, you can effectively provide formative feedback in online courses, which in turn will lead to improved learning quality and student satisfaction.
Quality criteria play an important role in the educational process. Despite the belief that the assessment system does not take this aspect into account, this is actually not the case. Firstly, student work is reviewed by both instructors and peers. Secondly, some instructors who have already implemented the new assessment system are developing quality criteria together with students. These criteria are discussed during the learning process, although they do not affect the final grade. This promotes a deeper understanding of the material and improves students' skills.
Why is this necessary?
Asao argues that this teaching system makes the learning process collaborative and active. When assigning reading assignments, teachers often fail to consider how students complete these assignments and how long they take. As a result, they fail to convey to students the importance and value of the learning process itself. This can negatively impact motivation and comprehension of the material. Engaging students in active interaction and discussion of what they read will help develop critical thinking and teamwork skills, which are important aspects of modern education.
The focus of assessment shifts from the product to the approach to the work. This is because the results of students' work can vary significantly depending on their life experiences, and the quality of these products is subject to different interpretations. Assessment should be based on the process of work, allowing for the identification of creativity, effort, and methods used by students in completing assignments. This approach will ensure a fairer and more objective assessment, focusing on personal development and study skills.
Who and how uses such a system
Teachers, particularly interested in alternative assessment systems, have begun to study Asao Inoue's developments and implement them in their educational institutions. This methodology is attracting attention due to its effectiveness and ability to improve the learning process. The implementation of alternative assessment approaches can contribute to a deeper understanding of the material by students and increase their motivation.
The issue of implementing methods for teaching creative writing and academic writing is becoming relevant not only for teachers of these disciplines, but also for specialists from related fields. Teachers of astronomy and history have already begun to appreciate the advantages of such a system, and proposals are emerging to adapt these approaches to the teaching of psychology and neuroscience. Using effective writing methods can significantly improve the quality of the educational process and foster deep understanding of the subject.
An interesting example of adapting an educational system originally designed for the humanities to a computer science course is demonstrated by the experience of faculty at the University of Washington's School of Engineering and Technology. Associate Professor Chris Marriott shared the results of modifying his course based on student assessment. Together with colleagues, he conducted a student survey and then presented the results publicly. This initiative demonstrates how humanities approaches can be integrated into engineering disciplines, improving the quality of education and student engagement.

Teachers have made changes to the assessment system. Now, each assignment is classified into three categories: "complete" – if the student completed the task correctly and submitted it on time; "incomplete" – if the assignment was submitted late or contained significant errors that were not corrected; "ignored" – if the student did not submit the assignment at all. All types of assignments are recorded in a report prepared using a standard template, which allows for effective tracking of student progress.
The course was significantly revised to accommodate the new assessment system. This requirement became the basis for changes to the structure and content of the course, allowing for more effective assessment of students' knowledge and skills. Now the course better aligns with modern educational standards and ensures a fairer and more transparent assessment of student performance.
- Chris Marriott divided the course into several modules with weekly homework assignments. Since each assignment should be given the same weight depending on the effort spent on it, the volume of these assignments should also be similar – which is why they were made weekly. Assignments were based on a problem-based approach.
- Instead of the usual exams, which Chris administered several times a semester, he began using tests and quizzes (they also became part of the homework). For students, this was simply a way to review the material and independently assess their knowledge.
- Chris also added what he called "meta-labor." For example, he suggested that students keep a work log (the same table where they record the time spent studying in minutes and other data). At the end of the week, students were asked to look at it and reflect on their learning process, and at the same time recall the material covered. This could be done in a free form. This, incidentally, allows the teacher to receive quite honest feedback on their own work and the content of the course.
- The teacher also began to organize students into small groups (randomly). Together, they can work on a small study or develop a product—and thus earn additional credit.
The new grading system has demonstrated positive results, as reported by Chris Marriott and his colleagues. According to their observations, students have become more trusting of their teachers, a sentiment shared by the students themselves. Teachers, in turn, receive higher-quality feedback, which contributes to an improvement in the educational process. Student engagement in learning has increased significantly compared to the traditional grading approach. Students now focus less on earning grades and more on the learning process. Through the use of reflection and tests, they develop meta-skills, which contributes to better retention of information and a deeper understanding of the material being studied. This new grading system not only improves the quality of education but also forms deeper knowledge in students.
The implementation of the new educational system has brought additional benefits, such as reduced levels of anxiety among students and a decrease in cases of academic dishonesty. Chris Marriott notes that this system reduces the need for cheating because students are encouraged to discuss their homework with each other. This contributes to a more open and supportive learning environment, which has a positive impact on student achievement and emotional well-being.
However, some disadvantages were also identified. They can be summarized in one aspect - this is a labor-intensive system for teachers, which is a characteristic feature of most alternative assessment methods. The reasons for this include the significant time required for assessment and analysis of results, as well as the difficulty of introducing new approaches into the educational process.
- Implementing and adapting a course to a work-based assessment system takes a significant amount of time.
- Teachers themselves must also adapt if they choose work-based assessment. They are forced to rethink many of their usual practices and ideas about education.
- The assessment process itself with this approach also takes more time than with a standard system. For example, Chris Marriott noted that a significant portion of his teaching time is spent reading students' reflective notes. However, he sees value in this for his teaching practice.
Not all instructors who have implemented performance-based grading are satisfied with the results. For example, a professor at a California university used the system in an online creative writing course and noticed that students demonstrated less progress in their work compared to previous courses. However, it is worth noting that these results may be due to the unique conditions of her class. Despite this, the professor emphasized that students became more open and less focused on grades, which may indicate a positive impact of the new system on their approach to learning.
Most instructors discussing the implementation of the new system note positive changes. However, this does not eliminate the possibility of questions and concerns. Dr. Breana Bayraktar raises important issues regarding adapting the system for students who lack intrinsic motivation. How can work tracking support students in their learning process? How important is it to consider the quality of work within this system? These questions require careful consideration to ensure the effectiveness of this new approach to the educational process.
Currently, practicing teachers continue to search for answers to the question of the effectiveness of the new assessment system, as comprehensive research in this area is still lacking. However, Asao Inoue asserts that this system is superior to the traditional one because it encourages students to "take risks and engage fully in the process, explore new things, and discover the unknown, rather than simply demonstrating existing knowledge." Asao believes that it is precisely this capacity for exploration and discovery that is the true value of the educational process.
Learn more about the world of education on our Telegram channel. Subscribe to stay up-to-date with current news, useful resources, and interesting facts.
Be sure to check out these additional materials:
- Simple Formative Assessment Techniques for Teachers
- Why Modern Educators Are Calling for Abandoning Grades
- An Unusual Practice: "The Sweet Road" and Bubbles for Intrinsic, Not Extrinsic, Motivation

