Contents:
- Is it true that students' extracurricular activities have a positive impact on their academic performance?
- How can a student's interest in some extracurricular activity be related to his academic success?
- Is there such a connection in Russia? What did your research show?
- The difference between the two samples is that HSE pays close attention to extracurricular activities?
- At the same time, there have always been and still are activists in all Russian universities. So, it turns out that student activists aren't enough?
- How can extracurricular activities be made more useful?

Course with employment: "The profession of a Methodologist from scratch to PRO"
Find out moreIrina Scheglova, an employee of the Institute of Education of the Higher School of Economics, conducted a study on the relationship between the extracurricular involvement of Russian students and their educational outcomes. Specifically, she studied how extracurricular activities influence the development of critical thinking, teamwork skills, and on-time completion of studies. We discussed the importance of extracurricular activities in higher education and ways to effectively harness this potential in Russia. Extracurricular involvement of students plays a key role in the development of their competencies and successful adaptation in the labor market, which emphasizes the need to integrate such activities into the educational process.

Junior Research Fellow, Center for Sociology of Higher Education, Institute of Education, Higher School of Economics (HSE). In his work, he studies the sociological aspects of higher education, analyzing trends, problems, and prospects for the development of the educational system. His specialization includes studying the interaction between educational institutions and society, as well as the influence of social factors on the quality and accessibility of higher education.
The study of student engagement was initiated at the recommendation of his supervisor, Igor Chirikov, as part of one of the Center's core areas—"Student Experience." Irina successfully defended her dissertation for a PhD in Educational Sciences, based on a collection of articles. This paper aims to provide an in-depth study of the factors influencing student engagement in the learning process, a topic of current interest in educational research.
Is it true that students' extracurricular activities have a positive impact on their academic performance?
We avoid using the term "impact" because impact can only be confirmed experimentally. Correlational studies, such as this one, demonstrate only the existence of a relationship between different phenomena.
There are numerous studies demonstrating a positive relationship between students' extracurricular activities and their educational outcomes, such as communication skills, teamwork, critical thinking, and leadership skills. However, such studies are rare in Russia. It is important to recognize that active participation in extracurricular activities can significantly improve students' chances of successful employment. Integrating extracurricular activities into the educational process promotes the development of skills necessary for the modern labor market, making graduates more competitive.
Most research on extracurricular activities is conducted in the United States. In the American educational system, extracurricular activities are considered an essential element of learning. They contribute to the development of key skills such as leadership, critical thinking, and teamwork. In this context, extracurricular activities refer to project work, including social, volunteer, and research projects, as well as participation in student organizations. These activities are not part of the formal educational plan and are not assessed in points or credits. Extracurricular activities play a key role in developing a well-rounded student and contribute to their professional and personal growth.
There are currently no similar studies in Russia, and mine can be considered the first in this area. I am confident that more such studies will follow. Discussion of this topic will gain popularity, as interest in what students do outside of class is growing at a high level, including at the ministry. This demonstrates the need to study students' extracurricular activities and their impact on their development.
How can a student's interest in a particular extracurricular activity be related to their academic success?
Extracurricular activities are an important tool for deepening the knowledge gained during classes. By working together on social, scientific, or applied projects, students can not only master theoretical material but also solve practical problems that are close to real-life conditions. This creates a unique opportunity to gain experience in a chosen professional field, which can have a positive impact on career development and skill development. Extracurricular activities foster critical thinking, teamwork, and leadership skills, making learning more effective and multifaceted. This opens up opportunities to strengthen social capital through networking within the student body, academia, and business. Students can find inspiring role models, receive academic support, and receive recommendations that contribute to successful employment. Expanding such connections plays a significant role in professional development and career advancement. Some argue that the relationship between student involvement in extracurricular activities and their academic outcomes may be indirect. As my thesis reviewer, Alexander Sidorkin, noted, student participation in various associations and communities contributes to improving their overall well-being and mental health. In turn, this has a positive impact on their academic achievement. It's important to understand that developing social skills and support from the university environment play a key role in students' academic success.
Of course, I can help with text revision. Please provide the text you wish to change.
Is there such a connection in Russia? What did your study show?
The results of my study were mixed. A positive connection was found in the sample of the Higher School of Economics, where extracurricular activities had been actively developing for several years. Significant human and financial resources were invested in this area, and students had the opportunity to receive scholarships for their extracurricular activities. However, when analyzing data from a larger sample of 36 Russian universities, such a connection was not observed. This indicates the need for further study of the impact of extracurricular activities on students in different settings and contexts.
When planning my study, I assumed that it would be boring and with predictable results. I expected that, as in foreign studies on this topic, I would find a positive connection between engagement and educational outcomes. However, after conducting the analysis on a large sample, I was surprised that such a connection was not established. This finding highlights the importance of a critical approach to research data and the need for further study of the factors that influence educational achievement.

Is the difference between the two samples precisely in the fact that HSE pays close attention to extracurricular activities?
The Higher School of Economics offers its students a wide range of opportunities to participate in extracurricular activities. The university has over one hundred student organizations, and the team that organizes events consists of experienced specialists. Students can not only join existing organizations but also independently initiate projects, present their ideas, and participate in numerous events held at the university. The main thing is desire and initiative, which open the door to the implementation of their own ideas.
At other universities, students often do not participate in extracurricular activities. The results of interviews conducted as part of the SUPER-test project show that many do not see this as a need. Extracurricular activities, as a rule, take up time that students could spend on homework and preparing for classes. Moreover, participation in such activities is not officially recognized, leaving students confused about their true usefulness.
In interviews, students noted that they had joined a student activist group in their first year, but after several visits, they could not understand its goals and left. It is important to develop a program that will help students understand the significance of their participation in extracurricular projects and clearly articulate the tasks they can accomplish. This will increase student engagement and interest in active university life.
At the same time, all Russian universities have always had and still have activists. Does this mean student activists are not enough?
Activists do indeed exist in educational institutions, but their numbers remain small, and their activities are often nominal. Research, including mine, shows that only 30% of students participate in extracurricular activities during their studies, and their number decreases every year. Many students admitted in interviews that they join student organizations or unions merely as a formality, just in case, without any genuine interest in active participation. This indicates a low level of student engagement in university life and highlights the need to increase interest in active participation in student life.
Student activity is often associated with creative and recreational activities, as well as amateur performances. While this is important, not all students aspire to continue dancing or other similar hobbies in the future. In our research, only a small group of participants mentioned engaging in analytical work as part of social or other projects. The question remains: how can students develop critical thinking skills in an environment where the emphasis is on entertainment and creativity?
Estimating the optimal amount of extracurricular activities at universities is quite difficult. In surveys conducted as part of the "Monitoring the Economy and Economics of Education," students note low engagement in project-based activities. At the same time, university administrators claim that almost all students actively participate in such projects. However, in practice, this is often not the case. For example, at one online event, a professor remarked, "Oh, what projects? Students don't know how to do anything." This opinion is widespread in the academic community, where there is a belief that students lack interesting ideas. English: It is important to reconsider the approach to extracurricular activities and create conditions for the active involvement of students in project work, which will help develop their skills and creativity.
How to make extracurricular activities more useful?
I propose making the following changes:
- redistributing the students' academic workload and expanding the educational formats that involve students' extracurricular work: for example, within the framework of student organizations or project work;
- creating accessible platforms and open formats for extracurricular activities at the university;
- consider creating a department that will coordinate students' extracurricular activities;
- expand the practice of taking extracurricular achievements into account in special scholarships and other incentives from the university.
All changes require thorough testing and research, but attention to extracurricular activities can be very beneficial. The importance of developing universal skills in students is currently being actively discussed. Employer surveys show that many graduates struggle with critical thinking and teamwork. However, the question of how to integrate the development of these skills into the educational process remains relevant. Research confirms that structured and organized extracurricular activities contribute to the development of key skills in students, such as leadership, communication, and collaboration. The introduction of such activities into the educational program can significantly improve the level of graduates' preparation for the requirements of the modern labor market.

