Education

How eliminating grades affects student performance

How eliminating grades affects student performance

Learn: The Profession of a Methodologist from Scratch to PRO

Find out more

Recent school graduates who have entered a university need to adapt to a new team and academic environment, which is not always easy. One of the main stress factors is the pressure to achieve high grades during exam sessions, as this can impact scholarships, opportunities for interesting internships, or continued study in a free master's program. Successful socialization and university studies require not only knowledge but also the ability to effectively manage time and stress.

Recent studies have confirmed that fear of grades significantly increases stress and anxiety levels in students. Thoughts about grades can reduce intrinsic motivation, shifting attention from the learning process to the pursuit of results. This creates unhealthy competition among students and promotes superficial memorization of information instead of a deep understanding of the material. Understanding these factors can help develop methods aimed at improving the educational process and supporting students' psychological well-being.

There are non-graded alternatives to traditional point systems, the most well-known of which are the credit system, which assigns only pass or fail grades and provides feedback without the use of grades. Research shows that eliminating grades can reduce stress in students and improve their overall psychological well-being, which in turn has a positive impact on academic motivation. However, the impact of gradeless approaches on academic performance remains a subject of debate. Research results in this area are often contradictory, requiring further analysis and study. Researchers at Copenhagen Business School in Denmark conducted a study among students to determine the impact of eliminating the grade system on stress levels and academic performance. The study analyzed students' opinions on the new grading system. The results showed that eliminating the grade system did not reduce stress as expected. However, the system does have its advantages, which were noted by the participants. The study demonstrated that alternative assessment methods can promote deeper understanding and increase student motivation, making them relevant for discussion in educational circles.

Context of the study

In Denmark, university admission is largely determined by an applicant's high school grade point average. This means that while at school, potential students face high academic pressure to achieve high grades. This pressure continues after entering higher education, creating additional stress factors for students. High grades at school become an important criterion that influences future career and employment opportunities.

In order to reduce stress among first-year students and create a more comfortable learning environment, members of the student council at Copenhagen Business School proposed introducing a grade-free system in the first year of the Bachelor's program in Business and Psychology. In response, in 2018, the program's leadership adopted a new system based on credits and constructive feedback from faculty and students. Faculty underwent specialized training in providing feedback and adapted their courses to the new requirements. However, the planned learning outcomes remained unchanged, allowing students to focus on mastering the material rather than focusing on grades.

Still: film "Exam" / Hazeldine Films / Bedlam Productions

Teachers provided students with feedback in two formats. The first type was formative feedback, which was used to analyze assignment completion throughout the course. This feedback allowed first-year students to track their individual progress, identifying strengths and areas for improvement. The second type, summative feedback, assessed the extent to which students' achievements aligned with established learning goals. This approach to feedback fosters a deeper understanding of their own success and guides them toward improving their learning outcomes.

A study conducted by researchers at Copenhagen Business School aimed to evaluate the impact of new educational technologies on students' long-term learning outcomes. The main goal of the study was to find out whether these innovations could negatively impact the quality of education and student performance in the future.

Read also:

There are various alternatives to traditional assessments that can more accurately reflect the level of knowledge and skills of students. One popular approach is to use a portfolio, in which students compile their work to demonstrate their progress and achievements. Another option is formative assessment, which emphasizes the learning process rather than the end result. Self- and peer-review assessments are also worth considering, allowing students to recognize their strengths and weaknesses. Alternative assessment methods, such as project-based activities and oral presentations, help develop critical thinking and creativity. These approaches can increase student motivation and foster a deeper understanding of the material.

What data did the researchers collect?

The study was conducted on two cohorts of students who entered the Business and Psychology program in 2018 and 2019, following the abandonment of the traditional points system for first-year students. These students constituted the experimental group. The analysis also included data from a control group consisting of students who began their studies in 2017, when the old grading system was in effect.

Data collection for each group was conducted in several stages. First, a preliminary analysis was conducted to identify key parameters and study objectives. Data was then systematically collected using various methods, including surveys, interviews, and analysis of existing materials. The information was then processed and verified for reliability, enabling the identification of key trends and patterns. The final stage was a summary of the results, which facilitated the formation of conclusions and recommendations for further research. This approach ensures high accuracy and reliability of the collected data, which is crucial for successful analysis and informed decision-making.

  • At the end of their first academic year, participants completed a survey on well-being (measured perceived stress, loneliness, and social integration), motivation to study, and learning strategies (the researchers were interested in whether students used superficial strategies, such as rote memorization, or deep ones, that is, they tried to comprehend the material).
  • After the third semester, students from the experimental group (those admitted in 2018 and 2019) took exams for scores for the first time in their entire studies at the university. The researchers recorded these grades.
  • Similarly, the study authors collected data on grades at the end of the fourth semester.
  • At the end of the course (after the sixth semester), the researchers collected information on the grades received by students for defending their theses.

Academic performance was assessed using three key indicators: average grades for the third and fourth semesters, as well as the results of the thesis defense. These criteria allow for an objective assessment of students' knowledge and skills, which is important for their further education and professional activities.

How did eliminating grades impact students?

Analysis of the collected data revealed no significant differences in well-being between students in the control and experimental groups. This observation contradicts the results of other studies that indicate a reduction in stress levels when eliminating grades. The researchers suggest that first-year students accustomed to the grade-based system in school may experience stress due to the absence of their familiar grading system. This highlights the importance of understanding the psychological factors that influence students’ adaptation to new learning conditions.

Photo: University of North Carolina Asheville

The lack of a clear benchmark that the scoring system provides, makes it difficult for students to evaluate their academic performance. Many students associate their identity with the grades they receive. The researchers emphasize that when introducing a gradeless system, special attention must be paid to its design and to providing support for students as they adapt to the new environment. This will help students better navigate their educational journey and increase their motivation to learn.

First-year students who did not receive grades were less likely to use superficial learning strategies and more likely to use deep approaches compared to their peers in the control group. This means that they are more likely to comprehend new information rather than simply memorize it. This approach in itself is a significant advantage. Furthermore, as the researchers hypothesized, the absence of grades had a positive effect on academic motivation, both intrinsic and extrinsic. This confirms the importance of creating an educational environment that promotes a deeper understanding of the material and increases student engagement in the learning process.

In conclusion, the authors of the study compared the average exam scores of the experimental and control groups and found no significant differences. Similarly, there were no differences in the average grades for theses. Thus, students who did not receive grades during their first year demonstrated the same results in subsequent stages of study as students who did receive grades. There are differences in student performance that arise based on their previous academic achievements. The higher the average grade on their high school diploma, the more likely it is that eliminating grades will negatively impact academic performance. The researchers emphasize the need for a thorough analysis of the impact of the gradeless system on different groups of students. This may be due to motivational patterns. Students accustomed to studying solely for good grades had an internalized motivation, which may lead to its loss under the gradeless system. In contrast, those who study out of intrinsic interest or strive for meaningful goals, such as obtaining a gainful profession, are less dependent on grades and maintain their motivation. Thus, it is important to consider individual motivational factors to understand the impact of the zero-grade approach on students' academic performance.

Read also:

Academic motivation: scientific theories and their explanations

Academic motivation plays a key role in the educational process. It determines how actively and purposefully students approach learning. There are many scientific theories that explain the mechanisms behind academic motivation and its impact on academic achievement.

One of the most well-known theories is self-determination theory, proposed by Edward Deci and Richard Ryan. According to this theory, motivation is divided into two main categories: intrinsic and extrinsic. Intrinsic motivation is associated with personal interest and satisfaction in the learning process, while extrinsic motivation depends on external factors such as grades or praise.

Another important theory is expectancy-value theory, developed by John Weiner. It posits that students' motivation depends on their expectations of success and the value they place on learning activities. The higher the expectations and the greater the significance of the learning outcome for the student, the higher their motivation.

Also worth mentioning is the achievement theory proposed by James Atkinson. This theory emphasizes the human desire to succeed and avoid failure. Students who are highly motivated to achieve demonstrate greater persistence and diligence in the learning process.

Studying academic motivation and its theoretical underpinnings helps educators develop effective strategies for increasing student interest in learning. Understanding the mechanisms of motivation allows us to create more productive learning conditions, which leads to better academic results.

The authors highlight another important area for future research: the impact of gradeless learning on the development of universal competencies, including soft skills. In particular, a previous study showed that eliminating grades promotes greater student collaboration. This may be due to the fact that competition in a grade-free environment is reduced, which, in turn, creates a more comfortable environment for collaboration and knowledge sharing.

Researchers from the Copenhagen Business School emphasize the importance of teacher training in the context of the implementation of a grade-free system. This system is often implemented in conjunction with other innovations aimed at student-centeredness, interactivity, and an emphasis on dialogic teaching methods instead of traditional lectures. Without adequate professional development courses and organizational support from educational institution leadership, teachers find it difficult to adapt to new teaching methods. Ensuring high-quality teacher training is a key factor in the successful implementation of innovative educational approaches.

Learn more about education by subscribing to our Telegram channel. We regularly publish interesting materials, news, and useful tips to help you stay up-to-date on educational trends. Join our community and expand your knowledge.

Explore additional resources:

  • Why modern educators are calling for the abandonment of grading
  • Simple formative assessment techniques for teachers
  • The old saying: "Bad grades are harmful in every way." Tsiolkovsky and School Grades
  • Bookshelf: "Abandoning Grades," edited by Susan Bloom

The Profession of Methodologist from Scratch to PRO

You will improve your skills in developing curricula for online and offline courses. Master modern teaching practices, structure your experience, and become a more sought-after specialist.

Find out more