Content:

Course with employment: "The profession of a Methodologist from scratch to PRO"
Find out moreA big man suppresses a little one without having a legal basis for this. The teacher realizes that the student is experiencing suffering, blushing and sweating in his presence. He himself is bored and hard, but he follows the established rule, according to which he must accustom the student to say the same thing. This not only creates tension but also hinders the natural learning process. It is important to remember that teaching practice should be based on mutual understanding and respect, not on power and coercion. Effective learning is only possible in an atmosphere of support and trust, where every student feels valued and capable of development.
Teaching children to speak publicly raises many questions. Why do it? Some argue that this process is necessary to assess the student's level of knowledge. However, in my opinion, a teacher can determine the degree of assimilation of the material without forcing the student to read aloud in public. An hour-long period will not provide an objective picture of knowledge, since a real teacher can assess a student's knowledge without formal exams and answering questions.
The method of individual questioning that we observe today is a relic of old traditions. In the past, teachers required students to memorize material, since this was the only way to test their knowledge. Over time, it became clear that simply reproducing a text does not always mean understanding. Despite this, the practice of individual questioning remains, and teachers continue to solicit responses at their own discretion.
It is important to seek more effective assessment methods that will help develop critical thinking and a deep understanding of the subject matter. Given modern approaches to teaching, it is worth focusing on developing self-expression and discussion skills, which can be more beneficial than traditional memorization.
Exams that require answering questions represent a new and often useless subject, requiring significant effort and specialized skills. This subject could be called preparation for exams or lessons. Grammar school students study not only history and mathematics but also, importantly, the art of answering exam questions. I do not consider this art useful for the educational process. As a teacher, I assess my students' knowledge as accurately as I do my own, even if neither the student nor I submit lesson reports. If someone wants to objectively assess knowledge, let them live among us, study the results and the application of our knowledge in life. There are no other methods of assessment, and all attempts to introduce exams are nothing but a deception and an obstacle to quality education. In the educational process, the only independent judges are teachers, and only the students themselves can control them.
Leo Tolstoy's article "The Yasnaya Polyana School for November and December," published in the Yasnaya Polyana magazine in 1861, examines important aspects of the educational process at the Yasnaya Polyana School. The author focuses on teaching methods, the interaction between students and teachers, as well as the cultural and moral development of students. Tolstoy emphasizes the importance of an individual approach to each child, their needs and interests. The article also focuses on the role of family and society in the educational process. This text provides valuable historical evidence reflecting Tolstoy's views on education and its influence on personality development.
Exams, whether transfer or final, are invariably accompanied by a number of problems. Their administration includes elements that can be described as senseless pressure on students, randomness, and the influence of the personal preferences of teachers. Unfortunately, this leads to arbitrary decisions and potential cheating by students. It is important to consider how these factors influence the assessment system and what measures can be taken to improve the situation. University exams are the subject of much debate regarding their effectiveness in assessing student knowledge. Based on personal experience and the opinions of many involved in the educational process, it can be argued that exams are not a reliable indicator of knowledge. Instead, they often become a platform for arbitrary decisions by teachers and attempts at cheating by students. It is necessary to seek alternative assessment methods that more accurately reflect student knowledge and skills and facilitate their development.
There have been three exams in my life that left a significant mark. I failed the first exam due to a conflict with a professor of Russian history, who, despite the fact that I never missed lectures and knew the subject well, did not advance me to the second year. I also received a low grade in German from the same professor, even though my knowledge of the language was significantly higher than that of most students. The following year, the situation changed: I passed the Russian history exam with an A. That time, a friend and I argued about who had the better memory, and we each memorized one question. Luckily, I got the very question I had prepared for – a biography of Mazepa. This was in 1946.
In 1948, I took the candidate's exam at St. Petersburg University, and, to my surprise, I began preparing just a week before the exam. I didn't sleep at all, but by focusing on civil and criminal law, I was able to get satisfactory grades, even though I only had a week's preparation for each subject.
Now, in 1962, I see many students finishing the course, starting their preparation just a week before the exam. I also know of fourth-year students who forged exam papers. One professor gave a student a C instead of an A simply because he allowed himself to smile. The professor remarked, "We can smile, but you can't," and gave him a low grade. Such cases demonstrate how much attitudes toward exams and assessment have changed.
In his article "Upbringing and Education" by Leo Tolstoy, published in the journal Yasnaya Polyana in 1862, he examines key aspects of the upbringing and education process. Tolstoy emphasizes the importance of the harmonious development of the individual, focusing on the need to cultivate moral qualities in children. He emphasizes the importance of freedom of choice, allowing children to make their own decisions and develop critical thinking. The article also discusses teaching methods that should focus not only on imparting knowledge but also on developing the student's inner world. Tolstoy calls for an individualized approach to education, taking into account the unique abilities and needs of each child. His ideas remain relevant today, inspiring educators to create more humane and effective educational systems.
Context
Lev Nikolayevich Tolstoy is an outstanding classic of Russian literature and a profound thinker of his time. His interest in various aspects of public life knew no bounds. One of the key themes of his reflections was pedagogy and the importance of education for the individual and society as a whole. Tolstoy was critical of the educational systems existing in his time, both school and university. He shared his views in journalistic articles, which provoked active discussions and debates. Tolstoy emphasized the need to reform education to achieve true development and education of an individual.
As a student, Leo Tolstoy had only an indirect relationship with higher education, but his experience in school education was significant both as a teacher and as the founder of his own school. In 1859, at the age of 31, Tolstoy founded a school for peasant children in Yasnaya Polyana, where he applied innovative approaches to teaching and upbringing. These methods were based on the principles of freedom, meaning the absence of coercion and strict discipline. This approach to education was extremely unusual for the time and became an important step in the development of pedagogy.
The school was short-lived, as the pedagogical methods used there provoked discontent among the authorities. After the institution's closure in 1862, Leo Tolstoy began publishing the pedagogical journal "Yasnaya Polyana," in which he shared his views on education and criticized existing systems. This journal published articles and excerpts illustrating his approaches and ideas in the field of pedagogy.
The journal lasted even less than the school, publishing only 12 issues. Its closure was the result of significant discontent on the part of the authorities.
Revised text:
Study additional materials:
- The past: how they studied and passed exams at the Smolny Institute
- How those entering universities in Tsarist Russia passed exams
- Special project: 5 questions about the Unified State Exam for its twentieth anniversary

