Contents:

Training program with a guarantee of employment: "Methodologist: from the basics to the professional"
Find out moreA meeting of the working group dedicated to the development of EdTech in Russia was held on October 28. This group was formed last year with the support of the Digital Economy Autonomous Non-Profit Organization (ANO) and the Association for Innovation in Education (RACI). The main topic of discussion was regulating the implementation of artificial intelligence in the educational process. Participants considered how to develop rules regarding the use of technologies that have been transforming educational practices for several years, yet remain legally unregulated. During the event, key risks associated with the integration of AI were identified, international examples of regulatory approaches were analyzed, and possible solutions to these issues in the Russian context were proposed.
The Need to Regulate the Use of Artificial Intelligence
Valentina Kurenkova, GR Director at Netology and Head of GR at RACIO, emphasized that artificial intelligence is a unique phenomenon in the educational system, the consequences of which have not yet been fully understood. She believes that AI truly has the potential to become the revolutionary technology that has long been hoped for in the education sector. However, at this stage, its integration is happening haphazardly, which creates risks for both educational institutions and the EdTech sector.
Luaza Bayramkulova, Chief Analyst in the field of “Personnel for the Digital Economy” at the ANO “Digital Economy”, gave a report in which she described in detail the threats arising from the unorganized implementation of artificial intelligence.
According to all of the above, the main risk for students is a radical change in their thinking, as well as the potentially adverse impact of the regular use of artificial intelligence on their cognitive abilities.
“Having highlighted three key cognitive functions - information processing, solving mental problems, and analyzing and synthesizing data, we can see that under the influence of artificial intelligence they are transformed into the processes of verification, fact checking, integrating the results provided by AI, refining answers and assessing their relevance, or adapting the style depending on specific tasks,” explained Luaza.
As a result of all this, in the future, people may The motivation to independently solve mental problems will decrease, leading to dependence on technology and a decline in critical thinking. The situation for teachers appears more promising—artificial intelligence can significantly simplify their workflows, freeing them from administrative duties and acting as AI mentors or tutors. At the same time, the evolution of AI will create new professional roles for teachers. First and foremost, this concerns the shift in their function from "knowledge translator" to mentor, helping students socialize and develop key skills. Furthermore, teachers can become AI facilitators, teaching students how to effectively use technology. An important role for teachers may also be to act as commissioners of educational solutions that will be implemented in the educational process. However, as Vera Loktionova, Head of Government Relations at Umskul and a member of the RATsIO Board, noted, there is still concern among teachers that artificial intelligence could eventually replace them in the workplace.
The main conclusion from Luaza Bayramkulova's report on teachers is that it is important to organize their methodological training for the effective use of this new technology.

"The key aspect of the education strategy should remain the focus on the teacher, not technology," noted Luaza Bayramkulova. "Currently, there is a tendency to focus on technical equipment and tools, but ultimately, it is important to focus on the role of the teacher."
Beyond the potential negative impact on students' cognitive development, there are ethical risks associated with privacy breaches, hidden advertising and manipulation, and digital discrimination. Increasing social inequality may manifest itself in the emergence of "privileged" solutions with superior technical characteristics, accessible only to certain segments of society.
In short, if the current situation remains unaddressed, the implementation of artificial intelligence in education will be chaotic, leading to numerous complications. Regulators should strive to mitigate these risks. English: It is expected that the following measures may be useful in this process:
- creating a state strategy and legislative framework for the use of artificial intelligence in the educational sphere, including, in particular, the development of a national code of ethics concerning the use of AI in this area;
- Organizing methodological assistance and extensive training for teachers in the use of artificial intelligence, as well as assistance in their integration with this technology, implies the creation of general guidelines and recommendations for the use of AI in the educational process with students.
Luaza Bayramkulova believes that, depending on how the aforementioned risks associated with the use of artificial intelligence in the educational sphere are eliminated, three key scenarios for the further development of the situation can be identified:
- The negative aspect is that the lack of control can increase risks, including the likelihood of deterioration of students' mental abilities, which can ultimately lead to deterioration of the entire educational system.
- With this approach, a division into strong and weak educational institutions is likely to occur. More advanced organizations will implement artificial intelligence, which will allow them to significantly improve their performance, while less successful institutions will find themselves at an even greater disadvantage.
- An optimistic view of the future suggests that artificial intelligence will become an ally of humans, offering individualized approaches and freeing teachers from monotonous tasks, thereby facilitating more personalized learning. To realize this prospect, it is necessary to begin work now on the creation of regulatory acts in this area, teacher training and, of course, the development of the appropriate infrastructure.
The state of international policy in the field of artificial intelligence regulation
Vera Loktionova, who heads the department of interaction with government agencies at Umskul and is a member of the board of RATsIO, shared the experience of other countries in regulating the use of artificial intelligence in the education system. Her analytical study showed that approaches to regulating AI integration vary around the world.

The United States currently lacks centralized regulation of artificial intelligence. However, in April 2025, Donald Trump signed an executive order that laid the foundation for the formation of a federal task force focused on integrating artificial intelligence into educational institutions. This order also called for the development of programs to improve AI literacy among young people. By that time, 28 states had already submitted their recommendations for integrating AI into educational institutions, most of which were advisory in nature. Meanwhile, states such as California, Connecticut, and Texas have passed bills aimed at creating oversight boards and regulatory sandboxes for testing AI-based tools.
China has adopted a centralized approach: the Ministry of Education has developed strategic guidelines for integrating artificial intelligence into the national curriculum, mandating that children be taught the basics of AI starting in elementary school. The application of generative AI to students' learning is also clearly defined—its use is permitted solely for the preparation of diagnostic reports and provision of support, but not to replace their own work.
India plans to make AI mandatory in educational institutions starting in 2026 and to include it in all undergraduate curricula.
Japan has also published guidelines for the implementation of AI in educational institutions, with the goal of becoming "the most AI-friendly country on the planet." The focus is on developing critical thinking skills in AI, understanding its potential and limitations, and addressing the ethical and social implications of technology use.
In 2024, the European Union approved the AI Act, a set of rules designed to regulate the field of artificial intelligence. All AI systems were classified into four risk levels, with educational technologies falling into the high-risk category. This implies the introduction of strict requirements for transparency, auditing, and human oversight. Specifically, strict conditions are established for AI systems responsible for automated assessments, admissions to educational institutions, behavioral monitoring, and language proficiency. The use of AI to analyze students' emotions using biometric data is prohibited.
In August 2025, the Russian Ministry of Education and Science noted that regulations governing the use of artificial intelligence technologies in the education system have not yet been developed in our country. Nevertheless, the need for such rules is obvious. It is worth noting that Maksut Shadayev spoke about the advisability of initiating regulation specifically in the field of education, considering it one of the most pressing. According to Vera Loktionova, the lack of legislative regulation generates uncertainty and creates potential threats.
Certainly, certain measures to establish regulatory frameworks have already been taken, and the speaker announced their list:
- On October 10, 2019, Decree No. 490 of the President of the Russian Federation "On the Development of Artificial Intelligence in the Russian Federation" was signed, approving the National Strategy for the Development of AI, designed to last until 2030. In the field of education, the main focus of this strategy is the training of personnel with knowledge of artificial intelligence, as well as the development of skills related to this field. In addition, the document includes measures to implement ethical standards in the work of educational institutions based on the principles of the Code of Ethics in the Sphere of AI.
- The national standard of the Russian Federation GOST R 59895–2021 regulates the main aspects and terminology related to artificial intelligence technologies in education.
- The Ministry of Education presented advice on the integration of relevant digital technologies into basic educational programs. These recommendations cover a wide range of digital solutions and are not limited to artificial intelligence.
- GOST R 59895–2021 is a national standard dedicated to the topic "Artificial Intelligence Technologies in Education. Basic Principles and Terminology." This standard also specifies the various purposes for which artificial intelligence technologies can be applied.
- GOST R 59896–2021 is a regulatory document concerning "Educational products with artificial intelligence algorithms intended for adaptive learning in the general education system. It sets out the requirements for teaching and methodological materials." However, Vera Loktionova emphasizes that there is a particular problem with standards: they can quickly become outdated due to constant changes in both artificial intelligence technologies and the methods of their application.
- The Code of Ethics concerning artificial intelligence is a recommendatory document that applies to all organizations. A number of universities have also joined.

Furthermore, the Ministry of Digital Development has prepared a draft concept for regulating artificial intelligence through 2030, which is subject to government approval. However, this document has not yet been presented for public discussion. The key principles of the concept include a human-centered approach, technological independence, as well as guarantees of transparency and the inadmissibility of causing harm to humans.
Vera Loktionova noted that the proposed principles are important and valid, but more specific recommendations regarding the field of education would be useful. Currently, Russian universities exhibit a wide range of opinions regarding the use of generative neural networks: some permit their use, requiring mandatory disclosure in student papers, others prohibit it entirely, and still others prefer not to express their position. Thus, a unified approach is still lacking: should the use of neural networks be permitted, prohibited, or somehow controlled? At the same time, some universities are already implementing artificial intelligence for various purposes, including adaptive educational platforms, predictive analysis of student performance, and video surveillance systems that track student engagement in the learning process.
Read also:
At the Moscow State University of Psychology and Education, they are developing models for predicting student academic performance using artificial intelligence.
The code of ethics, of course, implies the correct use of technology, however, according to the speaker, it is necessary to formulate clearer rules regarding the permissible and unacceptable use of artificial intelligence. It is also important to teach students how to use these technologies responsibly and consciously in the educational process. At the same time, it is necessary to strive for harmony between prohibitions and the unrestricted, thoughtless use of new technologies. In other words, it makes sense to use a risk-based approach, similar to that used in the European Union, while developing experimental legal models, as is being done in Japan.
It would be advisable to centrally implement mandatory courses on artificial intelligence at all levels of education, with an emphasis on developing critical thinking, ethical judgment, and practical skills, drawing on China's experience and upcoming initiatives being developed in India. The speaker fully agrees that it is necessary to improve teacher training in the use of AI technologies, which can be achieved through large-scale professional development programs and the creation of relevant teaching materials. However, it is worth noting that implementing these measures will require significant financial investment.
Vera Loktionova believes that RATIO could play an active role in creating a unified national strategy for integrating artificial intelligence into the educational process. This requires coordinated efforts by organizations such as the Ministry of Digital Development, the Ministry of Education and Science, Roskomnadzor, and other government agencies.
What's Next?
While all participants agreed on the importance of regulation, concerns repeatedly arose during the conversation that excessive regulation could negatively impact the industry. Overly rigid frameworks could limit space for experimentation, which, in turn, will slow development. Therefore, it is crucial that the regulatory process be collaborative, involving both government agencies and experts from the educational field and EdTech businesses. In addition, there needs to be a mediator who can connect these different groups.

«It is necessary "An institutional-level intermediary capable of facilitating interaction between the educational community and technology companies is needed. This will allow educators to communicate their requirements, which should be taken into account when creating these systems so that they do not worsen the standard of education," noted Luaza Bayramkulova.
Yulia Goryachkina, Head of the "Personnel for the Digital Economy" department, believes that a working group including representatives of various stakeholders could serve as a suitable intermediary in this matter.
In conclusion, Valentina Kurenkova noted that there are two main approaches to implementing artificial intelligence regulation in education in Russia. The first approach involves a top-down approach, in which industry representatives expect the government to develop and implement a comprehensive strategy for regulating AI in education. In this case, the sector will only have to adapt to the new state policy when it is formulated by the government or the president.
The second option is a proactive approach, which implies "moving towards the regulator." This means developing industry recommendations with the participation of the professional community and presenting them to the regulator for integration into the strategy being developed. However, for this approach to be successfully implemented, it is time to move from general discussions to specific proposals. According to information from RATIO, active work on issues related to artificial intelligence is planned for 2026.
Read also:
- In the EdTech environment, the time has come to begin discussing ethical issues. Technologies used in education are becoming increasingly influential and permeating various aspects of the educational process. This creates a need not only for innovation but also for understanding their consequences.
With the increasing use of artificial intelligence and big data in educational applications, many questions arise about privacy, security, and fairness. How can we ensure that student data is used responsibly? How can we avoid bias in algorithms that could affect the educational process? These and other issues require attention and discussion.
Furthermore, it is important to consider the impact of technology on teachers and students. How are new tools changing traditional methods of teaching and interaction? The ethical aspects of these changes must be the subject of serious analysis.
Therefore, the discussion of ethics in EdTech is not only relevant but also necessary to ensure a healthy and equitable educational space. We must address these issues to create a sustainable and ethical environment for the education of future generations.
- Russian companies took part in the signing of the Code of Ethics in the Field of Artificial Intelligence.
- Trump issued an executive order concerning the implementation of artificial intelligence in the educational programs of American schools.
- In Singapore, all educational institutions will begin to use adaptive teaching methods based on artificial intelligence technologies.
- Yandex, together with the National Research University Higher School of Economics, conducted a study on the use of artificial intelligence in the higher education system.
- British universities have developed key principles concerning the responsible use of generative artificial intelligence.
