Education

Updated School Digital Transformation Strategy: Will AI Check Homework?

Updated School Digital Transformation Strategy: Will AI Check Homework?

Learn: Profession Methodist from scratch to PRO

Find out more

In November, a statement by Deputy Minister of Digital Development, Communications, and Mass Media Oleg Kachanov was actively discussed in Russian media and the professional community. He noted that one of the requirements for a standard digital solution in school education would be the percentage of homework that would be automatically checked. This statement is of interest, as automated homework checking could significantly improve the efficiency of the educational process and reduce the workload of teachers. The implementation of such solutions could contribute to improving the quality of education and creating a more individualized approach to learning.

Deputies expressed their concerns regarding the introduction of new technologies into the educational process. Olga Kazakova, Chair of the State Duma Committee on Education, noted in an interview with Kommersant that homework checking requires a personalized approach from the teacher, which cannot be replaced by automated systems. Her deputy, Yana Lantratova, also expressed her opinion on her Telegram channel, emphasizing that the use of artificial intelligence in schools could negatively impact the motivation of both students and teachers, as well as lead to a decrease in the level of communication and interaction between them. It is important to consider that the educational process requires human involvement and emotional interaction, which is difficult to achieve with technology.

The Ministry of Digital Development clarified that Kachanov mentioned the requirements for regional information systems being discussed with the Ministry of Education. The ministry noted that, in addition to automatic homework checking, other assessment criteria are also being considered. Full automation of the educational process is not planned, which confirms the ministry's position.

The media is discussing the implementation of automated homework checking, which is mentioned in the strategic direction for the digital transformation of education, developed by the Ministry of Education of the Russian Federation. This document was approved by government order and posted on the official legal information portal at the end of October 2023. It sets out the content and implementation deadlines for several digitalization projects aimed at improving the educational process in schools, preschools, and secondary vocational education institutions. The introduction of such technologies can significantly improve the quality of education and simplify the process of assessing homework, which is an important step in the development of modern education.

What tasks for the digital transformation of education has the government set?

The approved strategic direction replaces the previous document adopted in 2021. The new strategic plan, like its predecessor, covers the period up to 2030. The targets in this document are linked to specific projects, which will be discussed below. This approach ensures a clear connection between the strategy and its implementation, which allows for more effective achievement of the set goals.

The new document has amended the wording of the goals, objectives, and priorities of the strategic direction for the digital transformation of schools. The goal is now to achieve a high degree of "digital maturity" in the field of education. Previously, the stated goal was "to provide effective information support to participants in educational relations during the process of obtaining an education and managing educational activities." The new wording emphasizes the importance of integrating digital technologies into the educational process, which not only improves the quality of education but also enhances the overall management efficiency of educational institutions.

According to the new document, Russia plans to create a unified, secure educational space. This space will ensure equal access to high-quality, verified content and services for all participants in the educational process, including teachers, students, and their parents. The creation of such a space is aimed at improving the level of education and safety in the learning environment, thereby promoting more effective learning and development.

Photo: FSOSh / Sirius

The document contains changes to the objectives, which now differ from previous versions. The implementation of the strategic direction is still aimed at improving the efficiency of educational organizations. The main goals remain ensuring equal access to high-quality, verified digital educational content and services, creating a single point of access to them, standardizing information systems in the educational sphere, and transitioning to unified registries and classifiers. In addition to these objectives, three new goals have been added that expand and clarify the strategic approach to the development of the educational system.

  • create opportunities for both students and teachers to build individual educational trajectories of personal growth;
  • create an effective system for identifying, developing, and supporting talents in children;
  • reduce the administrative burden on teachers using technology, including artificial intelligence (AI).

In addition to the main educational objectives, there are also additional goals not directly related to education. In particular, by 2030, it is planned that 100% of equipment and 42.8% of electronic goods, including software, will be produced in Russia. This creates opportunities for the development of domestic industry and increasing the country's level of technological independence.

The new document prioritizes the preservation and strengthening of traditional forms of education using information technology. In this context, digital technologies play a supporting role, contributing to the improvement of the educational process and increasing its effectiveness.

What services will be developed

The document presents the target state of the education system, associated with achieving "digital maturity", as follows: the education system must ensure the full integration of digital technologies into the educational process and the management of educational institutions. This includes the use of modern digital tools to improve the quality of education, access to educational resources online, and the development of digital competencies among both teachers and students. An important aspect is the creation of infrastructure that supports the digital environment, including internet access and the necessary equipment. Digital maturity also implies active interaction with parents and the community through digital platforms, which promotes more effective learning and increased interest in the educational process.

  • everyone has access to verified content, as well as the ability to plan and manage individual development trajectories;
  • students can select organizations for training and various competitions (for example, olympiads) online and register for them;
  • educational documents can also be obtained and submitted for admission to colleges and universities online;
  • teachers have the opportunity to check homework and plan educational programs using AI, and administrators can make management decisions based on big data analysis.

The document describes in detail the challenges faced by participants in the educational process in the context of digital transformation. One of the main problems is the presence of a large number of low-quality educational portals. Registration on these resources creates the risk of leakage of personal data of children, their parents, and teachers. The fragmented nature of information makes it difficult for parents to navigate their children's educational opportunities, teachers face excessive demands, and educational organizations and regulators are unable to adequately assess the situation. This is due to the lack of standardization of services and the diversity of data collection formats. It is important to develop unified approaches to the creation and management of educational platforms, which will improve the quality of education and protect the personal data of all participants in the process.

Photo: FSOSh / Sirius

In order to achieve The target state includes the development of a unified system of information technologies, services, and registries covering the entire country. Several projects aimed at streamlining processes and improving access to information have already been launched within this initiative. The creation of such systems will ensure more effective interaction between government agencies and citizens, as well as increase transparency and trust in the information environment. The results of this project are targeted at students, their parents, and teachers. Several digital resources have been developed within the project, including the Federal State Information System (FGIS) "My School," the library of the "Academy for the Implementation of State Policy and Professional Development of Education Workers," and the automated information system (AIS) "Big Data Platform." During the project's implementation, students will gain access to educational content and will be able to collaborate with their parents on their educational trajectories, while teachers will be able to improve their skills. The project's key targets include ensuring that 50% of children, teachers, and parents will have access to verified content by 2024, and that this figure will increase to 80% by 2030. This will ensure high-quality and accessible education for all stakeholders.

In this context, it is important to emphasize that the analysis of various projects focuses on indicators related to access to specific systems and services. However, the document lacks information on the actual number of children and teachers who will actually use digital solutions. This creates a gap in understanding the effectiveness of integrating technology into the educational process and requires a more detailed analysis.

All three projects are aimed at developing several information systems, including "Digital Assistants," "Digital Psychologist," "Registers of Participants in Educational Relations," and "Big Data Platform," as well as a system for children's supplementary education programs. Digital assistants will perform a number of functions, such as providing information, user support, and assistance in navigating educational resources. These systems are designed to improve the quality of the educational process, making it more accessible and effective. Data integration and the use of information analysis technologies will facilitate a deeper understanding of student needs and increase their engagement in learning.

  • The "Digital Student Assistant" will help students develop an individualized learning plan, receive assistance from counseling psychologists, and interact with mentors. By 2024, the use of digital content collection services by students, their parents, and teachers should reach 60%, and by 2030, 80%.
  • The "Digital Parent Assistant" will allow parents to organize their children's education and receive consultations from educational psychologists. The target indicator is the share of those who have been given the opportunity to create an effective system for identifying, developing, and supporting children's talents using a comprehensive proactive service. Moreover, this share should always (from 2024 to 2030) be equal to 80%.
  • The "Digital Teacher Assistant" will use AI to automate homework checking and educational program planning, allowing teachers to effectively support children's talents and reducing bureaucratic burdens. The ability to automate program planning and homework checking should be provided to 90% of teachers throughout the implementation of the strategic direction.

The project aims to integrate data from the My School and Registers of Participants in Educational Relations systems with the government services portal and the Big Data Platform. As a result, each student, with their parents' consent, will create a portfolio including their academic and personal achievements. This portfolio will serve as the basis for applying to college or university. By 2024, the plan is to provide the ability to effectively plan personal growth trajectories for 40% of students, their parents, and teachers, and by 2030, for 80%. This approach will improve the quality of education and enhance the level of students' preparation for future academic and professional activities.

Photo: BearFotos / Shutterstock

Discussions about a digital portfolio have begun to actively arise In 2021, when its introduction was considered a five- to ten-year prospect. At the time, many experts predicted that the digital portfolio would become an essential tool for showcasing skills and achievements in various fields. With the advancement of technology and the increasing importance of online presence, especially in the professional world, a digital portfolio has become not just a desirable feature, but a necessity for career growth and competitiveness. Every year, more and more professionals understand the importance of creating and maintaining an up-to-date digital portfolio that allows them to effectively present their projects and achievements. The project's main product is the "Management System for an Educational Organization." The project also includes the "Registers of Participants in Educational Relations" and the "Big Data Platform." This project will significantly expand the capabilities for making informed management decisions based on big data analysis. It is expected that by 2024, the information system will be implemented in 90% of educational institutions, which will improve management processes and increase the effectiveness of educational activities.

What has already been accomplished

All projects described in this document have been transferred from the previous strategic direction, approved in 2021. The text also presents the achieved results. For example, the "Library of Digital Educational Content" project was 35% fulfilled according to the established targets by 2022, the "Digital Student Assistant" project reached 10%, and the "Digital Student Portfolio" project reached 15%. These and other initiatives have become part of digital transformation strategies in most regions of Russia. In addition, some of them are integrated into the federal project "Digital Educational Environment", which is an integral part of the national project "Education". Such projects are aimed at improving the quality of the educational process and introducing modern technologies into the learning environment.

The roadmap for implementing projects in the strategic direction is formatted in a standard manner, with repeating wording for each element for each year. The main conclusion that can be drawn from this document is that service functionality is scheduled to be updated annually, with new versions released in December. This ensures that the services offered remain relevant and competitive, as well as providing users with access to the most modern capabilities.

The list of executors, co-executors, and participants in the development and implementation of the strategic direction includes the Ministry of Education, the Ministry of Digital Development, the Ministry of Economic Development, the Ministry of Industry and Trade, as well as state authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation and local governments. Other government agencies are also included in this category.

The project's strategic direction, which specifies the financial requirements for its implementation, was published on the Ministry of Education's website. Annual costs are expected to range from 1.5 to 2.2 billion rubles, and the total investment by 2030 will exceed 13 billion rubles. However, the official document approved by government decree does not contain this information. This creates uncertainty regarding the project's funding and implementation, which could impact its success and the achievement of its stated goals.

What could hinder the implementation of plans

The strategic direction for digital transformation of education identifies risks that could negatively impact the successful implementation of projects. These risks can be summarized as follows:

  • untimely equipping of educational institutions with the necessary equipment and access to the Internet and services, as well as the lack of the necessary technologies for the formation of a digital educational environment;
  • low quality of primary data on which analytics is supposed to be based;
  • lack of competencies among managers, teachers, and citizens to use new digital services;
  • lack of interest of citizens in these projects or unwillingness to use the digital educational environment due to mistrust in it, including due to insufficient information security.

The discussion about the possibility of automating homework checking underscores the importance of this issue in the context of the updated education strategy. Education is one of those areas where digitalization is facing serious resistance. Many Russians express concerns about the introduction of artificial intelligence in the educational process. These concerns may become a critical factor in developing new approaches to teaching and assessment.

Photo: Julia Zavalishina / Shutterstock

According to a recent survey conducted by According to SberStrakhovanie, 61% of respondents believe in the positive changes that artificial intelligence can bring. However, only 17% of survey participants believe AI will be in demand in education. Compared to 2021, when the previous version of the strategic direction was adopted, digital transformation plans now appear more realistic. Numerous AI assistants with diverse functions already exist in education, and Russian teams such as Yandex, Skyeng, and Samoletum are developing them. These companies are actively implementing innovative solutions, which contribute to improving the educational process and increasing its effectiveness. The university admissions process has now become a public service on an online portal. In 2022, many expressed dissatisfaction with the super service, but in 2023, no serious problems were observed. The Ministry of Education and the Ministry of Digital Development appear to be truly capable of providing the necessary services to both students and teachers. The question of how much demand these services will have remains open.

Revised text:

Also study:

  • Interview about a digital tutor for schoolchildren: "Our task is to develop thinking and speech"
  • Teachers expect digitalization to save time, but instead receive an extra workload. Why?
  • "Scrub", "Seraphim" and digital commissioners: a new digital ecosystem was invented for universities
  • Why UNESCO is calling for a review of approaches to the digitalization of education

The profession of Methodologist from scratch to PRO

You will upgrade your skills in Developing curricula for online and offline courses. Master modern teaching practices, structure your experience, and become a more sought-after specialist.

Learn more