Contents:

Learn: Soft Skills for Hard Times
Find out moreThe new issue of the scientific journal "Problems of Education" presents the article "Interest Cannot Be Forced. The Role of Academic Motivation and Teaching Styles in the Development of Students' Critical Thinking." The authors of the study are Yulia Koreshnikova, a research fellow at the Center for Skills Development and Professional Education at the Institute of Education at the National Research University Higher School of Economics, and Elena Avdeeva, Head of the Department of Pedagogy and Psychology at the Krasnoyarsk State Medical University named after V.F. Voyno-Yasenetsky. The article highlights important aspects of academic motivation and teaching methods that contribute to the development of critical thinking in students, which is a relevant topic in the modern educational process.
The researchers analyzed various scientific studies devoted to motivation and the development of critical thinking, and also conducted their own study among students. Their goal was to determine which teaching style contributes to the development of critical thinking in students. In particular, they investigated which teaching approach activates students' motivation, which, in turn, plays a key role in the development of critical thinking. This problem requires a deep understanding, and we will now explain its essence.
What assumptions did the researchers proceed from?
Critical thinking is one of the key competencies in the modern world. It allows you to effectively filter unreliable information, avoid manipulation, make informed decisions, and argue your opinions. Using Benjamin Bloom's classification of learning objectives, critical thinking can be viewed as a set of skills, including information analysis, argument evaluation, and synthesis—the formulation of logically sound conclusions. The development of critical thinking contributes to a deeper understanding of reality and improves the ability to solve complex problems.
Yulia Koreshnikova and Elena Avdeeva argue that there is research confirming that critical thinking does not develop automatically during the learning process. Along with other educational outcomes, this competency requires a targeted approach for its development. This emphasizes the importance of implementing specific methods and practices aimed at developing critical thinking in students, which facilitates a deeper acquisition of knowledge and skills. International researchers emphasize the importance of academic motivation as a key factor in the development of critical thinking. In this context, it is worth noting the research of Patrick Buckley and Elaine Doyle, as well as the work of Samuel Abramovich, Christian Shann, and Ross Higashi. Their research demonstrates how motivation to learn contributes to the development of analytical skills and the ability to critically analyze information. This emphasizes the need to implement methods that stimulate students' interest in the learning process, which, in turn, influences the development of their critical thinking. Koreshnikova and Avdeeva note that motivation often declines during the learning process. To ensure that a lack of motivation does not become an obstacle to students' critical thinking development, it is important to ensure its ongoing support. Active learning methods, creating conditions for self-expression and student engagement in the learning process can help maintain high levels of motivation, which, in turn, will contribute to more effective development of critical thinking.
Different teaching styles play an important role in the educational process, including constructivist (activity-based) and traditional (knowledge-based). In the constructivist approach, students actively participate in learning, independently constructing knowledge and finding solutions to problems. This method promotes the development of critical thinking and independent work skills. In contrast, the traditional style implies the transmission of knowledge in a dogmatic manner, usually through lectures, where students receive information and solve problems using predetermined algorithms. In practice, both approaches are rarely found in their pure form, as instructors often combine elements of different styles. However, it is possible to identify the predominant style in each specific case, which allows for a better understanding of the teacher's methodological preferences and their influence on the educational process.

Researchers I-Wan Kwan and Angela Wong studied the influence of a constructivist approach on the development of critical thinking and concluded that there is a link between these two aspects through motivation. However, the influence of a traditional (knowledge-based) approach on the development of critical thinking remains understudied. In Russia, the impact of teaching style on the development of students' critical thinking has not yet received due attention. According to Koreshnikova and Avdeeva, cultural factors play a key role in this context, making it impossible to simply transfer foreign findings to Russian realities. Thus, further research is needed to understand how different teaching approaches influence critical thinking in Russian educational institutions.
Experts conducted a study to determine which teaching style most effectively motivates Russian students and promotes the development of their critical thinking.
How the study was conducted
This work is part of the international WiWiKom project, aimed at assessing students' economic literacy. The study was conducted online and covered 5,123 undergraduate students studying in programs related to economics and management in their first three years. The WiWiKom project provides valuable information on the level of economic knowledge among students and contributes to improving the quality of education in this field.
Students were asked to take an economic literacy test and complete a questionnaire containing questions for self-assessment of their level of critical thinking and motivation. In addition, they needed to evaluate the teaching styles they encountered at the university. This initiative aims to identify the level of economic awareness and a critical approach to learning, thereby improving the quality of the educational process in universities.
The researchers note that the self-assessment method of critical thinking has its shortcomings, as it is based on subjective perception. However, they emphasize that Russia lacks standardized, valid, and reliable instruments for assessing critical thinking at the higher education level. Foreign instruments cannot be applied in this context due to cultural differences. Therefore, there is a need to develop adapted assessment methods that take into account the specific features of the Russian educational environment.
To assess the level of academic motivation, the Academic Motivation Scale (AMS), created by Tamara Gordeeva, Evgeny Osin, and Oleg Sychev, is used. It is based on the self-determination theory of Edward Deci and Richard Ryan. Unlike traditional approaches that divide academic motivation into extrinsic and intrinsic, this scale identifies seven different subtypes of motivation. This allows us to more accurately determine the factors influencing the educational process and student achievement.
- intrinsic motivation — knowledge (the desire to learn new things), achievement (a person gets pleasure from high results and solving difficult problems), self-development (studying for the sake of a feeling of mastery and competence, realizing one’s potential);
- extrinsic motivation — external (a person studies to avoid possible problems), introjected (the desire to study is based on a sense of duty and shame) and self-esteem motivation (studying for the sake of a feeling of one’s own importance);
- amotivation — lack of motivation to study.
To determine teaching styles, the researchers conducted a survey among students, asking them to rate a number of statements on a scale from “Completely disagree” to “Completely agree”. The traditional teaching style is defined by the following characteristics:
- instructors expect students to primarily write down material from dictation or from the board in class;
- instructors emphasize the need to memorize facts;
- most classes are organized in such a way that the instructor presents the course material;
- it is more important for instructors that students learn certain facts than how these facts can be used;
- instructors expect students to treat the information presented in class as indisputable facts.
The researchers attributed the following statements to the constructivist style:
- instructors show the connection between the material taught and practice;
- instructors emphasize not only the memorization of facts, but also an understanding of the theories within which they arose;
- instructors allocate time in class for student participation in discussions;
- teachers encourage students to ask questions and formulate their own hypotheses;
- teachers encourage students to solve authentic problems in class;
- teachers encourage students to apply the skills acquired in class in practice.
Students provided their responses to questions regarding critical thinking, teaching methods, and motivation developed by Koreshnikov and Avdeev. These responses were placed on the appropriate scales for further analysis. As a result of the data analysis, relationships between various indicators were identified, which allows for a deeper understanding of the influence of these factors on the educational process.

What are the results
The study confirmed the findings of foreign scientists that a constructivist teaching style promotes the development of critical thinking in students. In contrast, a traditional approach focused on knowledge transfer did not demonstrate a significant connection with the formation of this important competence. This underscores the need to implement innovative teaching methods that will promote a deeper understanding of the material and the development of analytical skills in students.
Teaching style does not directly create critical thinking, but influences it through maintaining academic motivation. The study by Koreshnikova and Avdeeva emphasizes that intrinsic motivation, based on the desire for knowledge, achievement, and self-development, plays a key role in the development of critical thinking. This confirms the importance of creating conditions that promote students' interest in learning, which in turn contributes to the development of analytical thinking and the ability to critically analyze information.
Extrinsic motivation plays an important role in the educational process, but its influence on the development of critical thinking is not as positive as might be expected. Research shows that self-esteem-based motivation does not improve critical thinking. Furthermore, external and introjected motivation can have a negative impact. Students who study to avoid negative consequences, such as problems or feelings of obligation and shame, are less likely to develop critical thinking skills. This also applies to students who lack an intrinsic drive to learn. Intrinsic motivation, which promotes deeper understanding of information and active engagement in the learning process, is essential for the successful development of critical thinking.
The study revealed the impact of different teaching styles on student motivation. The constructivist approach enhances intrinsic stimuli, such as the motivation for learning, achievement, and self-development. In contrast, the traditional knowledge-based approach negatively impacts these motives, supporting only external and introjected motivation, which can ultimately lead to amotivation. Thus, traditional teaching methods can suppress the genuine desire to learn and master new things in initially inquisitive students, replacing it with the motive of "I study because I have to." This underscores the importance of choosing a teaching approach to developing sustainable motivation in students.
What conclusions can be drawn
The authors of the Russian study claim that their findings confirm and deepen the results of international research. They emphasize that critical thinking is directly related to various types of intrinsic motivation. It is important to note that a constructivist teaching style has a positive impact on the development of both critical thinking and intrinsic motivation in students. Yulia Koreshnikova and Elena Avdeeva emphasize that constructivism as an educational approach is justified by its unique characteristics. Within the constructivist learning model, students actively process the information they receive, integrating it with their existing knowledge to form new understandings. The teacher's role in this system is to initiate and organize the learning process in a way that stimulates student interest and curiosity. This creates the basis for active intrinsic motivation, which is a key element of successful learning. The authors of the study believe that the findings obtained during the study with students from one university may be applicable to students at other Russian universities. However, they acknowledge the limitations of this study and plan to conduct a repeat study with a more representative sample. A standardized instrument for assessing critical thinking, currently under development, will be used for this purpose.
Reading is an important part of our lives, and it offers numerous benefits. It broadens our horizons, develops our thinking, and improves communication skills. Books, articles, and blogs can be a source of inspiration and knowledge. Make time for reading to enrich your inner world and improve your literacy skills. Modern technology offers access to a variety of information sources, making reading even more accessible and engaging. Don't miss the opportunity to develop yourself through literature and scientific publications. Read regularly to stay up to date with new trends and discoveries in your field of interest.
- Why and how Russian universities are implementing pedagogical design
- Soft skills vs. hard skills: what is more important for employment
- 5 books on how to motivate learning
- John Keller's model of student motivation: what it is and how it works
Soft Skills for Hard Times
You will learn to manage teams, recognize colleagues' emotions, and speak in public. You will learn how to maintain productivity in stressful situations, cope better with work, and feel more confident.
Find out more
