Education

Why Don't Students Ask Questions? Excerpt from "Interactive Questioning"

Why Don't Students Ask Questions? Excerpt from "Interactive Questioning"

Learn: Educational Programs Methodologist

Learn more

Questioning, or the art of asking questions, is one of the oldest methods of active learning, known since ancient times. In modern education, which emphasizes the active role of the student, questioning takes on special significance. This method promotes a deep understanding of the material, developing critical thinking and analytical skills. By asking questions, students not only actively engage in the learning process but also become more independent, which contributes to their personal and professional development. In a rapidly changing world where information is available in abundance, the ability to ask the right questions is becoming a key skill for successful learning and adaptation.

The authors of the collection of materials "Interactive Questioning: How the Ability to Ask Your Own Questions Helps Develop"—Vera Danilova, Vadim Karastelev, Vadim Rozin, and their colleagues—examine the methodology and theoretical aspects of questioning. They analyze international experience with questions and provide specific methods and techniques that will help readers develop questioning skills for personal and professional growth. This manual will be useful for those seeking to improve their communication skills and learn how to effectively use questions to achieve their goals.

With the consent of the authors, we present an excerpt from the chapter "Interactive Questioning as a Technology of Modern Education." This chapter examines methods and approaches that promote active student engagement in the educational process through interactive questioning. Interactive questioning not only enhances learning but also develops critical thinking, an important aspect of modern education. We hope this section will be useful for educators and students interested in new methods in education.

What is the current situation?

Two types of pedagogical practices need to be distinguished: industrial and post-industrial. These approaches differ in both the learning goals and the methods and means of implementation. It is important to note that they also differ in the opportunities for student learning, especially in what can be called the learning path. In industrial education, the path is standard for all students—a kind of conveyor belt onto which a child is placed at the age of seven, moving them from lesson to lesson and from class to class. In contrast, post-industrial education, which is currently in its infancy, provides students with the opportunity to independently create their own educational path, which promotes the development of individuality and critical thinking. This opens up new horizons for self-education and active participation in the educational process.

In industrial pedagogical practice, all rights were vested exclusively in the teacher, allowing them to exercise their authority, including methods of suppressing the will of students, such as physical punishment and educational talks with parents. This situation was a consequence of the needs of industrial production, which required mass performers, similar to work on a factory assembly line or in the army. At that time, the process of knowledge transfer and the adaptation of professions occurred slowly, which limited the opportunities for flexible training and development.

The situation changed with the acceleration of innovation and the increase in the volume of knowledge, which made it impossible to predict the needs of a dynamically developing modern economy. This required a revision of approaches to training and education processes. As a result, training in specific professions in a number of industrial sectors became ineffective, since by the time specialists completed their training, the professions could disappear (for example, secretaries-typists, radio operators, and others). This highlights the importance of flexibility and adaptability in educational programs, which must take into account the rapidly changing demands of the labor market.

In a context of constant uncertainty, the fundamental foundation of education is being transformed: the emphasis is shifting from preparing for a specific workplace to developing a readiness for constant change. In this situation, the key task of modern pedagogical practice is creating conditions that facilitate the formulation and implementation of students' own goals. It is also important to preserve the cultural and historical context of education, reflect on the results obtained, and develop responsibility for the decisions made. This will allow students to more effectively adapt to changes in the professional environment and successfully cope with the challenges of the modern world.

The task of revising the foundations of pedagogical practice requires deep reflection. In this regard, an important question arises: what learning formats and pedagogical tools can promote the development of independent thinking and responsibility in students? How can we help students who have already gone through the traditional educational system begin to understand the meaning of their education and build an individual educational path? A key aspect is the use of available educational resources both within the university and beyond. This may include online courses, workshops, projects, and other forms of interaction that inspire active participation in the learning process and help develop personal and professional competencies.

Russian Academy of Education Academician Alexander Asmolov emphasizes that modern school education often involves providing answers without students asking questions first. This phenomenon is observed not only in our educational context. Canadian cultural theorist and philosopher Marshall McLuhan noted that the main problem is not a lack of answers, but a lack of questions. We believe that the ability to formulate one's own questions and analyze those underlying the knowledge gained is a key aspect of both meaningful learning and effective independent action. Unfortunately, this ability is not only unsupported but also undermined by the current mass education system, which negatively impacts the development of critical thinking in students.

Fostering a culture of questioning in students can be an effective solution to this problem. This process involves the use of modern thinking techniques that have been actively developing since the late 20th century. These methods not only encourage students to generate their own questions but also help avoid knee-jerk responses, which significantly improves the quality of learning. Creating an environment where active questioning is encouraged fosters a deeper understanding of the material and develops critical thinking.

The techniques for forming and using question fields developed in our International Laboratory of Interactive Questioning effectively motivate participants in a variety of activity formats. These methods are used in traditional lessons, lectures, and seminars, as well as at conferences. They are also useful in creative planning, training sessions, and brainstorming sessions, as well as in conflict resolution and prevention. The techniques facilitate teambuilding and help explore the boundaries of the known and unknown. Their use is especially relevant during project and strategy sessions, as well as when creating question frameworks for research. Effective use of these techniques can significantly increase participant engagement and improve work results.

Before describing the techniques, it is important to consider the difficulties faced by even highly qualified university students who received Unified State Exam scores in the 90-100 range. These students, despite their academic achievements, often experience certain difficulties in the educational process. Understanding these difficulties will help you better adapt approaches and techniques for successful learning and overcome emerging obstacles.

Educational Programs Methodologist

You will go through the full cycle of creating an educational product from scratch. Learn to design curricula for online and offline courses. Become a versatile specialist – you can launch your own project or get a job as a methodologist at a large company.

Find out more