Contents:

Skillbox Digital College → In-demand professions in IT and design. Diploma of secondary vocational education and assistance in employment.
Find out moreIn this article, you will get acquainted with the key aspects of the topic. We will consider the main points that will help you better understand the subject of discussion. You will learn about the meaning and importance of these aspects, and also receive useful recommendations for their application in practical life. You will gain valuable knowledge that will help you in further mastering the topic.
- Why is the popularity of secondary vocational education growing?
- Who wins in terms of employment prospects after graduation and salaries - university graduates or college graduates?
- Which areas of secondary vocational education have the highest proportion of unemployed graduates.
- In which professions is it more difficult and, conversely, easier to find a job with a secondary vocational education.
- Why do graduates have to move to other regions to work in their specialty?
What is more advantageous for employment: a university or a college diploma?
Over the past decade, there has been a significant increase in the popularity of secondary vocational education in Russia. Ninth-grade graduates are increasingly choosing colleges instead of continuing their studies at school. The proportion of eleventh-grade graduates entering universities has also increased, reaching approximately one-third, according to Irina Seliverstova, Deputy Director of the Research Center for Monitoring and Statistics of Education at the Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration (RANEPA). This trend indicates that young people are increasingly consciously choosing their educational path, focusing on practical skills and the demand for professions in the labor market. Research shows that the popularity of secondary vocational education (SVE) is growing for several reasons. One significant factor is the influence of the Unified State Exam (USE). Schools strive to avoid admitting weak students into the tenth grade to avoid worsening their exam performance. In turn, many teenagers and their families are unwilling to spend two years and significant resources preparing for the USE, which also contributes to the growing interest in SVE. Over the past ten years, the practice of entering higher education through colleges, bypassing the USE, has become increasingly common. According to research, approximately half of college students plan to continue their education at universities, underscoring the importance of vocational education as an alternative path to higher education.
The popularity of vocational education cannot be explained by just one factor. Many young people choosing college after the 9th and 11th grades genuinely seek to quickly acquire professional skills and start earning money. For them, it is important not just to obtain a higher education degree, but to master a real profession and successfully enter the labor market. These students are focused on the practical application of knowledge and are ready to combine study with work to achieve financial independence and career advancement.
A pragmatic approach to educational choice is becoming increasingly common, and researchers attribute this primarily to economic factors. Many families face financial difficulties and cannot afford to support a student in university for several years, let alone pay for tuition. However, experts note that the situation has begun to change: approximately 20% of families whose children enroll in college have sufficient funds to pay for higher education. However, even for these families, choosing secondary vocational education (SVE) can serve as an additional guarantee. A child's rapid transition to independent living after school provides a certain level of financial security. Having a profession allows you to minimize risks and prepare for unexpected circumstances, which makes the choice of vocational education relevant and reasonable.

To improve the text for SEO, you need to focus on keywords and phrases that will help increase the visibility of content in search engines.
Reading is an important part of our lives, as it broadens our horizons and develops our thinking. Books, articles, and blogs provide a variety of information, allowing us to delve deeper into various topics. Reading not only enriches our knowledge but also promotes the development of critical thinking. Thanks to reading, we can better understand the world around us, analyze events, and form our own opinions. It is important to choose high-quality sources of information to get the most out of it. Don't forget about the variety of genres and styles, as each can offer a unique perspective on familiar things.
It is also worth noting that reading improves concentration and memory. Regular reading practice helps develop the skills of perceiving and analyzing texts, which is especially important in the modern world, where information comes in huge volumes.
Follow new publications and choose interesting reading materials to constantly develop and enrich your inner world.
Modern trends show that universities are losing their appeal for high school graduates. More and more young people prefer colleges, which is due to various factors. Firstly, colleges offer a more practical education focused on specific professions, allowing students to more quickly adapt to the labor market. Secondly, colleges often have more accessible programs and lower financial costs compared to universities, which also plays a significant role in choosing a future career. Thirdly, many colleges offer flexible schedules and the opportunity to combine study with work, making them more attractive to young people. Therefore, the choice between university and college is becoming increasingly important, and it is important to understand the advantages of different educational institutions. Economic research shows that the return on education remains high in Russia. Statistics show that incomes increase linearly with increasing educational attainment. For example, graduates of secondary vocational educational institutions (SVE) earn 15-25% more than those who did not continue their education after high school, while university graduates earn 50% more. Thus, despite the fact that secondary vocational education graduates begin working earlier than their peers who entered university, they ultimately suffer a loss in income. This underscores the importance of choosing an educational path for future financial stability.
The question of whether education is more beneficial than lack thereof depends on many factors. The previously mentioned indicators of the economic return on education are averages. A detailed analysis of specific fields and regions can reveal significant differences in results. These differences may be due to the demand for specialists, salary levels, and the economic situation in each specific region. Therefore, it is important to consider individual circumstances and goals to make an informed educational choice.
In the spring, the Higher School of Economics published a report on the employment of university graduates. This study, based on monitoring data from Rostrud, revealed significant variations in the incomes of entry-level specialists with higher education. Factors such as specialty, region of study, and the status of the educational institution have a significant impact on the economic return on education. In our article, we examined the key findings of the report in detail.
Rostrud collects data on graduates of secondary vocational education (SVE), but it has not yet been published. Therefore, we compared the findings of a Higher School of Economics (HSE) report on university graduates with available research on SVE. For this purpose, we used the results of a survey of over 11,000 students and 3,000 SVE graduates conducted as part of the Monitoring of Education Markets and Organizations (MEO) in 2020, as well as data from the Center for the Economics of Continuous Education at RANEPA and graduate employment statistics collected by Rosstat. The 2021 survey covered Russians who graduated from both universities and colleges between 2016 and 2020 and was conducted among 100,000 households across the country. These data provide a deeper understanding of the effectiveness of training specialists in the secondary vocational education system and their subsequent employment.
There are jobs for secondary vocational education graduates. What about salaries?
According to Rosstat, university graduates have slightly higher employment chances than graduates of secondary vocational educational institutions. However, the difference in employment rates between these groups is insignificant: as of 2021, 86.1% of secondary vocational education graduates found work, while among bachelor's degree holders, this figure was 87.7%. This indicates that secondary vocational education graduates are also successfully integrating into the labor market, providing employers with qualified specialists.
There are other assessment options.
- According to a survey conducted as part of the 2020 International Economic Review, 88% of secondary vocational education graduates were employed.
- According to the Graduate Employment Monitoring, presented by researchers from RANEPA at the conference "Secondary Vocational Education: Practice and Management" in February 2022, only 5% of 2019 graduates were unemployed within a year of graduation, and 11% of 2020 graduates.
In 2019, only 75% of graduates entered the labor market, which does not mean that the rest found work. Many of them continued their education, chose military service, or became childcare workers after becoming mothers. This highlights the diversity of paths young people take after completing their studies and the importance of supporting various life decisions.
According to Rosstat statistical data, approximately 38% of secondary vocational education (SVE) graduates do not attempt to find work immediately after graduation. Importantly, many of these graduates eventually find work, possibly receiving job offers before actively seeking vacancies. However, the proportion of those who do not participate in interviews after completing college remains significant. This phenomenon may indicate a variety of factors, including a lack of motivation, self-confidence, or insufficient knowledge of the labor market. Understanding the reasons for this phenomenon can help develop effective strategies to support graduates in their employment.
One of the main reasons students from secondary vocational education (SVE) continue their education is their desire to enroll in higher education. However, the scale of this phenomenon should not be exaggerated, as not all vocational school graduates continue their education at universities.
In the year they graduate from college or technical school, only a small proportion of graduates—just 12% in 2020—enroll in universities. Most choose to take a break before continuing their education. This time interval can be used to gain experience, work, or determine future career goals, which can subsequently positively impact the quality of higher education and professional training.
Entering a university is not a barrier to entering the labor market. Many graduates of secondary vocational educational institutions who continue their education at universities actively combine study with work. According to a survey conducted by the International Economic Society, 38% of students planned to work while studying. Alumni survey data confirms that such intentions are generally realized: 47% of secondary vocational education graduates from 2017–2019 continued their studies at a university in 2020 or successfully completed a shortened program. Moreover, 88% of all graduates were employed. This underscores the importance of combining education and work for students and their future careers. Higher education is not always accessible to everyone. Elena Polushkina, Deputy Director of the Center for Continuous Education Economics at RANEPA, noted at a webinar dedicated to monitoring graduate employment that many graduates of secondary vocational education in the northern, Siberian, and Far Eastern regions face economic barriers when entering universities. The problem lies not only in the cost of tuition, as state-funded places are available, but also in the significant geographical distance of educational institutions. This creates additional challenges for young people seeking higher education and improving their competitiveness in the labor market. Young people in some regions face high travel costs for exam sessions, making this event prohibitively expensive even once every six months. Relocating during studies is also financially burdensome. These circumstances force many to limit themselves to secondary education. For example, in 2017, only 6.9% of graduates of secondary vocational education programs in the Chukotka Autonomous Okrug were able to enroll in universities. In the Murmansk Region, this figure was 4.6%, and in the Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug, only 2.5%. These data highlight the need to address education accessibility and support for young people in these regions. According to the Monitoring of Education Economics, in 2020, the average salary among graduates of secondary vocational educational institutions was 23,200 rubles. Meanwhile, by comparison, bachelor's and master's degree graduates in 2021 had average incomes of 53,500 rubles for bachelor's degrees and 75,200 rubles for master's degrees. These data highlight the significant differences in income depending on educational level and can serve as an important guide for prospective students when choosing an educational path.
According to the Monitoring of Employment of Graduates of Secondary Vocational Educational Institutions, researchers from RANEPA, including Elena Polushkina and her team, presented the results in webinars for college staff. In 2018–2019, 54% of secondary vocational education graduates earned less than 25,000 rubles, while 46% earned more. Average salaries vary across federal districts but remain low. The highest average salary in the country was recorded in 2019 in the Far Eastern Federal District, at just over 33,000 rubles. These data highlight the need to improve the situation on the labor market for secondary vocational education graduates.

Going to university after college doesn't always lead to a significant increase in income. According to a recent study by the Higher School of Economics, based on data from the "Trajectories in Education and Profession" project, university graduates who received higher education after college have the lowest labor income among their peers. These results highlight the importance of choosing an educational path and its impact on career prospects and financial well-being.
Why does this happen? During their education, students often find only low-skilled jobs, and the experience they gain does not contribute to career advancement and salary increases. According to the Ministry of Economic Development, more than a third of students who work while studying are employed as general laborers. The reality is that a young person without experience can only count on low-paying work, such as as a courier. This creates a vicious circle where a lack of qualifications limits career opportunities, which subsequently affects income levels.
Research conducted by the Higher School of Economics, based on Rostrud monitoring data, confirms that work experience during studies significantly impacts the earnings of university graduates. Bachelor's degree holders who combined their studies with part-time work earn 29% more than their peers without work experience (61,600 rubles compared to 47,700 rubles). For master's degree holders, the income gap is even more significant – 48% (82,500 rubles versus 55,900 rubles). This underscores the importance of practical experience for students seeking a successful career and high earnings after graduation.
Long educational trajectories, such as the college-to-university path, may seem disadvantageous at first glance, but researchers from the Institute of Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences are confident that they represent the future of professional development. Modern reality shows that the traditional model of studying at a university for five years and then working in their field for life is outdated. In a dynamically changing labor market, work and study increasingly overlap. Education is becoming longer and occurs in parallel with entry into the labor market. Thus, combining study and professional activity is becoming the norm, opening up new opportunities for career advancement and skill development. At the recent Grushinsky Conference, sociologist Ekaterina Popova shared interesting observations about respondents' educational trajectories. She noted that those who had followed a multifaceted educational path were more likely to mention their proactivity in interviews. These respondents consciously chose secondary vocational education (SVE) and subsequently successfully completed their studies at universities. In contrast, many respondents with higher education admit that they entered universities immediately after school without a clear understanding of the need for this step. They didn't even always understand what kind of education they needed. These differences in approaches to choosing educational trajectories highlight the importance of informed choice in the modern educational process.
The long path "to university via college" often does not lead to significant income advantages immediately after graduation. However, such a trajectory is typical of more conscious and independent individuals who make informed decisions about their education and career. These students typically have a clear idea of their goals and are willing to invest time and effort in their development.
What helps and what hinders employment
Data on graduates of secondary vocational education (SVE) does not allow for a comprehensive analysis of the factors influencing their income. In the absence of materials from the Rostrud Employment Monitoring Survey for SVE, we can only assess employment success based on the percentage of graduates who were able to find work, especially in their professional field. This limitation complicates understanding the real state of the labor market and requires a more thorough study of the employment situation for secondary vocational education graduates. Statistical data on the relationship between work and specialty are provided by Rosstat. In 2021, the highest number of unemployed graduates who graduated between 2016 and 2020 were registered in the fields listed in the tables below. The information is presented in the context of two types of secondary vocational education: mid-level specialist programs and skilled worker programs. These data highlight the importance of choosing a profession and field of study, as well as their impact on graduate employment.


It is observed that fields with high unemployment among graduates include computer science and computer engineering, electronics, radio engineering, and communication systems. This raises questions about the quality of training in colleges and technical schools. Despite the fact that these fields are formally considered in demand, many graduates do not meet the demands of the labor market. A reassessment of curricula and teaching approaches is necessary so that educational institutions can prepare qualified specialists who will truly be in demand by employers.
A comparison of employment rates among graduates of mid-level specialist training programs shows that only 3.8% of graduates in the "Pharmacy" group were unemployed. At the same time, among graduates of blue-collar jobs, the best results are demonstrated by specialists in the field of "Mechanical Engineering", where the unemployment rate is just over 7%. These data highlight the high demand for qualified specialists in the pharmaceutical and mechanical engineering industries, making these fields attractive to prospective students.

The issue of employment in one's specialty is especially important for colleges, technical schools, and vocational schools. This is due to the fact that secondary vocational education is focused on practical training in a specific profession. Unlike higher education, which may have a broader range of goals, vocational educational institutions emphasize the necessary skills and knowledge in demand in the labor market. Thus, college and technical school graduates have a higher chance of finding work in their specialty, making their education more targeted and relevant.
A report from the Higher School of Economics, based on Rostrud monitoring materials, analyzes the distribution of university graduates across various industries. However, it is not possible to accurately determine whether graduates are employed in their field for all specialties. For example, a lawyer can find work in the information and communications sector, as well as in public administration or other sectors. For specialties with a more obvious connection to specific industries, the statistics look different. Specifically, only 15.4% of university graduates majoring in Agriculture and Agricultural Sciences are employed in agriculture, while 13.6% are employed in science. Meanwhile, 77% of medical graduates find employment in healthcare. This underscores the importance of choosing a field of study for their future career and confirms the need for more careful monitoring of graduate employment. Employment rates for graduates of secondary vocational education (SVE) remain low. According to the Ministry of Economic Education (MEE), 69% of SVE graduates find employment in their professional field immediately after completing their studies. However, one to two years after graduation, this figure drops to 56%. This demonstrates the need to improve training programs and increase demand for these specialties in the labor market.
According to Rosstat data, 61% of graduates of mid-level specialist training programs from 2016 to 2020 found employment in their field. For blue-collar jobs, this figure is even lower, at 57%. The table below presents the groups of specialties and professions in which more than 50% of graduates were not working in their field at the time of the 2021 survey. This highlights the pressing issue of the mismatch between the education they received and actual employment opportunities.

Graduates of secondary vocational education programs in healthcare most often find employment immediately after graduation. These specialists are in demand in the labor market thanks to the knowledge and skills they acquire, which allow them to effectively perform their duties in healthcare facilities. A significant number of graduates find positions as nurses, paramedics, and laboratory technicians, confirming the high level of training and demand for these professions. By continuing to develop their skills and competencies, such specialists can count on career advancement and additional opportunities in the healthcare sector.
- "Pharmacy" (95.7%),
- "Health Sciences and Preventive Medicine" (93.8),
- "Nursing" (93).
In the training program for blue-collar workers and employees, the highest employment rates in their specialty are demonstrated by the groups "Nursing" with a rate of 85% and "Economics and Management" with a result of 84%. These areas of education provide a high chance of successful employment, which emphasizes their relevance in today's labor market.
The reasons for employment outside their specialty are varied. A survey conducted by Rosstat among graduates of secondary vocational educational institutions and universities revealed several key factors. The main one is the lack of vacancies in their specialty, which was indicated by almost half of the respondents. Poor working conditions and low wages rank second. As a result, many graduates are reluctant to pursue careers in their field under these conditions, leading them to seek alternative employment. Poor working conditions are a major source of dissatisfaction among graduates of skilled trades programs. Statistics show that 24.1% of them experience this problem, compared to 16.8% of young mid-level professionals. The problem extends beyond living conditions; graduates with blue-collar jobs are more likely to receive job offers without formal contracts, with unofficial salaries and a lack of social guarantees. This creates additional challenges for entry-level professionals, hindering their adaptation to the labor market and worsening their overall quality of life. Research conducted by the Higher School of Economics confirms that employment rates for entry-level professionals are comparable to those of other graduates. However, entry-level workers often find themselves in unofficial employment or with short-term contracts. This highlights the need to improve the quality of labor relations and protect workers' rights in the labor market.
One reason why graduates are reluctant to work in their field of study is the wrong choice of profession. With the introduction of the Unified State Exam (USE), the number of teenagers transferring to secondary vocational educational institutions (SVE) after 9th grade has increased significantly. At the age of 15–16, teenagers often have less realistic ideas about their future profession than high school graduates, as confirmed by research from the Higher School of Economics (HSE). This increases the likelihood of random selection, and after a few years of study, SVE graduates may realize they are not interested in their field. Therefore, it is important to focus on career guidance and support for adolescents in choosing a life path to minimize the risk of making the wrong career choice.
According to a report by the Higher School of Economics on graduate employment, almost 40% of students who graduated in 2018 had moved by 2021. Recent data is unavailable for graduates of secondary vocational educational institutions, but a 2016 study by the Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration (RANEPA) found that the majority of young professionals move to Moscow to find work after graduating from college. This underscores the trend of youth migration in search of better career opportunities and higher salaries.
The share of employed graduates of secondary vocational education who moved to the capital varied from a few percent in some regions to 60% in others. Similar figures were observed in the Smolensk, Ryazan, and Kaluga regions, as well as in other regions of the Central Federal District. This indicates a significant influx of specialists to capital cities, which may be due to a search for higher salaries and better career opportunities.
The capital attracts many people, but the main problem is the mismatch between the specialties and professions offered by secondary vocational education institutions (SVE) and the demands of the local labor market. In most cases, recent high school graduates choose colleges in their own regions, preferring to study closer to home. This leads to them receiving degrees but being unable to find work in their field in their home regions. At the same time, other regions may experience a shortage of such specialists but are not training them. Thus, there is a clear imbalance between educational institutions and labor market needs, which requires attention and solutions.
Researchers at the Center for the Economics of Continuous Education analyzed in-demand professions in various regions of the country that require training at secondary vocational education institutions (SVE). They compared these professions with programs offered by local colleges. The results of the study were presented at the conference "Secondary Vocational Education: Practice and Management" and at webinars dedicated to Employment Monitoring. It was found that in some regions, colleges do not offer educational programs for more than half of the most in-demand professions, highlighting the need to update educational courses and programs to meet labor market demands.
High school graduates often continue their education at colleges and technical schools in their region. However, after receiving their diploma, they face difficulties in the labor market. Many of them take low-paying jobs that are not aligned with their specialization or decide to leave in search of better opportunities. This leads to the potential of young professionals being undervalued, and the regional economy is losing qualified personnel.
The problem of educational programs not meeting labor market demands is being addressed as part of a large-scale reform of secondary vocational education (SVE). Starting this year, a new level of education—professionalism—is being introduced, while the standards of existing programs are being updated. All changes are aimed at training specialists and workers more quickly and efficiently, taking into account the needs of the economy. The question of employers' readiness to offer salaries comparable to those of entry-level specialists with higher education remains open.
Please pay attention to the following materials:
- Employment prospects and salaries of college graduates have become known
- Will the demand for secondary vocational education programs grow in the current situation?
- What are the most popular areas of study in colleges?

