GameDev

Why Bethesda and Todd Howard's Dislike of Fallout: New Vegas Is Just an Internet Myth

Why Bethesda and Todd Howard's Dislike of Fallout: New Vegas Is Just an Internet Myth

Learn: Profession Game Designer from Scratch to PRO

Learn More

Following the release of the Fallout film adaptation, fans of the franchise have once again begun discussing Bethesda's attitude toward Obsidian's Fallout: New Vegas. The main reason is that many felt that the studio intentionally included elements in the series that contradict the game. However, Bethesda representatives confirmed that New Vegas is part of the universe's canon and no one is going to forget it. This underscores the game's importance in the context of the entire franchise and its influence on the development of events in the Fallout world.

There are other examples where players have felt tension between Bethesda and Obsidian. In this context, it is worth considering the various situations that fuel rumors about Bethesda Game Studios' dislike of Fallout: New Vegas. In fact, many believe that such notions are merely myths created online. We'll analyze these cases and explain why this opinion is unfounded, as well as reveal the true reasons for possible disagreements between studios.

Subscribe to our Checkpoint Telegram channel. Here you'll find interesting materials about the world of games, their development, and creation. We share useful tips from game development professionals and inform you about important updates to popular programs and tools. Comments are open for your suggestions and discussions related to the gaming industry. Join us and stay up to date with the latest news!

Why fans talk about "hate"

It's important to emphasize that Bethesda representatives have never spoken negatively about Fallout: New Vegas. Controversy about possible hostility towards the game arose from discussions regarding their collaboration in the late 2000s. These rumors often distort Bethesda's true attitude toward the project, which has been recognized as one of the best in the Fallout series.

In 2012, media reports surfaced that publisher Bethesda Softworks failed to pay Obsidian a cash bonus for the Metacritic rating of Fallout: New Vegas. According to the contract, the publisher was obligated to provide additional royalties if the game's average critic score was 85 or higher. However, the final score was 84, and the developers did not receive the expected bonus. This incident became a topic of discussion among fans and industry experts, highlighting the importance of ratings and their impact on developers' financial results.

Chris Avellone, who served as Obsidian's creative director at the time, shared an interesting story familiar to many fans. Many of them had long believed that Bethesda could have accommodated their colleagues, as they were only one point short of achieving the required score. This seems especially likely given that the final score could have been affected by numerous bugs in the game's release version, and Obsidian only had about 18 months to develop it. This situation highlights the challenging environment developers face and the importance of time in the game development process.

Screenshot: Fallout: New Vegas / Bethesda Softworks

In 2021, Avellone decided to clarify the situation surrounding the contract between Bethesda Softworks and Obsidian Entertainment. He noted that Bethesda itself proposed including a bonus for reaching 85 points in the agreement, although it was not obligatory. Avellone urged fans to refer to his words if they encounter allegations that Bethesda "mistreated" Obsidian. This statement emphasizes the transparency of the relationship between the companies and the importance of accurate perception of information in the gaming community.

The developer emphasized that Bethesda shouldn't be blamed for the bugs in the release version of New Vegas. He noted that Obsidian accepted the proposed deadlines, and therefore the team should have focused on improving the game's quality rather than adding new content. This focus on polishing could have significantly improved the overall quality of the game and player satisfaction.

Some fans have once again begun discussing Bethesda's attitude toward Obsidian's game after the release of Fallout 4. They express the opinion that the latest installment lacked references to New Vegas and too many to Fallout 3. As a reminder, the latest numbered games in the series were developed by Todd Howard's team at Bethesda Game Studios. This question is a source of debate among fans of the franchise and highlights the differences in the approach to game creation between Bethesda and Obsidian.

Screenshot: Fallout: New Vegas / Bethesda Softworks

Some argue that BGS's "dislike" of New Vegas stems from its superior quality compared to Fallout 3 and Fallout 4, particularly in terms of story. Players often cite various ratings in which New Vegas ranks higher than the third and fourth games in the series. These reviews emphasize the deep development of the story and characters, which makes New Vegas a unique game in the Fallout universe.

Discussions of Fallout 4 often raise objections from fans who prefer New Vegas. One of the main arguments is the limited number of references to New Vegas in Fallout 4. This can be explained by the fact that the games take place on different coasts of the United States. Residents of a post-apocalyptic world might not know about events that took place thousands of kilometers away, even if many years have passed since then.

Similar complaints about the minimum number of references were made about Fallout ShelterScreenshot: Fallout Shelter / Bethesda Softworks

Doubts about Bethesda's goodwill may arise, especially given Chris Avellone's comments. His statements highlight controversial aspects of the company's work and its approach to game development. This raises questions about how attentive Bethesda is to the opinions of players and critics.

In late 2023, it became known that after the release of Fallout: New Vegas, Obsidian Entertainment repeatedly proposed ideas for spin-offs for the Fallout and The Elder Scrolls series to Bethesda. However, all proposals were rejected. This gave the developers the impression that the publisher was dissatisfied with the audience reaction to New Vegas, which was the reason for abandoning other similar projects.

One person's feelings are not always direct evidence of a negative attitude. It is important to consider that the company's leaders may simply have not reached an understanding. Avellone himself noted communication difficulties at Obsidian, which was one of the reasons for his departure from the company in 2015.

There is no evidence of Bethesda's negative attitude towards the New Vegas game. At the same time, it is much easier to present evidence to the contrary.

Bethesda did not consider other developers for New Vegas

In 2022, Todd Howard said that Fallout: New Vegas was originally planned as a large-scale expansion to Fallout 3. The success of Fallout 3 exceeded all of Bethesda's expectations, and the developers began looking for ways to build on this success.

Todd Howard's team at that time was focused on the development of The Elder Scrolls 5: Skyrim, which did not allow them to be distracted by other projects. Nevertheless, the game designer emphasized the need to create a full-fledged game, and not just an expansion. This decision reflected a commitment to high quality and depth of gameplay, which was one of the reasons for Skyrim's success and continues to generate interest in the studio's future projects.

Todd Howard Photo: Matt Grandstaff / Wikimedia Commons

Bethesda has decided to hand over the development of the game New Vegas to another company, and the only suitable option for Obsidian Entertainment took over from Todd Howard. This decision was driven by the fact that Obsidian employed many former Black Isle Studios employees who had been directly involved in the creation of the original Fallout games. This collaboration gave New Vegas a unique atmosphere and continued the traditions of the classic franchise. Bethesda transferred all the work from the third game and its core concepts to their colleagues at Obsidian. After studying the engine, the team focused on developing the elements that made Fallout: New Vegas memorable. The focus was on the main story, factions, and non-linearity, creating a unique experience for players. Fallout: New Vegas has sold approximately 11.6 million copies over the years, slightly less than Fallout 3's 12.4 million. It's unlikely Bethesda's management held any ill will toward Obsidian, which developed a successful game in 18 months and helped fill the gap before the release of Skyrim. Fallout: New Vegas continues to be a significant installment in the franchise, highlighting the importance of collaboration between studios in the gaming industry.

Todd Howard Has Repeatedly Praised Obsidian

In recent years, Todd Howard has repeatedly expressed his admiration for his colleagues at Obsidian and the game Fallout: New Vegas. In 2019, he noted that Bethesda did not consider anyone other than Obsidian for the development of the project, despite numerous offers from other studios. In 2021, during a conversation with fans on Reddit, Howard again praised New Vegas, emphasizing that it was an excellent game and that he was a big fan of Obsidian, where many of his friends work.

The game designer shared his opinion on Fallout: New Vegas in late April 2024. He emphasized the significance of this game for both Bethesda and its loyal fans. The game designer also noted Obsidian's outstanding work in creating Fallout and other well-known projects, which underlines their high level of skill in the gaming industry.

BGS Production Director Ashley Chen praised the studio's work on the Obsidian game. He noted that the team had done a significant amount of work, especially considering that New Vegas was developed almost without the participation of Howard's team. Chen emphasized that the game itself is an outstanding achievement in the world of video games.

The Fallout series contains many references to New Vegas

The recent film adaptation from Amazon is clear confirmation that Bethesda does not intend to exclude New Vegas from the canon of the series. The series contains numerous references to the game, including the recognizable soundtrack, the NCR ranger armor, the organization's flag, and even New Vegas itself, which appears in the final scene of the season. These elements not only emphasize the connection to the original but also heighten the interest of viewers familiar with the Fallout world.

The series has raised doubts regarding the timeline of the Fallout universe. One episode mentions that the city of Shady Sands was destroyed in 2277, which contradicts the events of the game New Vegas. However, the developers quickly clarified the situation, specifying that the nuclear bomb was dropped on the city after the events of the game, and the game itself will remain part of the canon.

Rework the text so that it meets SEO requirements and stays on-topic. Don't add anything unnecessary and avoid using emojis or extra characters. Make sure the text is clear and informative, and considers keywords to improve search engine visibility.

Read also:

Fallout Series: Key Easter Eggs and Plot Explained

The Fallout series attracts attention not only with its fascinating plot, but also with a multitude of Easter eggs referencing the game and its universe. In this text, we will look at the most interesting moments and explain their meaning.

Firstly, it is worth noting that the series maintains the atmosphere of a post-apocalyptic world in which various factions and characters coexist. The main events unfold in a world inhabited by mutants and survivors of a nuclear war. Each episode is filled with references to iconic elements of the game, such as the Pip-Boy, Nuka-Cola, and various factions.

Special attention should be paid to the characters, who were inspired by iconic heroes from the games. Their development and interactions highlight the core themes of the Fallout universe, such as the struggle for survival and moral dilemmas. Viewers can see how the series explores the consequences of nuclear war, which adds depth to the plot.

Equally important are the hidden references to various locations and events from the games, which true fans of the series will recognize. These details create a sense of continuity and connection between the series and the games.

Thus, the Fallout series is a fascinating continuation of the well-known universe, offering viewers not only an interesting plot but also many Easter eggs that enrich the viewing experience.

In the second season of Fallout, New Vegas will likely be a key location. The showrunners confirmed that it would be illogical to mention this city and then move the plot to New York. The development of events in New Vegas will allow for a deeper exploration of the atmosphere and features of the post-apocalyptic world, as well as attract fans of the original game. The location is expected to be rich in detail and familiar elements, creating a unique experience for viewers.

The creators of New Vegas do not plan to establish a canonical ending, as they are confident that the game's world continues to evolve. They believe that events may occur in the city at any time, corresponding to various plot twists. This way, each player can perceive the ending in their own way, which adds depth and variety to the gameplay.

Todd Howard shares this opinion. In a recent interview, he confirmed that New Vegas will be featured in the second season. Howard also noted that he does not intend to choose a canonical ending for the game for the series. He believes it is important that no fan feels left out, so special care will be taken with the game's plot and endings.

From the comments, it is clear that the creators of the series intend to strengthen the connection with New Vegas, rather than ignore it. Given that Todd Howard is one of the producers of the project, it is safe to assume that all important decisions will be agreed upon with him. This emphasizes the importance of the original material and the possibility of its integration into the new story, which may appeal to both fans of the series and fans of the game.

In recent weeks, there has been a perception among fans that there is no animosity between Bethesda and Obsidian. Fans point to the fact that Bethesda continues to actively release New Vegas merchandise, which indicates a positive relationship between the companies.

The myth of rivalry between Fallout game fans may have arisen due to different preferences among players. Some people enjoy building settlements in Fallout 4, while others prefer exploring storylines and interacting with factions in New Vegas. This diversity of interests highlights that different aspects of the game can appeal to different people, and it's not always possible to reach a consensus. It's important to respect each player's preferences and understand that each installment in the franchise has its own unique strengths that can be appreciated differently.

It's difficult to say exactly what Todd Howard and his team think of New Vegas. However, based on the arguments presented, it is unlikely that we can talk about feelings of "contempt" or "hatred" towards this project.

Game designer profession from scratch to PRO

A game designer creates the structure of the game. They develop the idea, rules, and gameplay, and decide what emotions the story will evoke in players. You'll master the principles of game design from scratch and learn how to work with popular engines like Unity and Unreal Engine. You'll learn how to keep players engaged and monetize games. And we'll help you start a career in the gaming industry.

Learn more